Measuring Women’s and Youths’ Informal Work in Non-Urban Settings: Evidence from El Salvador
How to cite
Dinarte, Lelys; Palacios-Lopez, Amparo; Costa, Valentina; Contreras, Ivette. 2022. "Measuring Women’s and Youths’ Informal Work in Non-Urban Settings: Evidence from El Salvador." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009541. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9541-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Measuring informal work is crucial for policy making, especially in development countries where informal work represents a high share of employment. Moreover, existing evidence shows that reporting engagement in work-related activities may differ across population groups. For the case of El Salvador, official data shows that women that answer by themselves register a lower participation rate than when data is reported by another household member. This behavior could be endogenous, since women are more likely to be at home so they perceive that they are not working, but it can also be that they are more likely to underreport.
The objective of this project is threefold. First, it aims to advance our understanding of how to obtain improved measures of labor, especially of those activities that tend to be underestimated in households’ surveys, such as informal and sporadic activities. More specifically, this project will provide experimental evidence on how to improve data collection on informal work, focusing on women and youth in non-urban (rural and peri-urban) areas. Second, it will also explore if the type of respondent (self or proxy) affects how labor participation is measured. Finally, this project aims to provide evidence on women’s and youths’ preferences on formal work attributes.
To achieve the first two goals, the plan is to design and implement a survey experiment to measure and compare the impact of different methods of collecting information on informal work and of the type of informant. The evidence on women's and youths' preferences for formal work attributes will be obtained from a discrete choice experiment inspired in Datta (2019).
Intervention
This project aims to advance our understanding of how to obtain improved measures of labor, especially of those activities that are usually miscounted in household surveys such as causal and sporadic activities.
There are two interventions in this trial:
• Members of the households assigned to treatment group 1 will be exposed to an additional survey module (Activities Module) before collecting their labor information. The Activities Module includes a list of the most common labor activities that people in their region do. The list is curated to use to provide examples of different income-generating activities that can be considered as work for statistical purposes.
• Members of the households assigned to treatment group 2 should provide their labor information by themselves (as opposed to using a proxy respondent as is common in household surveys).
Moreover, all households will respond to a discrete choice experiment that aims to measure respondents' willingness to pay on different attributes related to formal employment.
Experimental design
Group status: Control group
Type of labor module: Standard (LSMS labor module following 19th, ICLS)
Type of respondent: Main household respondent or if another household member (15-64 years old) is present, he/she provides his/her own information.
Group status: Treatment group 1
Type of labor module: New labor module that includes a new list of work activities
Type of respondent: Main household informant or if another household member (15-64 years old) is present, he/she provides his/her own information
Group status: Treatment group 2
Type of labor module: Standard (LSMS labor module following 19th, ICLS)
Type of respondent: Only self-respondents, selected household members (15-64 years old) must provide their own information
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.