Do families suffer from discrimination in the sharing economy?

How to cite

Nesseler, Cornel; Gonzalez, Carlos Gomez; Dietl, Helmut; Gasparetto, Thadeu. 2023. "Do families suffer from discrimination in the sharing economy?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009414. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9414-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Cornel Nesseler* , Carlos Gomez Gonzalez , Helmut Dietl , Thadeu Gasparetto

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009414
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9414-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-04-27 – 2023-07-25
Countries
Norway ()
JEL codes
D1, C93
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9414

Abstract

There is ample evidence that the sharing economy discriminates against minorities. The situation of families in the sharing economy, however, has been largely neglected. In this research, we want to examine if families suffer from discrimination.
Specifically, we want to contact vacation rental hosts asking if it is possible to rent an apartment. The control groups are a couple, a couple with one, two, or three friends. In the treatment group a couple has one, two, or
three kids. Additionally, we want to analyze if signaling the children’s ability increases the chances of receiving a response for
families.

Intervention

We want to contact rental hosts with the following text in the control group (couples without kids):

"Hello,
I am looking for a place for my husband and me. Do you think your place is appropriate for us?"

Additionally, we need a control group for couples with one, two, or three friends. Thus, we will change the
text as follows for three, four, or five adults:

"Hello,
I am looking for a place for a (two, three) friend(s), my husband, and me. Do you think your
place is appropriate for us?"

Families will contact the hosts as follows:

"Hello,
I am looking for a place for our (two, three) child(ren), my husband and me. Do you think your
place is appropriate for us?"

Hosts have almost no information available about the people who will stay in their place. We are using
accounts that have not received any reviews. To signal playful but well-behaved kids that are engaging
in quiet activities, we want to modify the sentence as follows:

"Hello,
I am looking for a place for our (two, three) child(ren), my husband and me. All of us (“We” for
the couple) are really looking forward to visiting the Louvre (or the appropriate local main
museum). Do you think your place is appropriate for us?"

Experimental design

We want to contact vacation rental hosts asking if it is possible to rent an apartment. The control groups are a couple, a couple with one, two, or three friends. In the treatment group a couple has one, two, or
three kids. Additionally, we want to analyze if signaling the children’s ability increases the chances of receiving a response for
families.

We want to contact hosts in the five largest cities in the European Union.

We will use exclusively native-sounding names, as previous research shows that people with foreign-sounding names suffer from discrimination (see, e.g., Gomez-Gonzalez et al., 2021). Thus, we will construct five native-sounding female and five native-sounding male names for each country. We will confirm in local surveys that the names sound indeed native.

Design details

Randomization method
We will use the computer program Stata to randomize the selection of hosts. We will set a seed before the start of the experiment to make the randomization method reproducible.
Randomization unit
We have five groups - each group is one city. In each city, a unit of randomization is one host.
Clusters
10,000 rentals. 2,000 in each city.
Observations
10,000
Arms
We have around 1250 observations in the control group and 750 observations in the treatment group. 2000 observations for each city. The control group consists of couples (500 obs.), with one adult friend (250 obs.), two adult friends (250 obs.), or three adult friends (250 obs.). The treatment group consists of families with one child (250 obs.), two children (250 obs.), or three children (250 obs.).
Primary outcomes
The response from the host is the main outcome variable. We expect that we will get either a rejection or an invitation.
Secondary outcomes
The secondary outcome focuses on the fact if the additional information that signals well-behaved children changes the response rate of the hosts.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords