The effects of instituting informal institutions on social and economic outcomes: Experimental evidence from Bangladesh
How to cite
Zizzamia, Rocco; Pople, Ashley; Dercon, Stefan; Sulaiman, Munshi; Matin, Imran; Das, Narayan. 2022. "The effects of instituting informal institutions on social and economic outcomes: Experimental evidence from Bangladesh." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009709. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9709-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Graduation programmes such as BRAC's Targeting the Ultra-Poor (TUP) have traditionally focused on transferring resources and providing health services and training to recipients. The origin of these transfers is from outside the recipient communities: That is, the transfer of resources and skills is made from wealthier parts of the country (in the case of tax-funded programmes) or of the world (in the case of foreign donors) to poor members of relatively deprived communities. This traditional model does not attempt to change the way in which resources are distributed and help is mobilised within recipient communities. At the same time, increasing transfers may have unintended consequences if within-community private transfers and risk-sharing are crowded out. Motivated by these concerns, in 2016, BRAC trialed an intervention which attempts to leverage local knowledge and existing forms of informal social protection to improve outcomes for the recipients of their TUP programmes, or at the very least to off-set any possible crowding-out effects. They did this by instituting informal institutions called "village assistance committees" (VACs) in recipient communities. By exploiting random variation that was built into the programme roll-out (VACs were established in a randomly selected subset of eligible villages), we aim to evaluate the impact that these forms of informal institutions have on distributive outcomes, consumption, social inclusion, and overall living standards among TUP beneficiaries.
Intervention
An important component of BRAC's TUP programmes is the institution of Village Assistance Committees (VACs), designed to strengthen the networks of recipient ultra-poor households. These VACs remain one of the least discussed components of the graduation approach that BRAC has pioneered. BRAC introduced this component in all their direct implementation sites, and three of the six country pilots had some type of VAC. Each committee is comprised of TUP representatives (i.e., ultra-poor women) and community leaders -- for instance wealthier land owners, teachers, imams, local authorities. The VAC meets monthly and discusses issues raised by the TUP representatives with the aim of helping them build social networks and leverage community ties. The VACs are intended to help programme recipients protect their assets, increase access to government services, and offer support in times of need by coordinating local community support.
The need for VACs was motivated by an acknowledgement that the programme needs to ensure community buy-in, leadership, and collective consensus so that the interventions do not crowd out the informal risk sharing and transfers often crucial in sustaining rural livelihoods, or indeed the sense of belonging of the recipients within community networks. Beyond this, VACs may complement TUP interventions -- local elites may be better informed and equipped to provide support to TUP beneficiaries, especially in the event of idiosyncratic shocks which require an immediate response. In addition, VACs may function as a commitment device, increasing recipients' compliance with the TUP programme.
Given the lack of evidence on the role of introducing VACs, in the 2016 roll-out of their Targeting the Ultra-Poor programme, BRAC randomly identified some villages in which VACs would be set up, and others which would serve as a control group.
Experimental design
In its fourth phase of the Targeting the Ultra-Poor Graduation (TUP) programme (starting in 2016) BRAC implemented an RCT in Bangladesh to test the effectiveness of instituting VACs on household outcomes. The sample of villages and households in this study is therefore drawn from villages in which BRAC was rolling out its TUP programme. The households which make up our sample in this study are all 2016 recipients of the TUP intervention. Therefore, any impacts we observe in 2022 will be the combined effect of the TUP programme and the introduction or non-introduction of VACs. (Note that this RCT was nested within a larger RCT in which three variants of BRAC's TUP were rolled out to randomly selected beneficiaries (see the other trial registered by the same authors on the ARA registry).)
A baseline survey was conducted in 2016 prior to rolling out the randomized interventions. Baseline surveys were completed by 1,600 recipients and their households. Our analysis of this RCT will be based on an endline survey on these beneficiaries. Data collection on this endline survey began on the 7th of June 2022, and is expected to be completed within two months -- by early-to-mid August 2022.
Figure 1 in the attached Analysis Plan summarizes the RCT design. The study covers 16 branch offices (the smallest unit in BRAC’s administrative structure) from 8 districts. 89 villages were selected from within these 16 branches, and villages were then randomly assigned to treatment (45 villages) and control (44 villages) where
a) Treatment: VAC was formed in the village
b) Control: No VAC was formed within the village
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.