Hard vs Soft Ultimatums

How to cite

Hyndman, Kyle; Karagözoğlu, Emin. 2022. "Hard vs Soft Ultimatums." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009319. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9319-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Kyle Hyndman* , Emin Karagözoğlu

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009319
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9319-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2022-05-15 – 2023-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
C90, D91
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9319

Abstract

Negotiation scholars agree on the following recommendation: avoid (hard) ultimatums and do not leave your opponent without any options. Using online experiments on Prolific, we will investigate the effect of the availability of soft ultimatums (ultimatum offers that specify a range of amounts – instead of a specific number – that the proposer is willing to give to the responder) on offers made, the likelihood of acceptance, and responders’ satisfaction and fairness perceptions of the negotiated outcome. There are two agents: a proposer and a responder. In the control treatment, they play the standard ultimatum game, where the proposer offers an amount of the given pie, and the responder accepts or rejects. In the experimental treatment, proposer can —at his/her will— specify a minimum amount and a maximum amount s/he would be willing to give to the responder. We are interested in the following markers: (i) how frequently is this option used, (ii) does the availability of this option influence the offers made by proposers (e.g., how do the maximum offers in the experimental treatment compare with the offers in the control treatment), (iii) how does the rejection rate for maximum offers in the experimental treatment compare to the rejection rate of equivalent offers in the control treatment, and (iv) how do the satisfaction and fairness perceptions of responders in the experimental treatment compare with those in the control treatment (for comparable offers)?

Intervention

The purpose of our intervention is to understand the influence of soft ultimatums on (i) offers made by proposers; (ii) the acceptance/rejection behavior of responders; (iii) their satisfaction with the outcome of bargaining'; and (iv) how fair they perceive the offer/outcome. To study this, we compare agents’ behavior (and answers to some post-experimental questions) across two treatments that vary the availability/presence of soft ultimatums.

Experimental design

The experiment has two treatments: standard ultimatum game (UG - control treatment) and modified ultimatum game (MUG - experimental treatment). These games are implemented using the direct-response method. We explicitly avoid implementing the strategy method since we believe that the treatment variation we implement can make a behavioral impact when the responders are in a hot emotional state. The experiment has a between-subjects design, i.e., each subject will participate only in one of the treatments. We decided against a within-subject design since the treatment variation is simple and transparent, which can easily reveal the research question and lead to an experimenter demand effect. The game is one-shot. Each subject only plays one role, and roles are randomly assigned with equal probabilities. There will be comprehension questions before the game. Only the participants who answer these questions correctly can proceed with the experiment. Instructions are common knowledge. The experiment will be conducted on Prolific.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
Groups of participants (sessions) are randomized to experimental treatments.
Clusters
We plan to conduct data collection in waves of approximately 20-24 pairs per session, which means that we will need to conduct 4 or 5 “sessions” per treatment.
Observations
85 complete pairs per treatment, with 2 treatments for a total of 340 subjects.
Arms
85 complete pairs – Control Treatment (UG) 85 complete pairs – Experimental Treatment (MUG)
Primary outcomes
• Offers by proposers in the control treatment • Minimum and maximum offers by proposers in the experimental treatment • Accept/reject decisions by responders in both treatments • Answers to outcome satisfaction and fairness perception questions by responders in both treatments
Secondary outcomes
• Answers to open ended questions that aim to understand proposers’ mindset (e.g., how they perceive the soft ultimatum option, why they used/did not use it, their intentions) by proposers in the experimental treatment. • Decision times (i.e., how long does it take for the subjects to make their decisions)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords