The Effectiveness of Business Coaching on Technology-Based Ventures' Survival Capabilities
How to cite
Ungerer, Christina; König, Marc; Baltes, Guido. 2015. "The Effectiveness of Business Coaching on Technology-Based Ventures' Survival Capabilities." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000973. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.973-5.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In order to enable offering more effective business coaching activities in the future, this research program analyzes the impact of such coaching on venture survival capabilities. The entrepreneurship research initiative, conducted by the Institute for Strategic Innovation & Technology (IST) at the Constance University of Applied Sciences, Germany, is supported by Nesta with an Innovation Growth Lab grant.
Technology-based ventures foster economic growth by accelerating the transfer of new technological knowledge to the market. Regional innovation activity is stimulated by expanding the technology-based venture eco-system. As a consequence, the industrial landscape is modernized and additional jobs are created. Hence, the public sector is interested in increasing technology-based ventures’ survival prospects by effectively allocating limited financial resources to support them.
Business coaching is an important support measure that positively impacts venture team performance because it helps to address the challenges of high-speed organizational change which founders face. Though not much research has investigated this type of supportive intervention applied to technology-oriented startups, it is a key value proposition provided by incubation and acceleration programs. But how do we know that business coaching actually affects survival capabilities, and thus the growth of ventures?
Following the conceptual design of a Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT) study, this research program applies quantitative research methods in a business context to investigate the cause-and-effect-relationship between business coaching and venture survival. RCTs represent a specific experimental study design, achieving the highest hierarchy of evidence in primary research. RCT studies first appeared in the fields of psychology and medicine to test the effectiveness of treatments on patients. Within business contexts, the method has hardly been applied yet – though it is seen as the gold standard for analyzing the effectiveness of an observed intervention.
For the RCT study, a longitudinal sample of 450 early-stage, technology-based ventures will be recruited in Germany over three years (2015-2017) by the project delivery partner bwcon GmbH. bwcon is an expert in supporting technology-based ventures and will selectively offer business coaching to the sampled ventures following the defined RCT experiment design. Six months post-intervention, the survival capabilities of those ventures which received coaching are compared with those which did not receive the support intervention. Survival capabilities will be measured based on indicators for the maturity of the ventures’ value-networks in various market dimensions. It is expected that the survival capabilities significantly differ between the two groups, thus proving the effectiveness of business coaching.
Accordingly, by using the unique database of early-stage, technology-based ventures from the German regional state Baden-Württemberg, a deeper understanding of the impact of coaching activities will be gained. Identifying underlying causal effects of the effectiveness of business coaching on venture survival capabilities enables accelerators and entrepreneurship program providers to become more effective, which accelerates startup business growth in the long-run.
Intervention
External support is needed to enable venture teams to develop their business activities efficiently. The coaching intervention will focus on tactical knowledge, which is designed to help founders building appropriate networks and enhance their know-how where needed capabilities cannot be derived from books. Our delivery partner bwcon has had an efficient business coaching concept in place since 2005 which serves as support intervention in the planned RCT. Content-wise, the coaching sessions do not only provide business and technological expertise to new business founders, but particularly aim at accelerating the creation of networks and tactical implementation of venture development activities during the growth phase. Business as usual refers to venture teams with different levels and exposure to explicit business knowledge gained for instance through prior work experience or by non-tactical coaching input.
Experimental design
A pragmatic two-armed Randomized Controlled Trial represents the basic study design testing the effect of tactical knowledge coaching on the survival capabilities of technology-based early-stage ventures. Over three years, 450 ventures from the German regional state Baden-Württemberg will be recruited. Accredited, experienced coaches are imparting certain tactical knowledge to the founder teams in the form of individual support sessions. The treatment group (T) encompasses 150 startups in total, each year about 50 being subject to the intervention. Not having been coached with a focus on tactical knowledge, another 300 ventures serve as the control group (C). After three years, ventures' survival capability (total score) six months post-intervention is compared.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.