Evaluating the Impacts of Skills Training and Access to Digital Platforms on Female Domestic Workers in Bangladesh

How to cite

ANUKRITI, S; Lee, Jean; Bussolo, Maurizio; Williams, Anaise; Sharma, Siddharth. 2023. "Evaluating the Impacts of Skills Training and Access to Digital Platforms on Female Domestic Workers in Bangladesh." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009633. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9633-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

S ANUKRITI* , Jean Lee , Maurizio Bussolo , Anaise Williams , Siddharth Sharma

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009633
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9633-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2022-08-01 – 2024-04-15
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9633

Abstract

Despite the importance of domestic work globally as a source of employment opportunities for women, particularly women from low-income backgrounds, limited research has been done in the economics literature to assess or evaluate interventions in this sector. Our study proposes to evaluate the impacts of two types of interventions for female domestic workers in Bangladesh: 1) technical and life skills training and 2) access to digital work platforms that make it easier for female domestic workers to access new work opportunities. We plan to conduct a randomized controlled trial to assess the impacts of training and exposure to opportunities on digital labor platforms on the wellbeing of female domestic workers in Bangladesh. The study will help us understand the extent to which providing skills, including life and employability skills, and easing information frictions in the markets for informal labor can improve outcomes for female domestic workers in Bangladesh, a setting where an estimated 80 percent of the 1.3 million domestic workers are female.

Intervention

This trial will evaluate the joint and separate effects of two interventions. The first intervention is a skills training program developed by our partner NGO that seeks to build female domestic workers' life and occupational skills. The training covers interpersonal skills, literacy/numeracy, issue-based life skills, financial literacy, as well as imparts training specific to the skillset needed to be a successful domestic worker (namely, cooking, cleaning, etc.). The training is administered in groups of up to 20 women and takes a total of 14 full (non-consecutive) days.

The second intervention will facilitate onboarding of female domestic workers to an existing digital job platform operational in Bangladesh. This platform allows households looking to hire a domestic worker to match with a female domestic worker searching for a job via a phone-based app in a manner similar to Handy or Uber. Domestic workers can use a feature phone or a smartphone to register on this platform and find domestic work. The app allows options for the domestic worker to take an instant job, in which an appointment is scheduled for an agreed-upon amount of time for a set of tasks. Domestic workers receive appointments through automated calls on their phone and are paid through digital phone-based banking. The onboarding process will comprise a 3-4 hour-long in-person orientation session, followed by an phone-based IVR training to improve workers' familiarity and comfort with the job platform. The app rewards workers with small payments for completing the IVR training.

Experimental design

We use a clustered RCT (randomized controlled trial) strategy to identify the causal link between the interventions and outcomes of interest. Our baseline sample comprises 4,391 domestic workers in 238 clusters or "training groups". The unit of observation will be a female domestic worker but randomization will take place at the cluster level. We divide our sample into 4 arms with approximately equal number of groups:

1. Skills training arm
2. App onboarding arm
3. Skills training + App onboarding arm
4. Control arm

Using individual-level regressions, we will estimate intent-to-treat effects as follows:
a. To determine the effect of skills training, we will compare endline outcomes of respondents assigned to the Skills training arm with respondents assigned to the control arm.
b. To determine the effect of app onboarding, we will compare endline outcomes of respondents assigned to the app onboarding arm with respondents assigned to the control arm.
c. To determine the joint effect of skills training and app onboarding, we will compare endline outcomes of respondents assigned to the skills training + app onboarding arm with respondents assigned to the control arm.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was conducted using STATA 17.0 in an office. Random assignment of training groups was stratified on neighborhood, training group size, and percent of the group that is currently working as a domestic worker.
Randomization unit
Training groups
Clusters
238 training groups
Observations
4,391 female domestic workers
Arms
61 training groups - Skills training only 59 training groups- Skills training plus app onboarding 57 training groups- App onboarding only 61 training groups- Control
Primary outcomes
a. Whether respondent is currently working as a domestic worker at endline b. Respondent's monthly earnings from domestic work (in the last month before endline) c. Respondent's monthly earnings from non-domestic work (in the last month before endline) d. Number of houses worked for by the respondent as a domestic worker during the past week at endline e. Respondent's hours spent on paid domestic work during the past week at endline f. Respondent's hours spent searching for domestic work during the past week at endline g. Whether respondent is registered on a digital job search platform at endline h. Whether respondent is an active user of a digital job search platform at endline i. Whether respondent found at least one job through a digital job search platform during the intervention period j. Whether respondent has tried to negotiate (salary/ hours/ something else) with an employer during the intervention period k. Respondent's bargaining power relative to employers / outside option
Secondary outcomes
The following variables for the respondent will be used as secondary outcomes: a. Job satisfaction at endline b. Unmet job needs at endline (i.e., gap between desired and actual attributes of a job) c. Distance/ commuting time to job at endline d. Workplace abuse experienced during the intervention period e. Agency at endline f. Experience of IPV and spousal control during the last 6 months or intervention period g. Mental and physical health at endline h. Social connections (job-related and others) at endline i. Locus of control at endline j. Mobile phone ownership at endline k. Ability/ comfort with mobile phone use at endline i . Whether respondent has a mobile money account in her name at endline j. Whether respondent received any payment for domestic work through her mobile money account during the intervention period m. Whether respondent has a skill certification n. Whether respondent is a part of a women's group/ union

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords