Migrant's Integration and Voting Behavior

How to cite

Quintana, Alejandra; Rozo, Sandra. 2022. "Migrant's Integration and Voting Behavior." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009806. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9806-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Alejandra Quintana* , Sandra Rozo

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009806
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9806-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2022-08-01 – 2022-10-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D72, F02, F22, O15, R23
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9806

Abstract

The alarming magnitude of forced migrant flows, which reached at least 84 million people by mid-2021, has opened a strong debate on how to effectively support displaced populations. Often times host government decisions are based on popular beliefs about the possible impacts of refugee’s economic integration. For example, politicians who observe the sharp increments in xenophobia and resentment towards migrants from the general public could be frightened that the electorate will punish them and their parties if they have a political platform that is more favorable towards migrants.This research project aims to inform this debate by examining the effects of a large-scale regularization program, the Permiso Especial de Permanencia (PEP), which granted working rights and access to safety nets to nearly 281,000 Venezuelan refugees in Colombia in August 2018.

For this purpose, mayoral electoral results are compared between municipalities with higher and lower program take-up rates, before and after the program roll-out in 2018. The regularization had negligible impacts in electoral outcomes, attitudes towards migrants. Mover over, since PEP is a national policy, we found empirical evidence that supports that the electorate did not change their political behavior in the presidential elections. The analysis is also enriched by exploiting the Survey of Political Culture -a unique and novel survey collected in 2019- by the Dane, the Colombian statistics agency, in order to characterize attitudes towards migrants and prosocial behaviors in Colombia. Given there is only one wave of the survey, the data only enabled the exploration of correlations between the PEP program take-up rates and social capital outcomes. The analysis, of this data, confirms that the correlation between the PEP take-up rates and social capital outcomes as well as attitudes towards migrants is close to zero.

How can local communities show no response to the regularization program in their voting behaviors, attitudes towards migrants, and prosocial behaviors? There are multiple potential explanations. For example, it is possible that voters do not follow closely the policies that regulate refugee’s labor rights. In fact, internet searches of residence and work permits granted by the Colombian government to Venezuelan refugees are search terms that Colombians do not use often (Santamaria, 2020). It is also feasible that the effect of immigration on Colombians voting behaviors is predominantly driven by voter’s concern on the overall economic impacts of migrants when they first arrive, as shown by Rozo and Vargas (2021), but not by subsequent policies that support them. If this is the case, voters will not be concerned about the effects of those refugees who are already in Colombia and changed their labor right status with the regularization program.

To test the mechanisms behind the negligible effects of the PEP program, we survey 1040 Colombian adults residents of Bogotá on their knowledge of the regularization pro- gram, voting behaviors and attitudes toward the refugee population. The survey will also include Survey-experiment to assess the effect of having information on the PEP program: half of the individuals will be randomly allocated to an information experiment in which they will be informed about the PEP regularization program and subsequently we will monitor the effects of receiving these information on their voting intentions and attitudes towards Venezuelan outcomes.

Intervention

We will collect a sample that is representative of Colombian adults in Bogota. Especially, we will interview around 1040 residents of Bogotá, who are Colombian born citizens and who were over 18 years old in 2019, on their knowledge of the regularization program, voting behavior, social capital and attitudes towards the migrant population.

Experimental design

Half of respondents will be randomly allocated to an information experiments in which they will be informed about the regularization program of Venezuelan migrants in Colombia. On one hand the treatment group will be given a brochure with facts on how many Venezuelan have been displaced from their country and how many lived in Colombia, how many of them are recipients of the PEP regularization program, and the benefits they have. On the other hand, the control group will be given a brochure informing ONLY how many Venezuelan have been displaced from their country and how many lived in Colombia.

Design details

Randomization method
We will use the "negative coordinate" algorithm, one of the most commonly used algorithms for selecting a simple random sample of statistical units. We will follow the following steps: (a) to each sample unit assign a random number between "0" and "1" (b) set the random values generated. (c) sort the units in ascending order according to the number generated within each stratum. (d) In each stratum take the first "n" units, where "n" is the sample size assigned to that stratum.
Randomization unit
Individuals
Clusters
Sample of Colombian adults residents of Bogota, who were over 18 years old in 2019. A presentative sample of 1040 people is contemplated, representative for three socioeconomic level (low, middle, and high) and for two age groups (22 to 30 years old and 31 years old and older). The survey will include a survey-experiment to assess the effect of having information on the PEP program: half of respondents will be randomly allocated to an information experiments in which they will be informed about the regularization program of Venezuelan migrants in Colombia
Observations
1040 individuals
Arms
520 individuals control and 520 individuals in treatment. Both groups will be sub-divided into three socio-economic stratums (173 individual of low, 173 of middle, and 174 of high income households) and two age groups (260 people 22 to 30 years old and 260 people 31 years old and older).
Primary outcomes
First, the survey will give us statistic evidence that support if Colombians are aware and have knowledge of the government's migratory regulation. Voting intentions, positive and negative reciprocity, attitudes towards migrants, and Political attitudes towards migrants’ integration policies

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords