Public-Private Partnerships: Causal Evidence from Colombia

How to cite

Barrera-Osorio, Felipe; Dustan, Andrew; Carvajal-Osorio, Luis; Zhang, Xinjie. 2023. "Public-Private Partnerships: Causal Evidence from Colombia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009563. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9563-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Felipe Barrera-Osorio* , Andrew Dustan , Luis Carvajal-Osorio , Xinjie Zhang

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009563
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9563-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-02-13 – 2025-01-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
O1, I20
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9563

Abstract

Public-private partnerships (PPPs) have the potential to expand the supply of high-quality education in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), fostering economic development by building human capital and creating more equitable access to effective schools. PPPs in this context typically consist of private providers educating low-income students, sometimes using public infrastructure, according to a contract with the government that stipulates performance criteria. While much is known about the operation and performance of such partnerships in high-income countries, such as charter schools in the United States, evidence from LMICs is scarce. This project leverages centralized assignment of students to schools in Colombia and rich data on both student backgrounds and outcomes to understand if and how PPPs generate benefits in a LMIC setting, focusing on both cognitive and non-cognitive outcomes. The findings will inform the design and implementation of PPPs not only in Colombia, but more broadly, where governments wish to expand the supply of high-quality education in low-income settings.

Experimental design

We use rank-ordered lists of applicants to oversubscribed schools in administration to define our sample. The Secretary of Education of the District (SED) in Bogota conducted a pairwise randomization for each of the applicant lists. Students were sorted in a descending order by a priority index, which was designed to give certain weights to particular criteria such as closeness to the school, victim status, or household wealth. Then, pairs within each lists were formed. One of the students of the pair was assigned to a school in administration and the other was assigned to a regular public school.

The way the student pairs were constructed implies that the two students should be similar to each other in terms of sociodemographic characteristics. Taking advantage of that similarity within a pair, we will estimate the causal effect of attending a school in administration by comparing treated and control students within their respective peers.

The uncontrolled estimating equation is as follows:

y_{ip} = constant + β*(treat)_{ip} + u_{ip}

The controlled estimating equation follows:

y_{ip} = constant + β*(treat)_{ip} + Γ'X_{ip} + u_{ip},

where X are the components of the priority index for student i in pair p, recorded prior to treatment assignment in the administrative database of the school assignment system, as well as student age and gender.

As a robustness check, we will also estimate a model with pairwise fixed effects. We note that the power of this specification depends on the rate of missingness in the student-level data, as pairs with one missing student will necessarily be dropped (in contrast to the previous specification without pairwise fixed effects):

y_{ip} = β*(treat)_{ip} + Γ'X_{ip} + λ_{p} + u_{ip}

where y_{ip} denotes an outcome of interest for student i in pair p, treat is an indicator variable that takes a value of 1 if the student attends a school in administration, X_{ip} is a vector containing student age and gender, and λ_{p} denote pair fixed effects.

We will explicitly estimate heterogeneity with respect to two dimensions:
- Gender
- Identity of provider operating the school in administration.

Design details

Randomization method
The Secretary of Education of the District (SED) used a computer to implement an algorithm that sorted students by priority order, formed adjacent pairs in that priority ordering, and determined admission offers randomly within that pair.
Randomization unit
Students who are applying for admissions to the first grade offered by schools in administration.
Clusters
1,502 students.
Observations
1,502 students.
Arms
The sample of 1,502 students is divided evenly: 751 students are assigned to a school in administration and the remaining 751 are assigned to a regular public school.
Primary outcomes
- Student score on PPVT - Student score on MODEL quantitative instrument modules (Number Identification) - Student score on MODEL executive function instrument modules (Head, Toes, Knees and Shoulders, Forward Digit Span, Backward Digit Span, Pencil Tap) - Student score on MODEL socioemotional development modules (Perspective-Taking/Empathy, Understanding Feelings)
Secondary outcomes
- Parental expenditure/year on educational materials (Question H7_14 in household survey) - Index of parental time investment in child (see explanation below) - Index of parental involvement with school (see explanation below) - Number of parent-reported school absences (Questions H4_2 and H4_4 in household survey) - Index of parent-reported perception of the school environment (see explanation below)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords