Effectiveness of Educational Module of Autism Spectrum Disorder (EMASD) in Identifying Children with ASD among preschool teachers

How to cite

taresh, sahar. 2022. "Effectiveness of Educational Module of Autism Spectrum Disorder (EMASD) in Identifying Children with ASD among preschool teachers." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009925. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9925-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

sahar taresh*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009925
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9925-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Withdrawn
Trial dates
2019-07-01 – 2019-09-28
Countries
Yemen (Taiz )
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9925

Abstract

Introduction: There is consensus that the main system for ASD identification relies on the preschool teacher. they have the chance to referrals of suspicious children with ASD to specialists. However, there is little literature is available on preschool teachers' ability or perception for this role. The main objective of this study is to evaluate the feasibility and acceptability of an educational module to identify children with ASD (EMASD). Also, to assess the effectivness of the EMASD on improving preschool teacher’s ability to identify children with ASD in a normal school.
Method and Analysis: This pilot study will examine the feasibility of the randomised controlled trial (RCT) using EMASD as an intervention. The intervention will be ten weekly group-based sessions designed to improve the knowledge, belief, identification skills, and self-efficacy to identify children with ASD among Yemeni preschool teachers. The feasibility will be determined based on the effectiveness as measured by questionnaires and open-ended questions. General linear measurement (GLM) will be used to compare between the two groups and within the group whereas thematic analysis will be used for qualitative data.
Ethics and Dissemination: This study conforms to the principles of the Declaration and Research Ethics Committee at University Putra Malaysia (UPM), with a reference number of UPM\TNCPI\RMC\JKEUPM\1.4.18.2 (JKEUPM). (STUDY PROTOCOL PROOFS 2).

Intervention

EMASD can be used to help preschool teachers identifying children suspected with ASD in normal schools. Therefore, the educational sessions in EMASD are designed based on the ADDIE model and two main theories, namely the Social Cognitive Theory (SCT) in triadic reciprocal determination (behavioural, personal, and environmental factors) and the Health Belief Module (HBM) to change the preschool teachers’ belief towards ASD. Both theories are used to indicates the methods to dispel misbeliefs surrounding ASD. Furthermore, EMASD is also developed based on the ADDIE (Analysis-Design-Development-Implement-Evaluation) model (Supplementary file 2). Walter Dick (48) emphasised that any instructional design requires the use of a system to analyse the problems and identify learning objectives before a strategic plan can be established to solve teaching problems, test solutions, evaluate the results and revise the programme. Among the many systematic instructional design models available in the literature, the ADDIE model is the commonly used model. For more details of the theoretical framework development, please see 10.3390/brainsci10030165.
The EMASD consists of 10 sessions that cover different aspects including i. Cognitive (Knowledge: Definition based on DSM5, symptoms, types, causes, prevalence, and the difference between ASD symptoms and other disorders); ii. Beliefs (Emotional: Social misbelief, religious belief, and the correction of the belief about ASD); iii. Identification skills (Motor-behaviour: report writing, observation, and recording skills; iv. Self-efficacy (Emotional: Preschool teachers’ responsibility in the identification of ASD and discussion with parents regarding the referral decision). Table 1 outlines the components in EMASD.
The EG will consist of four groups with approximately 10 to 20 teachers respectively. The intervention module will be organised based on the agreement and consensus of the participants. The session will be arranged flexibly based on the schedules of the participants. In addition, a two-hour booster session will be provided to reinforce the intervention and for the participants to discuss further issues related to ASD that will promote further referral services.
Furthermore, the intervention will include activities such as group discussions, brainstorming, short video viewing, exercises, and sharing of teachers' and parents' experiences to enhance early detection and referral. Besides, the intervention will also be outlined in two booklets for trainers and teachers. The intervention will be performed by the first author with the support of the school counsellor. During the intervention period, a WhatsApp group that contains only the EG participants will be created to support the intervention and to boost retention rates. The group will be moderated by the lead facilitator. To further enhance the retention rates, weekly reminders will be sent via private messaging to the EG participants.

Experimental design

The current study is a convergent parallel mixed study to evaluate the influence of the EMASD by applying both qualitative and quantitative methods to enrich the study findings. The parallel randomised controlled trial (P-RCT) compared changes in outcomes of interest among preschool teachers allocated to the EMASD experimental group against preschool teachers allocated to a control group (no intervention). The data collection involved obtaining quantitative data via questionnaire and qualitative data via open-ended questions. The quantitative and qualitative data findings was examined separately before contributing to the final interpretation.
The current study was based in the province of Taiz, Yemen. There were 125 government schools and 230 private schools in the province. Preschool teachers from these schools is recruited. The study was promoted on the Teachers' Qualification Training Course website of the Ministry of Education. The principals of all the schools was also be contacted formally via emails to obtain their approvals. Before the pre-test assessment, all the participants must provide informed consent digitally.
2.2.1. Selection Criteria
The sampling unit of this study is a teacher randomly selected from the schools in Taiz based on the following inclusion and exclusion criteria:
Inclusion Criteria
The inclusion criteria for schools and teachers were:
i. School should be kindergarten, preschool, or primary schools.
ii. Schools located in Taiz.
iii. Schools that agree to participate in the study.
iv. Teachers who are teaching at the kindergarten, preschool, or primary stage.
vi. Teachers aged 20-40 years old.
vii. Teachers who sign a consent form to participate in the study.
viii. Teachers with at least a high school level of education.
Exclusion Criteria
The exclusion criteria are:
i. School location is not in Taiz.
ii. Elementary and high schools.
iii. Teachers who will retire during the study period.
iv. Teachers who teach in elementary and high schools.
v. Teachers with lower than high school education levels.
After completing the pre-test assessment, all participants who are qualified to participate were stratified depending on their position and score to ensure a balance between the EG and CG. An impartial researcher is randomly assign participants to either EG or CG using computer-generated allocation, i.e. JavaScript's Math Random Number Generator (hedges.name) (47). As the EMASD intervention will be provided by the researchers, double-blinding of group allocation is not possible. Figure 2 depicts the recruitment procedure. To ensure allocation concealment, each cluster was receive a randomly generated treatment allocation unique code within a serially numbered sealed opaque envelope. The research assistant distributes the sealed opaque envelopes to all the participating schools. Later, the participants was open the envelopes and be assigned to EG or CG according to their unique codes. The software was also categorise EG and CG based on the list of codes. Finally, an equal number of participants was assigned to the EG and CG. Participants in the CG was continue with the standard teaching qualification course at the Ministry of Education. To assess potential preliminary differences between the two groups, measurements will be performed at Week 10 after the intervention period and again, four weeks after the post-test. Following the study completion, the participants in the CG was also receive an information pack on the relevant information and activities related to EMASD.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization control trial
Randomization unit
preschool teachers
Clusters
12 schools 120 participants 60 for experimental group
Observations
not more than 15 teachers in one group
Arms
20 preschool teacher 12 schools
Primary outcomes
increase Preschool Teachers’ Knowledge of ASD change Preschool Teachers’ belief of ASD enhance preschool teachers self efficacy to identify children with ASD
Secondary outcomes
enhance preschool teacher ability to identify children with ASD

Papers from this trial

  1. Sahar Mohammed Taresh, Nor Aniza Ahmad, Samsilah Roslan et al. Effectiveness of Educational Module of Autism Spectrum Disorder (EMASD) in Identifying Children with ASD among preschool teachers: A Study Protocol for Parallel Cluster-Randomized Controlled Trial feasibility study, 29 September 2021, PREPRINT (Version 1) available at Research Square [https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-923156/v1] https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-923156/v1

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords