The Gender (Dis)comfort Gap: the Effects of Gender on Everyday Interactions
How to cite
Dillon, Andrea; Gulzar, Saad; Mousa, Salma. 2022. "The Gender (Dis)comfort Gap: the Effects of Gender on Everyday Interactions." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009593. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9593-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
How (un)comfortable are inter-gender interactions in Muslim societies? A gender gap in economic and political integration persists in many parts of the Muslim world, yet interpersonal contact across gender lines as a driver of these gaps — as well as a potential remedy — has not been systematically studied.
This project has three goals. We propose an RCT that will first establish descriptive statistics about the prevalence of one particularly restrictive gender norm – the norm against unrelated men and women speaking to each other. This norm is thought to prevent women from participating in public spaces and the labor force, yet we lack basic facts about its prevalence. Second, we will experimentally test two mechanisms that plausibly drive this norm — concerns about women’s safety, and notions of “purity” — directly against each other. Finally, we will then explore a second RCT to erode this norm. Focusing on the workplace arrangement of gender segregation, we will explore the possibility of randomizing contact via gender-integrated vs. segregated workplace teams to study impacts on gender-progressive attitudes and behaviors concerning women’s economic integration, women’s safety, and notions of purity.
Intervention
The study aims to establish how gender shapes everyday interactions globally. We evaluate the impact of the three behavioral interventions, which include (i) a confederate asking the pedestrians for simple directions, (ii) a confederate dropping groceries near the pedestrians, and (iii) a confederate borrowing a cellphone from a pedestrian. The procedure allows us to quantify the inter-gender (dis)comfort gap in different types of interactions, as well as two different types of causal effects: (1) the effects of a stranger’s gender on an individual’s trust, (2) the effects of the costliness of the interaction – ranging from low cost (responding to a request for directions when asked) to high cost (going out of one’s way to help pick up groceries or lending one’s cellphone). We randomize both of these elements (the confederate’s gender, and the interaction type), allowing for the estimation of causal effects. Our goal is to run this experiment in several countries across the world to document the prevalence of the broader phenomenon of (dis)comfort with inter-gender interactions.
Experimental design
The study estimates the causal effects of everyday contact with individuals from different genders. The study consists of three treatment arms.
First, we randomize whether the confederate is female or male. Second, we then randomize the interaction – the subject will either be asked for directions or a cellphone, or the confederate will drop groceries on the street, in view of several pedestrians. Third – and this treatment arm applies only to the asking-for-directions and borrowing cellphone experiments – we randomize whether the subject chosen for the experiment is female or male. Note that we do not randomize the gender identity of the subjects in the groceries experiment, as all pedestrians close enough to observe the groceries being dropped are considered subjects.
A nearby confederate then documents the pedestrians’ comfort level via outcomes such as whether the pedestrian acknowledged the confederate, stopped to engage or walk away, and attempted to give directions / help with groceries / lend their cellphones or not.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.