Cultural institutions: The Effect of Physical and Digital Layouts on Visitor Experience (Part 2)
How to cite
Deshmane, Abhishek; Albéniz, Victor Martínez de; Aouad, Ali. 2022. "Cultural institutions: The Effect of Physical and Digital Layouts on Visitor Experience (Part 2)." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009585. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9585-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
A fundamental operational decision faced by museums and other major cultural institutions is the design of a display arrangement for their collection of items (artworks, objects, media contents), which in turn affects the visitors' interactions with the offered experiences. In this project, we collaborate with the Van Gogh Museum in Amsterdam to carry out experiments that help us causally identify potential links between layout-level decisions made by the experience providers and the visitor engagement, satisfaction levels, and learnings. The multimedia guides provided by the museum help us record visitors' movements and activities across time and space through granular event logs. Hence, the visitors navigate through both the physical layout, i.e. the arrangement of exhibits on display, and the digital layout, i.e. the tour of "Highlight" artworks recommended by the multimedia guide. We intend to analyse the interplay between these two types of content provision on the way visitors interact with the exhibits.
This study is the second part of our experimentation programme, where we test an optimized version of the Highlights tour displayed by the multimedia guide. Using a data-driven model and a simulation-based optimization algorithm, we identify a modified composition of the Highlights tour to increase the expected length of visitors' paths. Our intervention consists in removing three artworks from the Highlights tour and adding three other ones in replacement. We study the differences in the sequential choices made by the visitors across the treatment and control groups. The corresponding effect on the visitor engagement is measured, on a first level, through a Difference-in-Differences methodology; on a second level, we use a path-based Multinomial Logit model developed in previous research (paper in writing with same authors using historical observational data).
Experimental design
The Van Gogh Museum provides multimedia guides (MMT) to its visitors, a standard offering across many museums in the world. The objective of MMTs is to enable visitors to engage with the artworks on display in an informed and interactive way. As a result of this, the visitors not only navigate the physical space in the museum, but also they also browse through the digital layout of the multimedia guide. Both types of content provision affect how visitors progress within the museum and their encounters with artworks. The MMT provides the recommendation of a 'Highlights tour' that covers the masterpieces of the museum, as well as a longer, more exploratory 'Leisure tour', which includes a number of additional artworks on display. In this study, we intend to understand the effect of the selection of artworks recommended by the MMT on visitor engagement.
Our previous research in collaboration with the Van Gogh Museum yielded a stochastic choice model to describe visitors' sequential exploration of the museum collection based on the MMT clickstream data. In this study, we leverage this model to construct an "optimized" Highlights tour based on counterfactual simulations. Our algorithm determines a subset of three artworks on the Highlights tour that are replaced by three other ones with the goal of maximising the expected number of artworks viewed by visitors, subject to various practical constraints imposed by the museum. We track the effect of this change is on visitor activity, measured by usage data of the MMT guide, and on visitor satisfaction levels, tracked through post-visit online surveys.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.