Subjective Beliefs and Commitment Contract Take-Up
How to cite
Koepcke, Eric; Kim, Woojin. 2022. "Subjective Beliefs and Commitment Contract Take-Up." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009655. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9655-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study seeks to better understand the relationship between subjective beliefs and commitment contract take-up. Specifically, we will run a two-session modification of the survey-based experiment from Augenblick and Rabin (2019). We ask participants to predict the number of tasks they will do in the current session and in the next session for various wages, and also elicit the number of tasks they want themselves to do in the next session. We offer participants commitment contracts to perform a target number of Greek transcription tasks. Leveraging natural uncertainty, we collect participants’ subjective beliefs about the full distribution of how many tasks they think they will do in the future and collect their beliefs about the probability of reaching the target number of tasks both without and with the commitment contract.
We experimentally manipulate beliefs in two ways. First, we manipulate aspects of commitment contract. In particular, we record beliefs and commitment take-up under different task target numbers, different benefits of doing the task, and different penalties of missing the task target. Second, we inject uncertainty about when participants will perform future tasks, allowing us to manipulate beliefs without manipulating the contract itself.
Experimental design
This is a two-session study. Both sessions are conducted via a Qualtrics' survey. The study is a modified version of the one used in Augenblick and Rabin (2019). In this study, respondents make choices/predictions about how many Greek transcription tasks they will do. Each Greek transcription task involves transcribing a sentence of blurry Greek characters into their English counterpart.
In our study, we introduce commitment contracts to perform a target number of transcription tasks during Session 2. Under each contract there is a task target number, a base wage-per-task, and a penalty wage-per-task (which is less than the base wage-per-task). If the contract is accepted and enacted, the respondent is paid the base wage-per-task if they complete the target number of tasks (or more) and is paid the penalty wage-per-task if they complete less tasks.
We have two different types of treatments:
1. Commitment contract treatment: We have three different commitment contract types, where each has a different base and penalty wage-per-task combination. Respondents are randomized to a type, i.e., each respondent is only asked questions about one type of commitment contract.
2. Session 2 date (un)certainty: Before answering questions related to Session 2 work (see below), respondents are randomized. Half are informed of the date that Session 2 will take place. The other half know that Session 2 will take place on one of three future dates and are informed that the Session 2 date will be revealed to them at the end of Session 1 (i.e., after answering questions related to Session 2 work).
-Thus, there are 6 treatment arms/combinations.
Session 1 Outline:
(1) Introduction and five practice/warm-up transcription tasks
(2) Survey questions:
(a) Current work: Respondents are asked to report how many tasks they would like to do at the end of the Current session for different (per-task) wages
(b) Each respondent is told that Session 2 may take place on one of three future dates. They are asked to rank these three days based on how certain they are about how busy they'll be on each day. Half of the respondents are then informed the date of Session 2, while the other half are informed that the date of Session 2 will be revealed at the end of the current session
(c) Work Predictions: Respondents are asked to predict how many tasks they think they will do during Session 2 for different wages
(d) Desired work: Respondents are asked to report how many tasks they'd like to do during Session 2 for different wages
(e) Respondents are asked how certain they are about their predictions in (c) and asked for reasons for any uncertainty
(f) Respondents are asked to provide their full subjective probability distribution of how many tasks they think they will do during Session 2. They are asked to provide this for two different per-task wages, one of which corresponds to the base wage-per-task for the commitment contract type they were assigned to
(g) Commitment contracts are introduced and explained and respondents answer several comprehension questions
(h) For different task target numbers, respondents are asked to provide their subjective beliefs about how likely they would be to reach the target IF the commitment contract was in effect
(i) For different task target numbers, respondents are asked whether they accept or decline each commitment contract
(3) Task Completion: A random (per-task) wage is selected. Respondents are then free to complete tasks for that wage.
Session 2 only involves (1), (2a), and (3) above. For (3), it is possible that a commitment contract accepted in Session 1 is enacted.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.