Narratives about and Support for Economic Institutions
How to cite
Schlepper, Marcel; Potrafke, Niklas; Wochner, Timo; Heil, Philipp; Necker, Sarah; Blesse, Sebastian; Gründler, Klaus. 2022. "Narratives about and Support for Economic Institutions." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009883. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9883-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In recent years, democracies on the globe are facing the challenge of eroding support for established economic institutions. In Europe, most democracies have adopted some form of social market economy (SME), which balances between economic efficiency and the redistribution of resources. While the SME is often used as a popular phrase in political rhetoric, general knowledge about the attributes of the SME in the general population is low. In this paper, we examine whether limited knowledge contributes to declining support for economic institutions. We first elicit individuals' narratives about the SME to identify perceptions and misperceptions about the SME. We then design a randomized controlled trial in which a random subset of participants receives information about the construction of the SME. Our treatments also differentiate between general information and variants that put greater emphasis on either market aspects or social aspects of the SME. Our RCT explores whether correcting erroneous beliefs about the SME increases individuals’ support for economic institutions. The survey is conducted in Germany, which provides an ideal laboratory to study our research question, given that it is not only the largest European economy but also has a strong historical connection to the SME. Our analysis provides important implications for policy design. If declining support for existing institutions is driven by a lack of information, then trust may be restored simply via the provision of information.
Intervention
We provide survey participants with an explanation of the SME according to the economist Müller-Armack who contributed heavily to its conceptualization and implementation in post-war Germany. Survey participants are split into three treatment groups and a control group. The information treatments include a definition of the SME which highlights the duality of economic and social elements. The first group receives an additional explanation of the economic elements, e.g. touching upon competition and growth. The second group receives an additional explanation of the social elements, e.g. touching upon income redistribution and social support programs. The third group receives both additional explanations.
Experimental design
A subgroup of survey participants receives an information treatment. This information treatment provides an explanation of the SME allowing participants to update their knowledge and adjust their beliefs. As we expect knowledge on the SME to be low in the general population, we test whether information provision has an impact on the level of support for the SME. As allocation to a treatment group is random, a comparison with a control group will serve as a valid comparison to establish the causal effect of information provision.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.