We Don’t Talk About Boys: An Experiment on Masculinity Norms in Brazil

How to cite

Matavelli, Ieda. 2022. "We Don’t Talk About Boys: An Experiment on Masculinity Norms in Brazil." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009508. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9508-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ieda Matavelli*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009508
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9508-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2022-06-15 – 2023-04-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
J16 D90 C93
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9508

Abstract

Social norms are sometimes misperceived, which has consequences for important
economic outcomes. However, little is known about why misperceptions exist in the first place. This project
focuses on the role of communication in shaping misperceptions, which I study in the context of masculinity
norms among 7th to 9th graders in urban Brazil, in collaboration with the Secretariat of Education of the
City of Rio. The study assigns treatment children to discussion groups to learn peers’ opinions about two
traditional beliefs about masculinity: men who cry are weak and men should use violence to get respect if necessary. To further investigate different types of communicators, half of treatment discussion groups allow children to volunteer to speak (vocal group) and half of treatment discussion groups randomly pre-select students to be invited to share (representative group). Control discussion groups focus on a masculinity-neutral topic (recycling).

Experimental design

For each participating school and classroom:

1) Classes are randomly split into three groups:

Masculinity Vocal (Treatment 1) X Recycling (Control)
Masculinity Representative (Treatment 2) X Recycling (Control)
Masculinity Vocal (Treatment 1) X Representative (Treatment 2)

2) Within classrooms, students are randomized into one of the groups Masculinity Vocal (Treatment 1), Masculinity Representative (Treatment 2), and Recycling (Control).

The intervention consists of a ≈20 minutes discussion about Masculinity (treatment group) or Recycling practices (control group). Masculinity groups are further split into two types of discussion. In the first, referred to as Masculinity Vocal, subjects are asked to voluntarily speak during their session. In the second, called Masculinity Representative, subjects are drawn ex-ante and called to speak in random order.

Randomization is stratified by sex, and it takes place ex-ante, based on the student list sent by the school Principal.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
Classrooms, students
Clusters
80-100 classrooms
Observations
2,000-2,500 students
Arms
Rough sample size*: 700 students in Masculinity Vocal 700 students in Masculinity Representative 700 students in Control *The sample size will depend on students' attendance on the day the study takes place and on the number of students who consented to participate.
Primary outcomes
Measured Immediately After Treatment - Misperceptions with respect to two beliefs about masculinity: Men Who Cry Are Weak and Men Should Use Violence to Get Respect if Necessary - Social image concerns with respect to self-reports on the last time they cried and the last time they initiated a physical fight, and antisocial behavior, measured by a form of the Joy of Destruction Game Measured About 3 Weeks After Treatment - Misperceptions with respect to two beliefs about masculinity: Men Who Cry Are Weak and Men Should Use Violence to Get Respect if Necessary - Peer reports on aggressive behaviors, conflict resolution, emotion-sharing, and respect towards girls
Secondary outcomes
Measured Immediately After Treatment - First-order beliefs about Men Who Cry Are Weak and Men Should Use Violence to Get Respect if Necessary (unlikely to be affected) - Social acceptance of crying and acting violently, illustrated by 3 vignettes Measured About 3 Weeks After Treatment - First-order beliefs about Men Who Cry Are Weak and Men Should Use Violence to Get Respect if Necessary - Self-reported behaviors about whether have participated in a physical fight, have cried in front of someone, have had a deep conversation with a friend - Instagram post about "positive" masculinity

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords