Middle School Parent Engagement Text Messaging Study--Grade-Specific Program Analysis Plan

How to cite

Cortes, Kalena; Holzman, Brian. 2022. "Middle School Parent Engagement Text Messaging Study--Grade-Specific Program Analysis Plan." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009762. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9762-1.3

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Kalena Cortes* , Brian Holzman

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009762
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9762-1.3
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2020-09-17 – 2026-08-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I21, I24, I26, I29
Secondary IDs
National Science Foundation Award Number: 1918016
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9762

Abstract

Parent involvement at both home and school during the middle school years is positively associated with a range of behavioral and academic outcomes. Yet, due to structural changes in school environments and the increasing autonomy of teenagers, parent involvement often declines during the formative middle school years. Therefore, parents face unique challenges in their ability to both monitor their middle school child’s academic progress and be engaged in their child’s life.

This project covers a set of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of Texts4Teens, a text messaging program for parents of middle school that aims to increase parental involvement by decreasing the behavioral barriers to engaged parenting.

This document describes grade-specific text message interventions administered during four academic years: 2020-2021, 2021-2022, 2022-2023, and 2023-2024. Below are the school districts that participated in the study these four years:

• 2020-2021: District 1, District 2, District 3
• 2021-2022: District 1, District 2, District 3, District 4, District 5, District 6, and District 7
• 2022-2023: District 1, District 2, District 3, District 4, District 5, District 6, District 7, and District 8
• 2023-2024: District 4, District 5, and District 6

Our middle school parenting program, Texts4Teens, is a text-based intervention that seeks to positively influence parent-teenage day-to-day interactions by addressing potential barriers to parents’ home and school involvement with their child. Texts4Teens’ goal is to narrow achievement gaps before children enter high school and beyond. The text messages include facts and tips on: 1) How to best support and guide their child’s academic trajectory as they transition from middle school to high school; 2) How to best support their child’s social and emotional learning (SEL) skills; and 3) How knowledge, skills, and abilities of their child are grow-able. Parents can choose to receive texts in English or Spanish. Every week, we will send middle school parents in the treatment group three texts about a particular academic topic and an SEL skill or activity for their child. Specifically,

--> The INSPIRE texts will be sent on Mondays. These texts are designed to motivate parents on a weekly academic topic related to their middle school child (e.g., asking questions in class, learning from mistakes, sharing schoolwork in progress, talking about report cards, and talking to teachers).
--> The EXCEL texts will be sent on Wednesdays. These texts address the academic topic of the week and aim to: (1) develop specific social and emotional learning (SEL) skills for their child (i.e., growth mindset, self-efficacy, self-management, self-awareness, and social awareness, responsible decision-making), (2) promote their child’s school engagement (i.e., emotional, behavioral, or cognitive), (3) encourage a parenting practice (i.e., autonomy support, monitoring, or warmth) and/or (4) foster a type of parental involvement (i.e., home-based, school-based, or academic socialization).
--> The BOND texts will be sent on Fridays and are also related to the academic topic of the week. These texts typically reinforce the week’s aim from the EXCEL text by fostering positive parent-child interactions (e.g., affective interactions).

Intervention

Our middle school parenting program, Texts4Teens, is a text-based intervention that seeks to positively influence parent-teenage day-to-day interactions by addressing potential barriers to parents’ home and school involvement with their child. Texts4Teens’ goal is to narrow achievement gaps before children enter high school and beyond. The text messages include facts and tips on: 1) How to best support and guide their child’s academic trajectory as they transition from middle school to high school; 2) How to best support their child’s social and emotional learning (SEL) skills; and 3) How knowledge, skills, and abilities of their child are grow-able. Parents can choose to receive texts in English or Spanish. Every week, we will send middle school parents in the treatment group three texts about a particular academic topic and an SEL skill or activity for their child. Specifically,

--> The INSPIRE texts will be sent on Mondays. These texts are designed to motivate parents on a weekly academic topic related to their middle school child (e.g., asking questions in class, learning from mistakes, sharing schoolwork in progress, talking about report cards, and talking to teachers).
--> The EXCEL texts will be sent on Wednesdays. These texts address the academic topic of the week and aim to: (1) develop specific social and emotional learning (SEL) skills for their child (i.e., growth mindset, self-efficacy, self-management, self-awareness, and social awareness, responsible decision-making), (2) promote their child’s school engagement (i.e., emotional, behavioral, or cognitive), (3) encourage a parenting practice (i.e., autonomy support, monitoring, or warmth) and/or (4) foster a type of parental involvement (i.e., home-based, school-based, or academic socialization).
--> The BOND texts will be sent on Fridays and are also related to the academic topic of the week. These texts typically reinforce the week’s aim from the EXCEL text by fostering positive parent-child interactions (e.g., affective interactions).

Experimental design

To assign parents to one of the texting groups, we will employ a multi-site person-level randomized controlled trial design, blocking on, for example, middle school site, grade level, and texting language, English or Spanish (Spybrook et al., 2011). Specifically, within the districts’ middle schools, grades, and texting languages, we will randomly select half of participating parents to join the control texting group and half to join the INSPIRE-EXCEL-BOND texting group.

This study builds on an earlier text message RCT in District 1 in spring 2019 (pilot) and 2019-2020. That study used a general, non-differentiated curriculum that gave students in grades 6 through 8 the same text messages. During this phase of the study, we learned that parent participants commented that they would prefer grade-specific text messages. Therefore, this study delivers grade-specific messages to parents of middle school children.

District 1 parents who participated in the earlier general program and who enrolled in the grade-specific program in 2020-2021 were reassigned to their initial treatment condition. District 1, District 2, District 3, and District 7 parents who participated in the grade-specific program in 2020-2021 and who enrolled in in 2021-2022 were reassigned to their 2020-2021 treatment condition; see Figure 1 for an illustration. In 2022-2023, we, again, reassigned re-enrollees from those four districts to their earlier treatment condition. This design allows us to examine whether multiple years of treatment has effects on student outcomes, relative to zero years of treatment. District 8 participated in the study for a single year, preventing an analysis of multiple years of treatment.

For District 4, District 5, and District 6, parents who re-enrolled were re-randomized. The re-randomization of these districts will allow us to causally estimate dosage effects. For example, there will be four groups of parents across the 2021-2022 and 2022-2023 school years: control-control (CC), control-treatment (CT), treatment-control (TC), and treatment-treatment (TT); see Figure 2 for an illustration. This design will allow us to test whether one year of treatment has effects on student outcomes over zero years of treatment, as well as whether two years of treatment has effects on student outcomes over zero and one years of treatment (a double-dosage effect). When we integrate data from the 2023-2024 school year, some students (i.e., 5th and 6th graders) will have participated in the intervention for three years, producing 8 groups of parents: CCC, TCC, CTC, CCT, TTC, TCT, CTT, and TTT.

It should be noted that for District 2 and District 6, there are intermediate and middle schools. Intermediate schools serve grades 5 and 6, while middle schools serve grades 7 and 8. For these two districts only, we include 5th grade students in the randomization. Sixth grade students in District 2 and District 6 are unique in that they have already been exposed to one full year of intermediate/middle school, whereas 6th grade students in other school districts have not been exposed to that experience.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in Stata
Randomization unit
Individual-level randomization within school-by-grade blocks (or school-by-grade-by texting language blocks, if there are sufficient numbers of Spanish-speaking parents in a district) - Grade includes grade levels 5, 6, 7, or 8 (some districts include grade 5 in a middle or intermediate school) - Texting language includes English or Spanish text messages (chosen by parent during enrollment)
Clusters
2020-2021 (same-year effects sample sizes) District 1: 2,324 students, 46 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 2: 2,106 students, 12 blocks (school-by-grade fixed-effects) District 3: 2,888 students, 33 blocks (school-by-grade fixed-effects) 2021-2022 (same-year effects sample sizes) District 1: 1,133 students, 47 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 2: 943 students, 12 blocks (school-by-grade fixed-effects) District 3: 1,246 students, 33 blocks (school-by-grade fixed-effects) District 4: 2,819 students, 34 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 5: 3,510 students, 36 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 6: 4,976 students, 66 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 7: 609 students, 18 blocks (school-by-grade fixed-effects) 2022-2023 (same-year effects sample sizes) District 1: 3,522 students, 48 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 2: 858 students, 12 blocks (school-by-grade fixed-effects) District 3: 1,245 students, 33 blocks (school-by-grade fixed-effects) District 4: 1,581 students, 32 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 5: 1,584 students, 34 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 6: 2,420 students, 71 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 7: 319 students, 18 blocks (school-by-grade fixed-effects) District 8: 133 students, 16 blocks (school-by-grade fixed-effects) 2023-2024 (same-year effects sample sizes) District 4: 1,426 students, 33 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 5: 1,448 students, 35 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 6: 2,119 students, 72 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects)
Observations
2020-2021 (same-year effects sample sizes) District 1: 2,324 students, 46 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 2: 2,106 students, 12 blocks (school-by-grade fixed-effects) District 3: 2,888 students, 33 blocks (school-by-grade fixed-effects) 2021-2022 (same-year effects sample sizes) District 1: 1,133 students, 47 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 2: 943 students, 12 blocks (school-by-grade fixed-effects) District 3: 1,246 students, 33 blocks (school-by-grade fixed-effects) District 4: 2,819 students, 34 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 5: 3,510 students, 36 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 6: 4,976 students, 66 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 7: 609 students, 18 blocks (school-by-grade fixed-effects) 2022-2023 (same-year effects sample sizes) District 1: 3,522 students, 48 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 2: 858 students, 12 blocks (school-by-grade fixed-effects) District 3: 1,245 students, 33 blocks (school-by-grade fixed-effects) District 4: 1,581 students, 32 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 5: 1,584 students, 34 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 6: 2,420 students, 71 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 7: 319 students, 18 blocks (school-by-grade fixed-effects) District 8: 133 students, 16 blocks (school-by-grade fixed-effects) 2023-2024 (same-year effects sample sizes) District 4: 1,426 students, 33 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 5: 1,448 students, 35 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects) District 6: 2,119 students, 72 blocks (school-by-grade-by texting language fixed-effects)
Arms
2020-2021 (same-year effects sample sizes) District 1 - Treatment: 1,169 - Control: 1,155 - Total: 2,324 - Blocks: 46 District 2 - Treatment: 1,051 - Control: 1,055 - Total: 2,106 - Blocks: 12 District 3 - Treatment: 1,444 - Control: 1,444 - Total: 2,888 - Blocks: 33 2021-2022 (same-year effects sample sizes) District 1 - Treatment: 569 - Control: 564 - Total: 1,133 - Blocks: 47 District 2 - Treatment: 472 - Treatment: 471 - Total: 943 - Blocks: 12 District 3 - Treatment: 622 - Control: 624 - Total: 1,246 - Blocks: 33 District 4 - Treatment: 1,410 - Control: 1,409 - Total: 2,819 - Blocks: 34 District 5 - Treatment: 1,753 - Control: 1,757 - Total: 3,510 - Blocks: 36 District 6 - Treatment: 2,488 - Control: 2,488 - Total: 4,976 - Blocks: 66 District 7 - Treatment: 302 - Control: 307 - Total: 609 - Blocks: 18 2022-2023 (same-year effects sample sizes) District 1 - Treatment: 1,763 - Control: 1,759 - Total: 3,522 - Blocks: 48 District 2 - Treatment: 429 - Treatment: 429 - Total: 858 - Blocks: 12 District 3 - Treatment: 622 - Control: 623 - Total: 1,245 - Blocks: 33 District 4 - Treatment: 791 - Control: 790 - Total: 1,581 - Blocks: 32 District 5 - Treatment: 795 - Control: 789 - Total: 1,584 - Blocks: 34 District 6 - Treatment: 1,211 - Control: 1,209 - Total: 2,420 - Blocks: 71 District 7 - Treatment: 159 - Control: 160 - Total: 319 - Blocks: 18 District 8 - Treatment: 65 - Control: 68 - Total: 133 - Blocks: 16 2023-2024 (same-year effects sample sizes) District 4 - Treatment: 713 - Control: 713 - Total: 1,426 - Blocks: 33 District 5 - Treatment: 724 - Control: 724 - Total: 1,448 - Blocks: 35 District 6 - Treatment: 1,051 - Control: 1,068 - Total: 2,119 - Blocks: 72
Primary outcomes
- Student academic and behavioral outcomes (using student-level administrative data from each district) - Perceived levels of parental engagement and students’ development of social and emotional skills (using end-of-year parent survey data & texted prompts throughout the texting program) - Parent and student educational aspirations and expectations? (using parent survey data)
Secondary outcomes
Data from the texting platform will be used to examine opt-out rates. Open-ended text responses from the parent survey, as well as parents' texted responses to the texts and prompts, will be used to examine parent perceptions of the program.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords