Food safety training and rating programs for informal processed food markets in Northern Ghana

How to cite

Magnan, Nicholas; Hoffmann, Vivian; Opoku, Nelson; Posey, Sean. 2022. "Food safety training and rating programs for informal processed food markets in Northern Ghana." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009759. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9759-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Nicholas Magnan* , Vivian Hoffmann , Nelson Opoku , Sean Posey

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009759
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9759-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2022-08-01 – 2024-08-01
Countries
Ghana (Northern Region)
JEL codes
Q18
Secondary IDs
FP00023921
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9759

Abstract

Most food consumed in developing countries is transacted in informal markets. While these markets provide an important source of low cost food for the poor, they can also present food safety hazards. In Ghana and throughout West Africa, kulikuli is a popular snack food made from groundnuts. Because kulikuli is fried and spiced, it hides the morphology and taste of groundnuts likely to be contaminated with aflatoxin. Thus, poor quality and potentially hazard groundnuts (also traded informally) frequently end up in kulikuli. In this study we implement and evaluate a training program to teach kulikuli producers how to avoid and sort out potentially hazardous groundnuts before making kulikuli. As part of the program, we will test and rate producers' kulikuli and provide marketing materials for producers to signal that they have been trained and the safety of their kulikuli. The program will be complemented by an information intervention targeting local consumers. To evaluate the intervention we will conduct a market-level cluster randomized control trial with 720 kulikuli producers and 1440 consumers. We will evaluate the intervention's impact on producer and consumer behavior, as well as on food safety of locally available kulikuli.

Intervention

The project has a producer intervention and consumer intervention. The producer intervention has three components: training, testing, and rating. Producers will be invited to attend a training on using safe groundnuts to produce kulikuli. Upon completion of training they will receive a prominent sign to post at their point of sale stating they have completed the safe kulikuli production training. Testing will occur every two weeks using a sample purchased by a mystery shopper. Based on the test results, the producer will earn a rating, which they can post on their sign in a designated spot. The consumer training will involve telling nearby consumers about aflatoxin, the high risk of aflatoxin in kulikuli, how to find and identify producers trained on aflatoxin prevention, and how to interpret the rating system to make sure the producer has recently received a satisfactory rating.

Experimental design

Producers
First, we will randomize our interventions at the market cluster level. Treatment clusters will receive both the producer and consumer intervention, and control clusters will receive no intervention whatsoever.

Next, we will randomize recruitment into the producer intervention within clusters. In treated market clusters, we will randomly select half of the producers to invite to the training, testing, and certification program. The other half will be invited at the end of the study. This will allow us to test for effects on certified and non-certified producers, who may be affected through information spillovers, shifts in consumer preferences, or changing prices. Furthermore, offering these producers training and certification later will allow us to measure demand for certification not directly incited by the research team (see below) and reduce the potential of harming initially non-certified producers or causing conflict between producers. In control clusters, we will randomly select half of the producers to be in the study so that we have three equally sized treatment arms: 240 treated producers, 240 untreated producers in treated market clusters, and 240 control producers.

We will stratify the randomization across market clusters based on geography and the number of producers in the cluster. We believe geography will be the best determinant of where a producer sources their groundnuts, which is they factor we believe will be most highly correlated with aflatoxin levels. Stratifying based on the number of producers will help us get the same number of producers in the three treatment arms. Because we will only stratify on these variables, we can assign treatment before collecting baseline data, which has two advantages. First, it allows us to construct a sample with an average of 12 producers in treatment market clusters (half of whom will be treated) and an average of six producers in control clusters. Second, it makes it possible to invite (treatment) producers to training upon completion of the baseline survey.

Consumers
Coinciding with producer training, we will implement the consumer intervention in all treated market clusters. This means we will estimate the combined effect of a producer and consumer intervention, which we believe is the most likely way a program like this would be implemented in practice. This design does not allow us to estimate the effects of the producer intervention alone, or to estimate the \emph{additional} effect of the consumer intervention when the produce intervention is in place. However, it gives us maximum power to estimate the (combined) treatment effect we are most interested in.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
Market cluster (neighborhood) first, then individual vendors within treated market clusters.
Clusters
80 market clusters.
Observations
720 kulikuli producers, 1440 kulikuli consumers.
Arms
40 market clusters per treatment arm. 240 producers per treatment arm. 480 consumers per treatment arm.
Primary outcomes
Producer outcomes: aflatoxin awareness, time spent sorting bad nuts out, quantity of bad nuts sorted out, quantity of kulikuli produced, quantity of kulikuli sold, aflatoxin levels in kulikuli. Consumer outcomes: Criteria for selecting kulikuli, aflatoxin/food safety knowledge, knowledge of training and rating program
Secondary outcomes
Producer outcomes: Source of groundnut stock, price paid for groundnut stock, price of kulikuli sold, quantity of kulikuli consumed at home. Consumer outcomes: Perceives there to be a quality difference between vendors, quantity of kulikuli purchased, price paid, youngest kulikuli consumer in household
Sponsors
Name: United States Agency for International Development Feed the Future Innovation Lab for Peanut Location: Athens, GA Url: https://ftfpeanutlab.caes.uga.edu

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords