Evidence-based Cooling Strategies for a Warming World: Assessing Demand for Efficient Fans in India

How to cite

Fowlie, Meredith; Deshmukh, Ranjit; Venkateswaran, Jayendran. 2022. "Evidence-based Cooling Strategies for a Warming World: Assessing Demand for Efficient Fans in India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009524. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9524-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Meredith Fowlie* , Ranjit Deshmukh , Jayendran Venkateswaran

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009524
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9524-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2020-01-01 – 2023-04-01
Countries
Private
JEL codes
Q41, Q54, Q56
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9524

Abstract

As global temperatures rise, more people are exposed to heat-related risks. Coping with heat extremes is particularly challenging for people with lower socioeconomic status who cannot afford air conditioning. A recent study estimates that over 300 million people in India are at high risk of extreme heat due to a lack of access to cooling (SE4ALL, 2022). Warmer temperatures are also straining India’s aging power system; electricity demand surges during hot weather events have triggered cascading outages across the country in recent years.

Delivery of sustainable and accessible cooling solutions in India will require innovation and intervention. Fans are the most common cooling appliance used by low-income households in India. Energy-efficient fans, which consume less than half the energy of standard induction fans, are rarely available in rural and peri-urban areas of India where a majority of low-income households live. Demand for energy-efficient appliances in these markets is perceived to be low, and the costs of building out distribution networks, marketing, and sales teams to support new product offerings are high.

We investigate the conditions under which rural households in India are willing and able to purchase energy-efficient BLDC fans. Working closely with India’s Energy Efficiency Services Limited (EESL) and a network of Self-Help Groups (SHGs) in Bihar, we combine a randomized control trial with a supply-side intervention that provides training for local shop owners in procurement, distribution, marketing, and sales support for energy-efficient fans. Fan purchase prices are randomized across customers and local warranty support is randomized across clusters of local shops.

The aims of this study are threefold (1) to determine the level of consumer demand for energy-efficient fans at different price points; (2) to determine whether demand at a given price point increases with investments in local supply chain/warranty support and (3) to assess the potential role of a well-established SHG network in accelerating the diffusion of energy-efficient fans to under-served, low-income market segments.

Intervention

Randomization of efficient BLDC fan purchase prices
Randomization of local warranty support
Supply-side support to facilitate local procurement/distribution/marketing/sales

Experimental design

First, we elicit the willingness-to-pay (WTP) for BLDC fans in a sales trial using an incentive-compatible BDM style mechanism. This demand elicitation activity takes place at local shops that are participating in our study. Households interested in purchasing a new fan make sales appointments. This sales trial design will allow us to determine consumer demand for energy-efficient fans at different price points.

Second, for half the of the participating shops, we provide additional training and warranty support. Households are informed about this local warranty support when they are being educated about the study. Communications provide information about how any problems with the fan can be locally addressed. EESL provides a 2.5-year warranty for BLDC fans. But the web-based warranty support system is ill-equipped to support low-income customers in far-flung markets. To augment the manufacturer's warranty, we provided a 3-month local warranty whereby households could get a free replacement or repair supported by the local shop if technical problems arise. Random assignment of warranty support will allow us to determine whether investments in local supply chain support increase consumer demand.

In addition, we will assess the potential role of local SHGs and associated local shops and distribution networks in bringing energy-efficient appliances to under-served, low-income markets.

Design details

Randomization method
Fan purchase price/subsidy randomization was done using scratch cards. Participants scratched off a purchase price after stating their willingness to pay for a fan. Local warranty support was randomly assigned across clusters.
Randomization unit
Fan purchase price was randomized across individuals. Local warranty support was randomly assigned across village clusters/solar shops.
Clusters
N/A
Observations
~1500 households 8 solar shops
Arms
The distribution of BDM prices was designed to fairly allocate prices across participants. There were 13 distinct price points. In expectation, we should have 115 participants assigned to each price point. The actual assignment will depend on which scratch card cells participants ultimately choose. Warranty support treatment is assigned to 4 randomly selected shops. The other 4 shops serve as controls.
Primary outcomes
Households' willingness to pay for a BLDC fan. Purchase/take-up of fans across a range of offered prices. Impact of local warranty support on WTP.
Secondary outcomes
To shed more light on what generates heterogeneity in WTP, we will conduct additional exploratory analysis to test whether WTP varies systematically with: • Baseline electricity expenditures/consumption levels • Baseline energy literacy/prior beliefs about energy intensity of end uses. • Baseline demographics (including income and savings) • Baseline risk aversion

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords