Impact evaluation of PROSPERA’s change on higher education scholarship recipients.
How to cite
Martinez, Sebastian; Araujo, Maria. 2016. "Impact evaluation of PROSPERA’s change on higher education scholarship recipients.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000944. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.944-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The Office of the National Coordination of PROSPERA, the conditional cash transfer program in Mexico, is considering implementing some adjustments to the design and operation of the program in order to improve the services provided to the beneficiaries. One of the proposed interventions is the change in the high school scholarship recipient, from the mother to the beneficiary. High school beneficiaries have become particularly relevant to the program as dropout rates at this level are especially high (27.9%) . As such, one of the program priorities is to test new scholar incentives redesigns in high school.
This intervention will be implemented as a pilot during the 2015-2016 and 2016-2017 school years. The government is interested in evaluating the impact of this change in terms of dropout rates, employment, consumption and risk behaviors before scaling it up at the national level. For this purpose, we are proposing an experimental design, assigning the change in scholarship recipient to the beneficiaries enrolled in the randomly selected treatment high schools. The sample size for this experiment is 1250 high schools (625 treatment and 625 control) within 8 states (Baja California, Chiapas, Durango, Hidalgo, Mexico, Puebla, Veracruz, and Zacatecas).
Intervention
The pilot will be conducted during the 2015-2016 and 2016-2017 school years (August 2015-July 2017) over the PROSPERA beneficiaries that by August 2015 are enrolled in first, second or third grade of the randomly selected high schools within the states identified for this study.
On February 2017 both treatment beneficiaries and their mothers will be informed of the change of the scholarship recipient. Beneficiaries will also receive their personalized debit cards through which they will be able to access their monetary transfer.
Several sources of data will be used for the impact evaluation analysis. The collection of baseline data has been substituted by the merge of different administrative datasets (beneficiaries census, standardized educational test –ENLACE-, and the socioeconomic PROSPERA household survey -ENCASEH-). This compiled information will let us perform a descriptive analysis of the target population, prove the validity of the experimental design and confirm the comparability of the treatment and control groups.
The follow-up survey, planned for October 2016, is expected to collect information of variables such as drop-out levels, consumption, decision-making, and risk behaviors after an entire school year period of treatment. This household level survey will collect information for a sample of both beneficiaries and their mothers. This sample will be constituted based on a random selection of those beneficiaries that will effectively be part of the PROSPERA beneficiaries’ census in November 2015.
High schools and beneficiary students will remain in the alternate scholarship scheme (change in the scholarship recipient) for at least two school cycles and the impact evaluation results will inform the government over the decision to change the scholarship recipient at the national level starting August 2017. If the government decides not to scale up the intervention, the alternate scheme will endure for treatment beneficiaries’ cohort participating in the pilot until they graduate from high school (July 2019). In such a case, the government will resume the traditional scholarship scheme to the new cohorts that enroll in high schools beginning 2018-2019 school year.
Experimental design
We are proposing an experimental impact evaluation by randomly assigning the treatment status (change in scholarship recipient from mother to youth) to the eligible beneficiaries within the selected schools. This design will allow the comparison of the results of interest in the treatment group with the results of those beneficiaries who will remain in the traditional model (mother receives the scholarship).
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.