Employer Preferences for Local vs. Non-Local Workers: A Resume Audit
How to cite
Orr, Ashley; Kovak, Brian; Taylor, Lowell. 2023. "Employer Preferences for Local vs. Non-Local Workers: A Resume Audit." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009904. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9904-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
There is significant and persistent heterogeneity in unemployment rates and labor earnings across labor markets in the US, contributing to overall economic inequality. Developments since the 1990s indicate that migration has declined even as job posting websites have expanded access to and awareness of employment opportunities beyond a worker’s location of origin. This project explores the importance of workers' geographic location when applying to online job postings to proxy for access to job opportunities for job seekers who are local and non-local. We examine how job applicant characteristics, specifically a worker's current location, implied gender, and implied career stage/age affect employer contact/callback rates across several occupations and cities in the USA. Methodologically, this study conducts a resume correspondence experiment, randomly assigning the resumes of fictitious candidates with different geographical locations to employers who are actively seeking employees to determine if employers' have a location preference for their new hires. We also address potential mechanisms for why employers may prefer local applicants and engage in place-based discrimination.
Intervention
We systematically vary the distance between a fictitious job applicant and the labor market the applicant searches for jobs in.
Experimental design
In this resume audit, we consider the effect of the distance between fictitious applicants and job opportunities on the likelihood the employer contacts the applicant back for an interview for the job.
To do this we randomly selected residential addresses in random mid-large US cities (more than 100,000 people) and then randomly select zip codes for the fictitious applicants to apply for jobs in within three distance categories- local/close, local/far commutes, and non-local/requires migration. Our resumes were randomly constructed using the text randomizer from Lahey and Beasley (2009) and our fictitious applicants include randomly selected names which are implied female and implied male from younger and middle aged birth generations in the USA. We consider several occupational titles/job titles and several US cities.
With the assistance of a team of research assistants, we apply to open job postings available on publically available job boards, recording the date, time, and the text from the job posting. We then will monitor the fictitious candidates' email inboxes, voicemail boxes, job site direct message chats, and text messages and record which employers contact them for an interview.
We seek to compare callback rates for candidates by distance, gender, gender and distance, career stage cohort, career stage cohort and gender, and, if possible, age cohort, gender, and distance.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.