Social preference, voluntary donation to climate mitigation and framing

How to cite

Thompson, Charlie. 2022. "Social preference, voluntary donation to climate mitigation and framing." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009364. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9364-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Charlie Thompson*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009364
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9364-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2022-05-23 – 2022-11-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
Q54, D91
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9364

Abstract

According to the most recent ICCP report, we have to immediately and rapidly reach net zero carbon emissions to avoid many of the worst effects. Determining how to motivate the public to pursue carbon mitigation will therefore be essential for policy makers. This project studies the willingness to pay (WTP), for climate change mitigation in an experimental setting. In particular this project is interested if the way information about climate change is presented to people (framing), and people’s preferences on the distribution of income (social preferences), impact their WTP. Further, this project also studies if an individual’s social preferences changes the impact of framing.

The framing used in this experiment mirrors one of the real world characteristics of climate change. Developed nations pollute the most per capita, but developing nations are the most exposed to climate change. Thus, some participants will receive framing emphasizing the risks from climate change to themselves directly, whereas others will receive language emphasizing the risk to those in developing nations. It is hypothesized that the former framing may be more motivating to self-regarding individuals, whereas individuals who are more strongly concerned with other’s welfare will be more motivated by the latter framing. Results from this experiment will become part of the literature seeking to inform active and ongoing policy discussions. For example, this project’s findings will be of use to policy makers trying to word a referendum. Environmental activists engaged in outreach such as deep conversation may also find the results helpful in tailoring their messages. Additionally, this project will help serve as a rare experimental check on what are typically hypothetical prices for carbon mitigation in WTP surveys.

Intervention

This experiment will have two main components. It will measure individual's social preferences (via a dictator game). It will also present participants with an option to contribute towards carbon mitigation. Just prior to the option to contribute, present different framing languages describing climate change. The effects of social preferences, framing, and interactions will be studied.

Experimental design

Participants will be asked to do two tasks, with the order varied between which task is presented first. In a laboratory setting this project will elicit social preferences using a modified dictator game. It will also elicit an estimate of WTP for climate mitigation though offering participants a chance to purchase cap-and-trade permits. When eliciting these WTP estimates, there is a control language framing, and two treatment language farmings. One framing focuses on the effects of climate change in Oregon, the other focuses on its impacts on developing nations. To account for free riding, participants will be asked to guess the average contribution of their group, with the expectation that they will project a value close to their WTP as being the norm. This guess will be incentivized with money if they are right. Finally, demographic information which has been shown to impact WTP previously such as education, age, income, and parental status, will be collected. To reduce cognitive load, the whole experiment will be designed to take no more than twenty minutes, though an hour will be allocated per session to give participants time to consider their decisions, read instructions, and carry out tasks.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization of participant roles (dictator or recipient) will be done by computer during the session. The randomization of treatment types (language and order of tasks) will be done by computer before the first trial.
Randomization unit
Language treatment is to be conducted at the session level.
Clusters
12 Sessions, each with approximately 10 participants. Some may have 12 participants. More session may be needed depending on enrollment per session. While tasks and decisions are individual and so there should be no session effects, this clustering is to control for any unobserved differences that might arise between session. It is possible that maximum enrollment for each session may not be possible due to difficulty recruiting or no-shows. In that case additional trials will need to be run until the target number of participants are reached, and the number of clusters will increase accordingly.
Observations
244
Arms
There are two language framing, a control framing, and randomized order of contributions or mitigation tasks. This results in 6 variations of the experiment. At the start of data collection, each planned session will be allocated to one treatment type. However it is the underlying distribution of the of participants which matters. In the event that more sessions are needed (due to under-recruitment) new sessions will be assigned variations based on the participants still needed for a variation. If multiple types of participants are still needed assignment of the variation for a session will be randomly determined by computer. The following is a breakdown of the planned 24 sessions: 3 sessions (30 participants) will receive the dictator game first and the language focused on Oregon. 3 sessions (30 participants) will receive the contribution game first and the language focused on Oregon. 6 Sessions (60 participants) will receive the dictator game first and the control language. 6 Sessions (60 participants) will receive the contribution game first and the control language. 3 sessions (30 participants) will receive the dictator game first and the language focused on developing nations. 3 sessions (30 participants) will receive the contribution game first and the language focused on developing nations. The spread of these treatments is designed such that there are the same number of control language treatments as the other language treatments combined (List et al 2011). In the event that there needs to be more trials due to under-enrollment during the 24 planned sessions, sessions will be added until each variation above has at least the correct number of participants. The minimum of 2 participants per session may result in some slight over allocation to a given variation. Given that sessions were of different sizes, session fixed effects will be used in the analysis.
Primary outcomes
Contributions towards purchase of cap and trade permits, both in absolute and percentage terms.
Secondary outcomes
Subject specific covariates: Demographic variables (a) gender (b) age (c) highest educational attainment (d) income (bucket) (e) if they have children (f) zipcode of high school (for connection to census block information as a proxy for socioeconomic background) (g) Three question likert scale questionnaire for belief in climate change Task order (dictator game or contributions task) will be varied at the session level.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords