Community Choice Demonstration

How to cite

Gubits, Daniel; Cunningham, Mary; Lubell, Jeffrey; Paulen, Laura. 2022. "Community Choice Demonstration." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009805. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9805-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Daniel Gubits* , Mary Cunningham , Jeffrey Lubell , Laura Paulen

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009805
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9805-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2022-08-01 – 2027-12-31
Countries
United States of America (Los Angeles Metro, CA), United States of America (New Orleans, LA), United States of America (Minneapolis and Anoka, Carver, and suburban Hennepin and Ramsey Counties, MN), United States of America (New York, NY), United States of America (Rochester, NY), United States of America (Cuyahoga County (including Cleveland), OH), United States of America (Chester City and Chester County, PA), United States of America (Pittsburgh and Allegheny County, PA), United States of America (Davidson County (including Nashville), TN)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9805

Abstract

This multisite randomized controlled trial will evaluate the effects of the $50 million Community Choice Demonstration (Demonstration) that Congress funded to expand the residential choices of families with children and help them access lower-poverty areas. Through a competitive selection process, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development has selected nine sites across the United States to participate in the Demonstration, three of which represent a partnership between two neighboring public housing agencies. The 12 public housing agencies that are participating in the Demonstration and their partners are expected to offer mobility-related services to more than 10,000 families with children participating in the Housing Choice Voucher program over a four-and-a-half-year period beginning in August 2022. Mobility-related services consist of coaching, financial assistance and other supports to help families access specifically designated “opportunity areas.”

Applying a mix of qualitative methods and a randomized controlled trial, an Evaluation Team led by Abt Associates, in partnership with the Urban Institute and supported by evaluation partners, outside consultants, and an expert panel, will study the effectiveness of mobility-related services in facilitating moves to and retention in opportunity areas. In addition to generating actionable knowledge about the effectiveness of providing mobility-related services in a range of different cities and counties, the study will lay the groundwork for future long-term follow-up to assess the effects of being offered mobility-related services on the health and educational outcomes and economic mobility of children and their families.

Intervention

The Community Choice Demonstration (Demonstration) is a multi-site randomized controlled trial that will study the effects of two interventions. The first intervention, Comprehensive Mobility-Related Services (CMRS), will provide a comprehensive set of services that aims to address all of the principal obstacles that HCV participants experience accessing lower-poverty areas, including financial barriers, knowledge and skill gaps, hesitancy on the part of families to move to opportunity areas, hesitancy on the part of property owners in opportunity areas to participate in the HCV program, and challenges that affect families’ ability to stay in opportunity areas once there. The second intervention, Selected Mobility-Related Services (SMRS), will test up to three bundles of services selected from the broader CMRS to determine whether they can effectively assist families in accessing opportunity areas at a lower cost.

The term “Community Choice Demonstration” is the new name developed by the Department of Housing and Urban Development for the Housing Choice Voucher Mobility Demonstration that was authorized and funded through the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2019 and the Further Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2020.

Experimental design

The Demonstration will have two phases of enrollment over a study period of approximately four-and-a-half years. During Phase 1 implementation—the first two years of enrollment —the sites will randomize enrolled families to either CMRS or the control business-as-usual condition. During Phase 2, which will take place over the following two and a half years, the sites will randomize enrolled families to one of three groups: CMRS, SMRS, or the control group.

The impact analysis will estimate impacts for three experimental contrasts:
o CMRS versus Control (Families enrolled in Years 1–5 after the Pilot)
o SMRS versus Control (Families enrolled in Years 3–5)
o SMRS versus CMRS (Families enrolled in Years 3–5)

Because families will be randomly assigned to the offer of SMRS only during the last two and a half years of enrollment (Phase 2), the samples of families used to estimate the impacts of SMRS—both against the control condition and against CMRS—will only include families enrolled during these two and half years.

Confirmatory Research Questions

During Phase 1, the study will have the following confirmatory research questions:

1. For voucher families with children, what is the effect of offering CMRS on moves to an opportunity area during the 12 months following random assignment?
(a) What is the effect for existing voucher families?
(b) What is the effect for waitlist families?

2. For voucher families with children, what is the effect of offering CMRS on the duration of residency in an opportunity area in the 24 months following random assignment?

During Phase 2, the study will continue with the first research question and modify the second research question to examine the duration of residency in an opportunity area over a longer time period of 36 months. In Phase 2, the study will also add three additional confirmatory research questions:

3. For voucher families with children, what is the effect of offering a particular SMRS package on moves to an opportunity area in the 12 months following random assignment?

4. For voucher families with children, what is the effect of offering a particular SMRS package on the duration of residency in an opportunity area in the 24 months following random assignment?

5. Are families offered a particular SMRS package less likely to move to an opportunity area in the 12 months following random assignment than similar families who are offered CMRS?

Secondary Research Questions

The study will also assess the impacts of being offered CMRS on a range of secondary outcomes, such as the share of new voucher recipients who use their vouchers to find a unit (in any location) and the share of existing voucher families who move (to any location). In addition, the study will examine which services appear to be most effective in facilitating moves to an opportunity area and the site- and household-level factors that appear to affect the likelihood that a family moves to an opportunity area, which may shed light on possible ways to strengthen mobility-related services in the future.

Pilot Periods

The first six months of Phase 1 and the first three months of Phase 2 will be considered pilot periods. The Study Team will decide whether to use data on households enrolled in the Demonstration during the pilot periods of each site in the impact analysis based on a site-by-site assessment of fidelity to random assignment procedures and the mobility-related services interventions. Absent a determination that a site is not implementing with fidelity during the pilot, the households that enroll in the Demonstration from that site during the pilots will be included in the analysis sample.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer
Randomization unit
Household
Clusters
10 providers of mobility-related services (one of the nine sites has separate providers of mobility-related services for the two PHAs)
Observations
15,875 households
Arms
CMRS:6,444 households SMRS: 3,077 households Control: 6,354 households
Primary outcomes
Having a new lease-up in an opportunity area during the first 12 months after RA Number of months residing in an opportunity area during the first 24 months after RA (for Phase 1 report) Number of months residing in an opportunity area during the first 36 months after RA (for Phase 2 report)
Secondary outcomes
Having a new lease-up in an opportunity area at any time during the study observation period Residing in an opportunity area at the 12-month timepoint after RA Percent of the period from month 13 after random assignment through the last month observed that a family spends in an opportunity area Residing in an opportunity area at some time during the first 24 months after RA (for Phase 1 report) Residing in an opportunity area at some time during the first 36 months after RA (for Phase 2 report) Leased up or moved with a voucher within 12 months after RA Rental unit characteristics 12 months after RA Census tract characteristics 12 months after RA Housing assistance payment (HAP) 12 months after RA
Sponsors
Name: U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development Location: Washington DC Url: https://hud.gov
Partners
Name: Abt Associates Partner_type: private_company Url: https://abtassociates.com Name: MEF Associates Partner_type: private_company Url: https://mefassociates.com Name: Social Policy Research Associates Partner_type: private_company Url: https://spra.com Name: The Urban Institute Partner_type: ngo Url: https://urban.org

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords