What prevents job-seekers from training? Reframing training access to reduce non-take up

How to cite

Lehner, Lukas; Schwarz, Anna. 2022. "What prevents job-seekers from training? Reframing training access to reduce non-take up." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009776. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9776-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Lukas Lehner* , Anna Schwarz

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009776
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9776-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2022-07-20 – 2026-07-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9776

Abstract

This document describes the research design and analysis strategy of our field experiment, designed to boost training and employment of job-seekers. We start with a detailed outline of the intervention, which takes place in 2022 and 2023 in the state of Lower Austria (Niederösterreich) in Austria. Job-seekers receive an email newsletter with information on training programs offered by the public employment service and open vacancies within two treatment arms. The newsletter includes a voucher framing that informs about the range of available training programs and signals their monetary value to job-seekers. The intervention builds on a precursor study that took place in 2021 (https://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/7141) and expands the most effective treatments to a wider population over an entire year. The major refinement consists in targeting the information on training and job vacancies to the educational attainment of job-seekers. We provide a detailed discussion of our sample selection, variables used and the handling of the data to make the analysis as transparent and replicable as possible. We report the outcomes of our stratified randomization. Further, we state our hypotheses and outcomes of interest motivated by our precursor study and the active labor market policy evaluation literature. Finally, we conclude by specifying our statistical approach to inference.

Intervention

From July 2022 to July 2023, we launch a field experiment designed in cooperation and implemented by the Public Employment Service (PES) of Lower Austria (Arbeitsmarktservice Niederösterreich, AMS NÖ). The aim is to increase training and employment among the unemployed by increasing completion of training programs. The treatment consists of an email newsletter sent to job-seekers with information on training programs offered by the public employment service. The newsletter includes a voucher framing that informs about the range of available training programs and signals their monetary value to job-seekers. In a second treatment arm, job-seekers receive on top additional information on the type of jobs with the highest number of open vacancies.

Two different treatment arms and one control arm vary the type of information that the job-seekers receive on training programs. The job-seekers in the sample will be randomly allocated to each of the three groups on an individual level. This randomization is conducted separately for each sending date. The different treatment and control arms are as follows:

1. Group: control
2. Group: treatment with a newsletter that includes a voucher and information on training provided by the PES targeted to the educational attainment of job-seekers.
3. Group: identical newsletter as the 2nd group complemented with job information also targeted to the educational attainment of job-seekers.

The treatment for group 2 is intended to spur self-driven initiative by raising perceived autonomy over training choices, and increasing reciprocity and reducing social stigma by signalling the monetary value of training programs. On top of it, the treatment for group 3 should also reduce asymmetric information on the demand for labor. Except for receiving the email newsletter, participants in the treatment groups continue to be subject to the same rules and obligations, including regular appointments with their job counselors, as participants in the control group.

Experimental design

The randomization is conducted for each sending date separately. In addition, we use the other
stratification variables as specified in table 1 to construct strata, i.e. blocks. The treatment assignment
is in the next step conducted randomly within these strata. Ideally, we would like to stratify
by more variables than just the three used, but the sample size does not allow more stratification
variables, because then the strata would become too small. In the first wave, we additionally
stratify on unemployment duration, as this population also includes unemployed with varying unemployment
durations, as already explained above.

Design details

Randomization method
Stratified randomization
Randomization unit
Individual level
Clusters
-
Observations
-
Arms
Our sample comprises of all eligible unemployed with an unemployment duration of at least six months to maximum 2 years in June 2022. In the subsequent bi-monthly treatments, new unemployed who exceed a duration of over 6 months will be treated. Every individual will only be treated once. This means that job-seekers who were part of the pre-cursor study are excluded to allow for clean inference of treatment effects. The sample size is thus unclear and will depend on the labor market situation. It will, however, most likely be larger than the sample we had in the precursor intervention of 2021.
Primary outcomes
Our two primary outcomes are training completion and days in employment.
Secondary outcomes
Training take-up, Type of training, Activation measures, Counseling, Subsidized employment Unemployment duration, Earnings Social and health outcomes

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords