Transparency in anti-poverty programs
How to cite
Hanna, Rema; Sumarto, Sudarno; Kyle, Jordan; Olken, Benjamin A.; Banerjee, Abhijit. 2014. "Transparency in anti-poverty programs." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000096. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.96-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The Raskin program is a national program by the Government of Indonesia (GOI) that provides subsidized rice to the poor. It is the largest social assistance program in Indonesia. However, many households fail to receive their entitled subsidy. The study aims to test two aspects: (1) whether providing identification cards for beneficiaries reduces leakages and (2) whether allowing competition for the right to distribute Raskin within the village will improve the program efficiency. The project is being conducted in 572 villages and comprises two phases. During the first phase, the GOI is testing the effect of providing beneficiaries with Government issued different types of Raskin ID cards and is testing whether the effect of the cards differs by how intensive the information campaigns surrounding the cards is. During the project’s second phase, we will randomly assign the village to either a community distribution treatment, an information treatment, or a control group. In the community distribution treatment, community members will be given a chance to bid for the right to distribute Raskin in randomly selected villages (the parameters of the bidding are also being varied); in the monitoring treatment, meetings will be held to provide information on the state of the Raskin program to community members.
Intervention
Intervention (1): Test the effect of providing identification cards to beneficiaries. This is done by introducing identification cards for Raskin beneficiary households in 378 villages (out of 572 villages). In 192 of these villages (randomly selected), there will be an enhanced information campaign on how to use the identification cards, consisting of a one-time meeting with village leaders and additional informational posters in the villages.
Intervention (2): Engage community in the distribution of Raskin in the village, by conducting an open bid process to determine who distributes Raskin (in 191 villages), or by conducting a community meeting to disseminate information on how Raskin is distributed (in 96 villages)
Experimental design
We sampled 572 villages, each of which possessed Raskin beneficiary households. Out of these 572 villages, 378 villages were randomly selected to receive Raskin identification cards. Of these 378 villages, 192 villages were visited by facilitators, who posted informational posters in the village and conducted a meeting with the village’s community leaders to explain how the Raskin card is used.
After six months, facilitators return to 287 out of the 572 villages above, where we engage the community in the distribution of Raskin in the village, by conducting an open bid to determine who distributes Raskin (in 191 villages), or by conducting a community meeting to disseminate information on how Raskin is distributed (in 96 villages).
The goal is to compare the outcome of those receiving Raskin identification cards, enhanced socialization and/or community engagement (the control group) with those who did not (the control group) in order to estimate the impacts of increasing program transparency of and engaging community in the distribution of Raskin. We will interview households in the 572 villages over the course of a year (specifically after 3 months, 7 months and 14 months) to conduct short and longer-term follow-ups.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.