Cambia, ¿todo cambia? The role of perceived social mobility on protests and migration in Latin America

How to cite

Marino, Maria; Donni, Paolo Li; Ramos, Xavier; Turati, Riccardo. 2022. "Cambia, ¿todo cambia? The role of perceived social mobility on protests and migration in Latin America." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009835. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9835-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Maria Marino* , Paolo Li Donni , Xavier Ramos , Riccardo Turati

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009835
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9835-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2022-08-01 – 2023-02-28
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9835

Abstract

Although income inequality in Latin America has decreased in the last decades, the region remains the most unequal in the world. When looking at one of the most harmful types of inequality, social mobility, the picture is even gloomier.
According to the predictions of standard political economy models, people should react to low (expected) social mobility by demanding more redistributive policies. Nevertheless, broken social ladders have not led to more demand for redistribution as these models anticipated.

According to some scholars, a possible explanation is that people misperceive social mobility in their country. Nevertheless, while misperceptions are often found, a growing literature shows that their correction does not necessarily lead to more redistribution.

Only few studies have however tested the role of perceptions of social mobility in developing countries. Additionally, not much has been done to investigate if people react to (perceived) inequalities with other behaviors rather than asking for more redistribution. For instance, Hirschman (1970) contends that individuals have three choices when dissatisfied: voicing their discontent to change the situation, while continuing as a member, exiting the organization, or remaining loyal. Protests (voice) and emigration (exit) are thus alternative actions individuals can take when they are profoundly dissatisfied. Scant evidence for the Hirschman’s framework is however provided for developing countries and, more specifically, for Latin-American countries that have been historically strongly characterized by massive protests and emigration flow.

Our research contributes to the literature by examining the relation between perception of social mobility, preferences for redistribution, protest, and migration intentions in a unified framework. We provide novel observational and experimental evidence in Mexico of the effect of perceived social mobility: the latter might not only affect preferences for redistribution but also intentions (or decision) to change the status quo, by either emigrating or protesting.

Our research contributes to the literature by examining for the first time the relation between perception of inequalities, preferences for redistribution, protest, and migration intentions in a unified framework. In particular, we provide novel observational and experimental evidence in Latin America of the effect of individual perceived social mobility: the latter might not only affect preferences for redistribution but also intentions (or decision) to change the status quo, by either emigrating or protesting.

Intervention

We run an online survey in Mexico. We recruit participants through a professional survey company to ensure that our sample is representative of the country's population along key dimensions - gender, region, and age. To be eligible, subjects must be adults (age 18+) and must be citizens of the country. The surveys will be performed online or on phone.

Experimental design

Some respondents are assigned to a treatment while others to a control group. The treated group is provided information on social mobility.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization is done by the survey company.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
1
Observations
1400 respondents
Arms
While the pilot is done with 400 respondents (4 groups to pre-test different framing of the treatment), in the main study, we will have 700 respondents for the control group, and around 700 respondent for the treatment group.
Primary outcomes
Support for redistribution, intention to migrate and to protest. Two behavioral measures (donation and wtp for information).
Secondary outcomes
We are also interested in the heterogeneity of the background characteristics of respondents and will thus look at outcomes by sub-groups as defined by past experiences of social mobility, trust in institutions, income, political ideology, past experience of protest and migration, perceptions of fairness. We will also test for several alternative mechanisms (feelings, political and economic discontent, perceptions of fairness)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords