Handwashing and Habit Formation

How to cite

Hussam, Reshmaan; Rigol, Natalia; Reggiani, Giovanni. 2016. "Handwashing and Habit Formation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000974. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.974-3.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Reshmaan Hussam* , Natalia Rigol , Giovanni Reggiani

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0000974
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.974-3.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2015-08-18 – 2017-01-01
Countries
India (West Bengal)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/974

Abstract

Diarrheal disease and acute respiratory infection result in two million child deaths per year worldwide (WHO 2013) and the physical and cognitive stunting of millions more. Caused by fecal and bacterial contamination, public health officials argue that handwashing with soap is the most cost-effective tool against such contamination. However, campaigns have met with consistent failure in engendering sustained behavioral change, suffering from two major weaknesses: (1) an inability to credibly measure handwashing; and (2) an incapacity to untangle the mechanisms behind the initial behavioral failure. In partnership with the MIT Media Lab, we develop a time-stamped sensor that unobstrusively measures household handsoap use. With this high frequency measurement tool, we examine three behavioral interventions targeted towards young children in an RCT setup in which control households receive a standard public health information campaign only: (1) a dispenser arm, in which the household is also provided with a foaming dispenser and soap; (2) a monitoring arm, in which the household is also informed that their behavior is being tracked by the dispenser and receives biweekly reports on performance; and (3) an incentive arm, in which the household is informed it is being tracked and receives discrete incentives for daily handwashing performance. The design is embedded within the classic habit loop of trigger, routine, and reward: the trigger is an agreed-upon mealtime against which performance is evaluated; the routine is handwashing with soap, and the reward is either clean hands only, a satisfied conscience (monitoring), or a monetary incentive. Within the two latter arms, some households are told that they will receive a future boost in their monitoring or incentive services; this allows us to examine the habit formation process against the standard model of rational addiction. External interventions (monitoring and incentives) will be removed after three months, but household dispenser use will continue to be tracked for one year to measure the precise patterns of habit formation. At the six month mark, households will be cross-randomized into an additional reminder arm, in which alarm clocks programmed for the daily meal time are attached to their dispensers, thereby enhancing the saliency of the trigger and examining limited attention. In conjunction with the high frequency dispenser use data, we will collect biweekly child health data on diarrhea and ARI incidence, as well as detailed anthropometric, blood, and stool data at endline.

Intervention

We examine three behavioral interventions targeted towards young children in an RCT setup in which control households receive a standard public health information campaign only: (1) a dispenser arm, in which the household is also provided with a foaming dispenser and soap; (2) a monitoring arm, in which the household is also informed that their behavior is being tracked by the dispenser and receives biweekly reports on performance; and (3) an incentive arm, in which the household is informed it is being tracked and receives discrete incentives for daily handwashing performance. The design is embedded within the classic habit loop of trigger, routine, and reward: the trigger is an agreed-upon mealtime against which performance is evaluated; the routine is handwashing with soap, and the reward is either clean hands only, a satisfied conscience (monitoring), or a monetary incentive. Within the two latter arms, some households are told that they will receive a future boost in their monitoring or incentive services; this allows us to examine the habit formation process against the standard model of rational addiction. External interventions (monitoring and incentives) will be removed after three months, but household dispenser use will continue to be tracked for one year to measure the precise patterns of habit formation. At the six month mark, households will be cross-randomized into an additional reminder arm, in which alarm clocks programmed for the daily meal time are attached to their dispensers, thereby enhancing the saliency of the trigger and examining limited attention. In conjunction with the high frequency dispenser use data, we will collect biweekly child health data on diarrhea and ARI incidence, as well as detailed anthropometric, blood, and stool data at endline.

Experimental design

A baseline survey collecting information on sociodemographic characteristics, health behavior, health knowledge, and aspirations and discount factor measures, is first conducted across all mothers (or primary caretakers of the children in the household) in the full sample of 2947 households. Surveys on child health (ARI and diarrhea episodes) are conducted every two weeks. A midline survey measuring WTP of the dispensers is conducted six months after roll-out, and an endline survey with blood and stool analysis is collected at the twelve month mark. Funds permitting, household behavior among dispenser households are tracked every four months over three years.

The randomization process proceeds in five steps:

1. 105 villages are randomized into Monitoring Villages (MV) and Incentive Villages (IV).
2. Households in MV are then randomized into two groups: (MV1) control and (MV2) dispenser. Households in IV are likewise randomized into two groups: (IV1) control and (IV2) dispenser + monitoring + incentive. This occurs after baseline, before roll-out of dispensers.
3. After roll-out, households in MV are randomized into those who remain dispenser only (MV2) and those who will receive the monitoring service (MV2a); likewise, households in IV are randomized into those who keep the standard incentive (IV2) and those who will experience the thirty-day incentive bump (IV2a). Both the monitoring service (in the case of MV2a) and the incentive bump (in the case of IV2a) are scheduled to begin approximately 1.5 months after the day the household received the dispenser.
4. On the date of the monitoring or incentive change (1.5 months after dispenser distribution), half of MV2 households (MV2b) and half of IV2 households (IV2b) are randomly selected to also receive the monitoring service or incentive boost, respectively.
5. Six months after roll-out, the fifth stage of randomization was completed, with households in all arms cross-randomized into a Reminders (R) intervention.

Incentives and monitoring services are withdrawn three months after roll-out, but household behavior continues to be tracked.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is done in the office by a computer.
Randomization unit
Randomization is at the village level for the first randomization and at the household level for all subsequent randomizations.
Clusters
NA
Observations
2947 Households
Arms
Control: (IV1) 1286 and (MV1) 499 IV2: 191 IV2a: 310 IV2b: 179 MV2: 130 MV2a: 233 MV2b: 119
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes of interest encompass both beliefs and behavioral changes of households. We capture beliefs through (1) forecasts of own daily handwashing behavior and (2) willingness to pay for the liquid handsoap dispenser. We capture behavioral change through (3) recorded total daily handwashing rates and (4) recorded dinner time-specific daily handwashing rates. Beliefs and behavioral measures can only be collected for those households with dispensers, so we do not have data from the pure control households on these metrics. Finally, we collect child health data in the form of (5) self-reported biweekly incidence of child diarrhea and respiratory illness (all households), (6) bacteria cultures of random hand swabs (a random subset), and (7) child blood and stool reports (a consenting subset).

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords