Inequality in Life Expectancy – (Mis)Perception and Policy Demand

How to cite

Koehne, Sebastian; Jessen, Lasse; Nüß, Patrick; Ruhose, Jens. 2022. "Inequality in Life Expectancy – (Mis)Perception and Policy Demand." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009711. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9711-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Sebastian Koehne* , Lasse Jessen , Patrick Nüß , Jens Ruhose

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009711
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9711-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2022-08-16 – 2022-11-30
Countries
Germany (), United States of America ()
JEL codes
C90, D39, D83, H50, I14, I18
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9711

Abstract

Inequality in income and wealth is closely linked with inequality in noneconomic domains - in particular regarding health and life expectancy: well-off individuals tend to live healthier and longer lives. To what extent are individuals aware of these socioeconomic differences in life expectancy? How should public policy react? Should redistribution policy become more generous towards the poor who are additionally deprived in terms of life expectancy? Should policies instead aim at improving health care access, living conditions, education and working conditions of the poor? Although these questions are highly relevant for society, science, and politics, they have not been studied in the existing literature.
We address these research questions with a representative large-scale survey experiment to document the perceived socioeconomic differences in life expectancy in the United States and Germany—two countries with very different health care systems and (potentially) different perceptions and beliefs about the inequality in life expectancy, their origins, the role of government and demanded policy actions. By providing an information treatment about the true inequality in life expectancy, we identify the causal effect of (mis)perceptions of inequality in life expectancy on concerns, policy preferences, and the willingness to donate to charities supporting individuals on low incomes.

Intervention

Information provision to a randomly selected group of survey participants, revealing the true extent of inequality in life expectancy of their country.

Experimental design

We conduct survey experiments in the United States and Germany. The experiment covers four stages: (1) Elicitation of prior perceptions of life expectancy inequality, (2) an information treatment to half the sample, (3) a post treatment survey on concerns, policy preferences, and background information, and (4) a follow-up survey.

Design details

Randomization method
Simple randomization, done by a computer.
Randomization unit
The randomization is going to take place at the level of the individual survey participant.
Clusters
n/a
Observations
12000 individuals in main survey. United States: 6000 individuals. Germany: 6000 individuals. Expected recontact rate in follow-up survey: 60% in both countries
Arms
3000 individuals per treatment for each country
Primary outcomes
Misperceptions of inequality in life expectancy, magnitude of and concerns about differences in life expectancy, policy preferences (general policy demand, health care access, economic stability, living conditions, education, working conditions), real outcome (donation to charities).
Secondary outcomes
Concerns about income inequality: We ask participants how concerned they are about income inequality. The concrete question is: Do you think income differences between rich and poor people in the United States/Germany are: not a problem at all; a small problem; a problem; a serious problem; a very serious problem. Perceived Covid-19 effect on differences in live expectancy: We ask participants about their beliefs to what extent socioeconomic differences in life expectancy have changed due to the Covid-19 pandemic. Heterogeneity analysis: Depending on the distribution of prior perceptions, we may not observe an average treatment effect on outcomes. We therefore generally differentiate between the treatment effects for participants who overestimate, correctly estimate, and underestimate the true (gender-averaged) socioeconomic inequality in life expectancy. We also study how treatment effects vary with or are mediated by: 1. Certainty about perceptions 2. Beliefs about a person’s degree of control about one’s own life expectancy (measured with a luck-effort belief scale and with an item battery about causes of health problems) 3. Attitude towards government (measuring trust, ability, and scope of government). 4. Political orientation (measured once with a left/right scale and once with party affiliation) 5. Socioeconomic background (such as actual income, employment status, age, gender, migration background, education, social mobility, health insurance status, …) 6. Perceived own income position and beliefs about a person’s degree of control about one’s own income position 7. Responsibility of government and other actors 8. Own health and health behavior 9. Individual preferences on patience, altruism, and risk. Mediation: To explain mechanisms of any potential treatment effects, we use a mediation analysis. The main potential mediator outcomes refer to the magnitude of and the concerns about socioeconomic differences in life expectancy. Moreover, we may also observe that the treatment affects luck/effort beliefs, trust in government, and the responsibility of the government for addressing inequalities. Country comparison: We also study why (if at all) misperceptions and treatment effects on concerns and policy preferences differ between the United States and Germany. Potential explanations for any differential effects of information provision in the two countries may come from differences in the attitude towards government, luck/effort beliefs, political orientation, perceptions of health, health care access and income position, health behavior, responsibility of government, and other factors that differ between the two countries.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords