Your Choice: Randomised Controlled Trial of a CBT Informed Violence Reduction Programme

How to cite

Rasul, Imran; Dias, Monica Costa; Cattan, Sarah; Eeve, Laura van der. 2022. "Your Choice: Randomised Controlled Trial of a CBT Informed Violence Reduction Programme." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009611. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9611-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Imran Rasul* , Monica Costa Dias , Sarah Cattan , Laura van der Eeve

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009611
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9611-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2022-07-01 – 2023-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I0, J0
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9611

Abstract

This small-scale pilot evaluates the roll out of Your Choice, an intervention designed by the London Violence Reduction Unit and the Association of London Directors of Children's Services, and developed in partnership with the Children and Adolescent Mental Health Service. Your Choice targets 11-17 year-olds entitled to public support for being at medium to high risk of harm or engagement in crime and violent behaviour. It aims to reduce violent and anti-social behaviour among them, by delivering an intensive schedule of meetings (three contacts per week for 12 weeks) with the youth workers coaching them, and by introducing elements of Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) in their interactions. To that end, it provides specialist training in a range of CBT techniques to youth workers and clinical supervision of coaches through their delivery of the programme to the young people. This project will provide qualitative and quantitative evaluations of the pilot phase of the intervention, where the latter will use a randomized control trial methodology to assess the very short run impacts of the intervention on emotional and behavioural outcomes for young people.

Intervention

Your Choice: a programme designed and developed by the London Violence Reduction Unit in collaboration with the Association of London Directors of Children’s Services and the Children and Adolescent Mental Health Service. The intervention is targeted at young people, aged 11-17, who are judged (by their local education, social care, justice and/or medical systems) to be at medium to high risk of harm or of engaging in violent and anti-social behaviour, and who are eligible to receive publicly-provided assistance in dealing with these problems. The intervention has three main components:

1. A 1-week intensive training of youth workers (who are social workers in direct contact with young people in the target group) on techniques and tools used in Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (CBT). The training is delivered by lead practitioners.
2. An intensive programme of three weekly meetings between each young person enrolled in the treatment and their trained youth worker, for the duration of 12 weeks.
3. Regular clinical supervision of trained youth workers, delivered by the trainer therapist individually or in groups, to revise the cases of each young person participating in Your Choice and the practical delivery of CBT techniques.

Experimental design

Local Authorities (LAs), which are the local government units in the UK, deliver a bundle of supporting services to young people, and particularly to those in the target group for Your Choice. London has 32 LAs, and they have all been commissioned by the London Violence Reduction Unit to deliver Your Choice by integrating the new programme within the range of other services they normally provide to our target population of youth. The delivery of these services is implemented by teams of 4-5 youth workers, organised at the LA level by intervention areas (e.g. Youth Offending Service, Gangs and Exploitation, Adolescent Safeguarding, etc). There are usually various teams in the same intervention area within each LA.

Randomization happens within LA, at the team level. London LAs provided us with the full list of teams that are in direct contact with young people in Your Choice target group. They also identified the full list of teams that are currently available to be trained in CBT techniques. All LAs named at least two teams that are ready for training. From this list of eligible teams, the evaluators will randomly select one or two teams per LA. Wherever possible, teams will be randomly selected within intervention area. Selected teams will be trained; randomized-out teams will form the control group.

Our research design relies on the fact that LA youth services operate at capacity. This implies that each time a new young person joins the services, the team that takes on the case will be the one in the relevant set of services that has fewer cases in their stock. This suggests that the assignment of young people to teams, conditional on Local Authority and service type, is as good as random – an assumption we will carefully test using the wealth of information that will be gathered about the participants during the pilot.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in the office by a computer.
Randomization unit
Teams of youth practitioners (operating each within a particular youth service and local authority). Wherever possible, treated and control teams will be selected from the same youth service within each local authority.
Clusters
We aim to have 32 youth practitioners teams to be selected (one in each local authority in London). At least one control team will be available in each local authority.
Observations
Based on the results of an earlier survey to local authorities, we expect treated teams to enrol at least 4 new children in Your Choice each month.
Arms
If the pilot runs for two months, we expect to have 4 x 2 x 32 = 256 young people assigned to treated teams of youth practitioners. At least the same number of young people will be assigned to control teams.
Primary outcomes
Emotional and behavioural difficulties and pro-sociality assessed using the Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ).
Secondary outcomes
Engagement and exposure to crime and violence, as measured by a scale co-produced by the evaluation and project teams administered to both the young person and their lead practitioner. Social connectedness, measured by a subscale of the the Student Resilience Survey. Mental Well-Being, measured by The Short Warwick–Edinburgh Mental Well-being Scale (SWEMWBS). Self-efficacy, measured by the New General Self-Efficacy Scale. Self-regulation, measured by the Trait Emotional Intelligence Questionnaire – Adolescent Short Form (teique-asf) – self-regulation subscale.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords