Contract Enforcement in a Stateless Economy
How to cite
Mehmood, Sultan; Chen, Daniel. 2022. "Contract Enforcement in a Stateless Economy." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009926. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9926-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In this paper, we study contract enforcement in the illegal gambling market of Pakistan as gamblers make high-stakes betting decisions without the state enforcing contracts. Our experimental intervention randomly assigns gamblers into four different contracts: (i) the most common, status quo contract that stipulates spot betting with the pay back the week after (ii) Blacklisting contract that imposes a local or global reputational cost in case of nonpayment (iii) Payment deadline extension treatment that provides a week’s extension to pay back the lost money i.e. pay back deadline in 14 days instead of 7 days; Finally, a (iv) decision aid group where we do not offer any contract but accept the status-quo 7 day pay back contract if the bettor explicitly requests this contract, within this treatment arm, the gambler also receives a decision aid notebook containing odds and historical data relevant to the bet. We pre-register three field outcomes and four strategic dilemmas. The field measures include (a) amount bet, (b) won and lost amount (c) payback amount. The behavioral data are collected for the following for games: (a) risk, (b) confidence, (c) cooperation and (d) coordination.
Intervention
Intervention(s)
Treatment 1: Give an opportunity to sign a book bet contract with the gambler with additional time to payback (2 weeks to payback relative to status quo of one week repayment in the standard book bet contract)
Treatment 2: Blacklisting Clause embedded within the status quo book bet contract of payment in case of non-payment. The gamblers within this greatment are further cross-randomized into:
T2a: Global Black Listing: the global blacklisting contract stipulates listing names of the gamblers on the notice board of the betting station upon nonpayment and notifying all betting stations about the gambler’s “default”, effectively banning the gambler from all eight betting stations at the race club
T2b: Local Blacklisting: the local blacklisting contract that also lists names of the gamblers on the notice board in case of non payment, as before, but we do not notify other stations at the race club.
Conceptionally, the difference in global and local blacklisting is that the local blacklisting imposes a reputional cost but the potential sanction is limited to one betting stand at the race club, allowing the gambler to bet freely at other stations.
Treatment 3: The third group of gamblers is assigned the standard or most common bookbet contract (payment deadline in 14 versus 7 days).
Placebo or Decision Aid Group: The last group is not explicitly assigned any contract but instead offered a decision aid i.e., a notebook with odds on each horse race and historical data relevant to the bet. This group is also allowed to engage in a status quo 7 day payback deadline booklet but we will not explicitly offer any contract to them
Experimental design
We will randomly allocate 12000 gamblers at the Lahore Race Derby into four groups of 3000 gamblers each:
T1: Give an opportunity to sign a book bet contract with the gambler with additional time to payback (2 weeks to payback relative to status quo of one week repayment standard book bet contract)
T2: Blacklisting Clause embedded within the status quo book bet contract of payment the week after. The mechanism underpinning the blacklisting is evaluated via a factorial design:
T2a: Global Blacklisting Imposed via making the "defaulters" public
T2b: Local Blacklisting by informing the Race Club Guild.
Treatment 3: Provide for free a decision aid containing odds and historical data relevant to bet embedded within the "handicap" decision aid and opportunity to sign standard book bet contract with payback 7 days later.
Placebo or Control: This status quo group is not explicitly assigned any contract but instead offered a decision aid i.e., a notebook with odds on each horse race and historical data relevant to the bet. This group is also allowed to engage in a status quo 7 day payback deadline booklet but we will not explicitly offer any contract to them
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.