The role of coaching within bundled ultra-poor graduation programmes: Experimental evidence from Bangladesh
How to cite
Zizzamia, Rocco; Dercon, Stefan; Pople, Ashley; Sulaiman, Munshi; Matin, Imran; Das, Narayan. 2022. "The role of coaching within bundled ultra-poor graduation programmes: Experimental evidence from Bangladesh." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009618. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9618-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We study the effects of a "big-push" program providing large asset transfers, coaching and other support to very poor women in rural Bangladesh. We focus in particular on the role of coaching within the programme, using an RCT implemented in 2016 to test whether changing the size and nature of the coaching element has lasting impacts on programme effectiveness.
Big push interventions have received much scholarly attention over the last decade, with most of these studies finding large, positive and enduring impacts of the programme on outcomes ranging from health and education, to asset holdings and political involvement. However, since these interventions are really a composite bundle consisting of an asset transfer, consumption support, savings facilities, and regular training/coaching, less is known about what is driving impact and through what mechanisms. At the same time, a major draw-back of these programmes, with implications for scaling, is that they are expensive and logistically burdensome to implement. This study seeks to understand the role that the form and intensity of the coaching element of BRAC's Targeting the Ultra-Poor (TUP) programme has in explaining some key outcomes, and the mechanisms through which coaching has an impact on these outcomes.
Intervention
In 2016, BRAC implemented a forth phase of their Targeting the Ultra-Poor programme (TUP). The programme consisted of a one-off transfer of assets to ultra-poor women in Bangladesh, complemented by regular coaching through home visits and/or group meetings, consumption support, access to savings facilities and other social services. In this phase of the TUP, BRAC introduced experimental variation in the intensity and mode of delivery of the coaching element of the graduation model.
The traditional model has been built with substantial coaching of recipients. This coaching aims to support the beneficiaries in their day-to-day actions, providing moral support and simple advice leading to behavioural and attitudinal change. However, this coaching is expensive. For this reason, BRAC experimented with implementing variations of the TUP model in which the intensity and mode of delivery of the coaching element was modified. Specifically, three variations were tested, corresponding to three treatment conditions:
T1: All transfers accompanied with weekly ``home visits” by staff for individualized coaching
T2: All transfers accompanied with fortnightly ``home visits” by staff for individualized coaching
T3: All transfers accompanied with fortnightly ``home visits” by staff for individualized coaching and fortnightly group meetings
Among the three coaching variations the weekly visit (T1) has the highest intensity and operational cost. This variant represents the approach to coaching that was used in BRAC TUP programmes prior to 2016. The second treatment arm (T2) is designed to test whether reducing the coaching intensity by half (from weekly to fortnightly home visits) results in a reduction in impact (on our primary outcomes -- see Section \ref{measurement}) that is higher than the reduction in operational costs. Finally, the third treatment (T3) includes a fortnightly group meeting along with fortnightly household visits, resulting in a variation in coaching intensity with operational costs somewhere between T1 and T2. Besides the cost-effectiveness aspect, the group meeting is also a potential way of creating social networks among the beneficiaries. In addition, group-based coaching may be complementary to one-on-one house visits in other ways, for instance, representing a potentially more interactive and engaging approach to hard- and soft-skill acquisition, a more binding form of commitment device, and allowing recipients to learn from the experiences of other recipients. Importantly, T3 is closest to the approach to the coaching element in the TUP design which was adopted by BRAC from 2017 onward.
Experimental design
In its fourth phase of the Ultra-Poor Graduation (UPG) programme (starting in 2016) BRAC implemented an RCT in Bangladesh to test three variants of the programme in which the form and intensity of the coaching element was experimentally varied. A baseline survey was conducted in 2016 prior to rolling out the randomized interventions. Baseline surveys were completed by 8,468 recipients and their households. The baseline survey drew a sample of between 50 and 200 eligible ultra-poor households from each branch. Our analysis of this RCT will be based on an endline survey on the beneficiaries and an additional sample of non-beneficiaries. Data collection on this endline survey began on the 7th of June 2022, and is expected to be completed within two months -- by early-to-mid August 2022.
Figure 1 (see analysis plan) summarizes the RCT design. The study covers 88 branch offices (the smallest unit in BRAC’s administrative structure) from 11 districts. These 88 branches were then randomly assigned into three treatment groups and a control group of 22 branches each (stratified by district) where
a) T1: All transfers accompanied with weekly ``home visits” by staff for individualized coaching (n = 2,101 at BL)
b) T2: All transfers accompanied with fortnightly ``home visits” by staff for individualized coaching (n = 2,358 at BL)
c) T3: All transfers accompanied with fortnightly ``home visits” by staff for individualized coaching and fortnightly group meetings (n = 2,297 at BL)
d) Control (n = 1,712 at BL)
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.