Citizens Preferences for Direct vs Indirect Taxation: Vertical vs Horizontal Equity

How to cite

Shaukat, Mahvish; Bachas, Pierre; Jensen, Anders; Hoy, Christopher. 2022. "Citizens Preferences for Direct vs Indirect Taxation: Vertical vs Horizontal Equity." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009771. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9771-4.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Mahvish Shaukat* , Pierre Bachas , Anders Jensen , Christopher Hoy

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009771
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9771-4.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2022-07-25 – 2022-09-30
Countries
Colombia (), Indonesia (), India (), Nigeria (), Philippines ()
JEL codes
H23, O23
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9771

Abstract

A large share of the workforce works in self-employed in developing countries, a hard to tax segment, compared to salaried employees. We study the perception of fairness of the tax system, focusing on the horizontal inequity between salaried and self-employed individuals, in five large low and middle-income countries. We conjecture that the prevalence of self-employment, strengthens horizontal equity concerns, which in turn lowers demand for tax interventions, and especially direct income taxation. To test this hypothesis, we conduct online surveys eliciting individual perception on horizontal equity, tax fairness, relation to vertical equity and how these preferences relate to the tax instruments used by their governments. To test whether increased awareness of horizontal inequity affects tax preferences, we conduct a within-survey information treatments aimed at increasing the salience of this issue.

Intervention

We administer an online survey to respondents across five countries eliciting their perceptions on horizontal tax equity regarding the gap in income tax collection between self-employed and salaried workers. During the survey, we show information about the proportion of tax contributions from self-employed versus salaried workers to a random subset of respondents, to test whether receiving this information influences their views regarding the horizontal fairness of the tax system.

We compare perceptions of horizontal fairness to vertical fairness, and enquire how these preferences relate to preferences for different tax instruments (direct vs indirect) and if respondents support tax policies aimed at reducing horizontal inequity.

Experimental design

An information treatment will be administered during the online survey. The study sample will be split two treatment arms (T1: 30% and T2: 30%) and a control group (40%). The first treatment group (T1) will receive information about the share of tax revenue paid by self-employed workers in comparison to salaried employees in the country survey the survey is administered in. The second treatment group (T2) will receive the same information as T1 and an additional pedagogical treatment containing information on the contributors of the income tax and consumption tax. The survey experiment aims to raise awareness of self-employed employee tax gaps (saliency of horizontal equity) via T1 and T2 and clarify the link between equity concepts of tax instruments (T2).

Design details

Randomization method
Done on the computer by an online survey firm.
Randomization unit
Individual Respondent
Clusters
13,500
Observations
13,500, corresponding to 2,700 respondents in each of 5 countries
Arms
1,100 respondents in control, 700 in T1, 700 in T2 for each of the 5 countries.
Primary outcomes
Tax preferences, views on the role of the tax system, perceptions regarding horizontal equity between self-employed and employees in taxation, preferences regarding vertical vs horizontal inequity, and support for different types of tax instruments (direct vs indirect). These outcomes correspond to questions in the survey instrument and their use is detailed in the pre-analysis-plan.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords