Avoiding Dissonant Information

How to cite

Cibik, Ceren Bengu. 2022. "Avoiding Dissonant Information." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009582. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9582-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ceren Bengu Cibik*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009582
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9582-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2022-08-16 – 2023-02-16
Countries
United States of America ()
JEL codes
C91, C99, D83, D91
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9582

Abstract

I examine firstly whether individuals pay to avoid dissonant information and secondly if the amount they are willing to pay varies based on their prior exposure to dissonant information and their beliefs. In experiments with US respondents, participants were randomly allocated to an article to read that either agreed with or opposed their prior self-reported beliefs. The participants then answered some incentivized questions based on the article they were assigned to. Subsequently, all participants were allocated to a second article that was inconsistent with their prior beliefs but were then provided with the option to pay to switch the conflicting article with one that is consistent with their beliefs. Participants were then asked to quantify the monetary value they were willing to forgo in order to switch articles. I measure the proportion of participants who were willing to pay to avoid completing an effort task on a dissonant article and their maximum willingness to pay to avoid it. Finally, I compare the proportion of people who are willing to pay to switch articles and the amount they are willing to pay to switch articles depending on their beliefs and their prior exposure to a dissonant view.

Experimental design

The experiment seeks to examine how varying beliefs about abortion rights and prior exposure to dissonant information affect information and attention avoidance. The experiment starts by asking participants' opinions on abortion rights: Pro-choice or Pro-life. I filter only Pro-choice participants for Session 1 and only Pro-life participants for Session 2 of the experiment. Then, I provide subjects with an effort task which includes reading a short article and answering some questions based on the article. Subjects are told that they will receive 0.10 $ per correct answer they give to these questions. Half of the subjects are randomly allocated to a consonant group (i.e. the article is in line with their beliefs on abortion rights) and the other half are randomly allocated to a dissonant group (i.e. the article is against their beliefs on abortion rights). It means that half of the subjects in each session complete the effort task on an article which is in line with their beliefs on abortion rights and the other half of the subjects in each session complete the effort task on an article which is against their beliefs on abortion rights. The content and which side of the argument the article supports are made clear by giving participants the title of the article and a sentence-long summary of its content. Once they answer the questions based on the article they are randomly allocated to in the first stage, subjects are presented with a different article in the same way as before (i.e first title and a sentence-long summary). However, this time before moving on to reading the article, they are asked if they would like to switch the article assigned to them with a different one which is in line with their prior beliefs on abortion. If they decide to switch articles, they are told that they can use the separate pot of 100 cents given to them at the beginning of the experiment. Any unused amount is added on top of their bonus payments. Once they indicate their preference to switch articles and their willingness to pay, a random number between 0 and 100 is drawn. If their maximum willingness to pay to switch articles is greater than or equal to the random number, the article that is assigned to them (against their beliefs on abortion) is replaced by another one (in line with their beliefs on abortion) to complete the task. If their maximum willingness to pay is less than the random number, then the article which is against their beliefs is not replaced by the one which is in line with their beliefs. Depending on the result of the lottery and their willingness to pay, subjects complete the effort task in the final article.
I also ask some questions about participants' beliefs and background characteristics such as posterior beliefs on abortion rights, political beliefs, media consumption, demographic information, risk preference, and information preference scale (IPS) (Ho et al, 2021).

See the attached documents (the transcripts and the experimental overview and analysis plan), which include more detail regarding the questions asked, treatments, subject recruitment and exclusion criteria.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is done by Qualtrics
Randomization unit
Individual level
Clusters
NA
Observations
1000 subjects Any small deviations from these exact figures will be due to sampling discrepancies generated by the Prolific platform.
Arms
250 subjects in each treatment. ( 500 participants from the Pro-life group and 500 from the Pro-choice group. 50% of each group will be assigned to a dissonant group and the remaining 50% will be assigned to a consonant group.)
Primary outcomes
The proportion of subjects who are willing to pay to avoid dissonant information, The mean amount of money subjects are willing to pay to avoid dissonant information
Secondary outcomes
The performance of subjects in tasks with opposite beliefs, attention avoidance, gender, age (generation), state of residence (USA), political view and extremism, information avoidance scale, belief updating, media consumption, the extremism of the belief on abortion rights. Tertiary: other demographics

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords