Facilitating uptake of resilience-enhancing technologies with stochastic benefits by subsidizing learning

How to cite

Malacarne, Jonathan; Boucher, Stephen; Popat, Meizal; Manuel, Lourenço. 2022. "Facilitating uptake of resilience-enhancing technologies with stochastic benefits by subsidizing learning." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009950. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9950-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Jonathan Malacarne* , Stephen Boucher , Meizal Popat , Lourenço Manuel

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009950
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9950-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2022-09-05 – 2026-09-04
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9950

Abstract

Emerging evidence suggests that bundling drought tolerant maize (DTM) and satellite-based index insurance (II) can foster resilience: the combined product not only helps farm households withstand shocks but allows them to deepen their investment in the wake of events that might otherwise prove crippling. These benefits, however, do not manifest themselves in all states of the world. The stochastic return on investment makes learning the value of the product challenging. This can delay the levels of sustained adoption necessary to generate large scale resilience. In this project, we will use a multi-armed randomized control trial to study subsidies to learning “through education” and “through experimentation”. Subsidy programs will be provided for two years and removed before the project’s final year. Removal of the subsidy will allow for a study of sustained adoption, both as it relates to the treatments and to the weather realizations experienced by households during the subsidy period. The project will generate additional evidence on the impact of DTM and II on maize yields, agricultural investment, and food security and builds on recent work by MRR Innovation Lab researchers and private sector partners, which led to the launch of Mozambique’s first commercial bundle of II and DTM.

Intervention

The proposed project will conduct a randomized control trial of two subsidy programs seeking to promote sustained adoption of a drought tolerant maize (DTM) and index insurance (II) bundle. The first program will be a voucher-based subsidy, reducing the cost of investing in the bundle to promote households’ experiential “learning through experimentation”. The second program will subsidize “learning through education” by providing participatory, community-based training sessions. The sessions, based on the agricultural extension model, will be designed to highlight the biological insurance inherent to DTM and the complementary protection offered by II. Experiential games – programmed for Android devices – will also be developed that allow households to “experience” many years’ worth of investment decisions, weather realizations, and returns on investment in a short, low stakes, training session.

Experimental design

The treatments will be randomized at the community level according to a two-by-two factorial design, with the subsidy programs provided for two years and removed before the project’s final year. The factorial design will allow the researchers to identify the effects of each treatment component separately, as well as identify any complementarity/substitution effects among the subsidy programs. The removal of the subsidy prior to the project’s final year will allow for a study of sustained adoption.

In addition to the randomization provided by the research design, farm households will have their learning opportunities further randomized by nature. The spatial distribution of the study communities will be maximized in order to increase the chances that some households experience weather realizations that highlight the benefits of drought tolerant maize and index insurance – reinforcing the educational interventions – while other households experience weather realizations that obfuscate the benefits.

Design details

Randomization method
Cluster and individual level randomization will be conducted remotely by the PIs using computer software.
Randomization unit
Voucher and community-level education treatments will be randomized at the community level. Within voucher communities, the level of subsidy will be randomized at the individual level. Within education communities, participation in a tablet-based educational game will be randomized at the individual level. Within all communities, the framing of some survey questions will be randomized at the individual level.
Clusters
80 communities
Observations
1120 maize farmers
Arms
20 villages control, 20 villages education, 20 villages subsidy, 20 villages education and subsidy
Primary outcomes
Area planted in maize, area planted in other staple crops, area planted in cash crops, agricultural investment in maize production, maize yields, food security status, household beliefs about the advantages of DTM relative to conventional improved maize varieties

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords