Early Childhood Development for the Poor: Impacting at Scale
How to cite
Meghir, Konstantinos (Costas); Phimister, Angus; Jervis, Pamela; Codina, Marta; Grantham-McGregor, Sally; Caeyers, Bet; Augsburg, Britta; Attanasio, Orazio; Day, Monimalika; Pahwa, Smriti; Behrman, Jere. 2015. "Early Childhood Development for the Poor: Impacting at Scale." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000958. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.958-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Neurobiological science has established that the first three years of life lay the basis for lifelong outcomes due to the rapid development of the brain. During this period, children are also vulnerable to negative influences of a number of biological and psychosocial factors such as malnutrition, illness and unstimulating environments. These factors may be induced by poverty and may have a detrimental effect on children’s health and development, including physical, cognitive, language and motor development. Research has shown that approaches to early childhood development (ECD) that involve psychosocial stimulation and/or nutrition are effective in mitigating influences of negative factors. Our aim is to understand the cost, sustainability and effects of such approach and the mechanisms needed for these early years’ interventions to be effective in poor populations. We need to know how the interventions change beliefs, knowledge and parenting practices as well as the specific investments (in time and resources) that parents and caregivers make in child rearing. We need to identify how specific investment choices are translated into individual child development outcomes. Our research agenda comprises evaluating two different modes of delivering an ECD intervention coupled with nutritional information through a randomised control trial in 192 villages in rural Odisha. Odisha provides an excellent setting for the study as it represents a prototypical context of low levels of stimulation, high malnutrition, poor developmental outcomes and extreme levels of poverty. The study will permit us to learn the extent to which an early childhood stimulation and nutrition intervention is feasible and effective in improving child health and development in low-income and disadvantaged environments.
Intervention
We will carry out a psycho-social stimulation programme coupled with nutrition education that aims to improve interactions between mothers or principal caregivers and their infants/children with the aim of achieving better child outcomes. The programme follows a systematic weekly curriculum based on the natural developmental stages of the child. Alternative service provisions include delivery of the curriculum by local women either (i) during weekly individual home visits to mother and child, or (ii) in a suitably modified way, within the context of weekly mother-child group meetings. The intervention will last for 24 months and will be evaluated using a randomised control trial. We will collect data on child development outcomes and detailed maternal and household level data before the start, half way through and at the end of the intervention. Our focus will be on communities in rural areas of Odisha and will involve children aged 7-16 months. We propose to implement and compare four variants of our intervention:
1. Provision of education on nutritional issues (hereafter referred to as “NE”): Regular visits to the home will be carried out by local women hired and trained for the project (henceforth referred to as educators) to deliver the nutritional education curriculum, which will be designed to produce positive changes in food choice, preparation and storage.
2. Individual Stimulation via Home Visits (IS) (+ NE): Weekly visits to the home will be carried out by local women hired and trained for the project (henceforth referred to as facilitators) to deliver the stimulation curriculum and involve mother and child in play and learning activities.
3. Group Stimulation (GS) (+ NE): In this variant, the facilitator will deliver a specially-designed version of the stimulation curriculum to a group of mothers and children. The group will meet weekly and is planned to have a maximum of 9 mothers and children.
4. Health and Nutritional Services Link (HNSL): A basic intervention that strengthens links with the existing services will be available to all study arms, including the control group. The aim of offering the basic service to all is to create a baseline where the current policy framework is well understood. We then measure our intervention over and above a status quo, which encourages take-up of policy as is now.
Experimental design
The evaluation design will be based on a cluster randomized trial in which a target sample of 192 villages with the selected facilitators/educators will be allocated randomly to intervention variants 1 to 3 described above and a control group. In total, there will be 48 villages in each intervention arm, including the control.
Within each village we intend to treat and collect data on all children aged 7-16 months at the start of the intervention. We estimated an average of 7.5 children in this age group per community based on data from our sanitation project in similar villages. However, in our final sample of 192 villages, this average was around 14. Since our budget did not allow for treatment of so many more children, we adopted the following approach:
- In villages with 8 children or less (one third of the 192 villages), we took all children to be part of the study.
- In the remaining villages, we chose one eligible child at random and thereafter included in the sample those additional seven children that live geographically speaking closest to the randomly chosen child.
This approach ensures that even in villages with relatively large populations and spread, our target children would come from the same neighbourhood, hence facilitating intervention implementation. Similarly, it allows to have a clear criteria for inclusion into (exclusion out of) the intervention. On the one hand, we have a clear age cut-off, on the other hand a geographical clustering. It may also improve the quality of the intervention if all mothers of children in a particular age group in the villages interact and provide social support for each other regarding child-rearing practices. Finally, this will be consistent with scaling-up the program to full coverage.
Villages are randomised to the different intervention arms as we expect the interventions to have spillover within villages. By randomizing across villages we allow for possible spillovers within villages that may increase the overall impacts.
Indeed part of our evaluation design is to measure such spillovers, which if there may be an important conduit for propagating and reinforcing good practice in child rearing. To do so, we will in addition to our target children, interview households of mothers with children below and above the target age range (2-6 months and 17-20 months). In total, 767 such spillover-households will be included in the sample.
To summarize, the total sample sizes will be 1,451 families with children in the 7-16 month age range at project start and 767 children outside the treatment age range, distributed among three groups of 48 intervention villages and one group of 48 control villages.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.