Evaluating Demand Side Constraints to Female Employment among Firms in Pakistan Through Experimental Provision of a Targeted Wage Subsidy
How to cite
Mahmud, Mahreen; Lee, Jean; Sarma, Nayantara; Bussolo, Maurizio. 2022. "Evaluating Demand Side Constraints to Female Employment among Firms in Pakistan Through Experimental Provision of a Targeted Wage Subsidy." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009226. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9226-4.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Female labor force participation rates throughout South Asia are low, declining, and are likely significantly slowing economic growth in the region. The underlying causes of low female labor force participation are not yet well understood. It is widely believed that restrictive gender norms play a strong role along with other economic forces (Jayachandran, 2019), but the channels through which norms may influence outcomes are not yet well articulated. Our study seeks to understand whether temporary wage subsidies can increase female employment in Pakistani firms, which are heavily dominated by male employees. We aim to look at the impacts of the wage-subsidy on hiring and retention of female employees, attitude changes among employers, and heterogeneity of effects along baseline characteristics. Using the Becker-DeGroot-Marschak mechanism, the experiment will elicit the true subsidy required for an employer to hire a woman. Our proposed research would fill a significant gap in the current experimental and quasi-experimental literature on norms and female employment by focusing on the demand side of the labor market and interventions that may make employers shift attitudes towards employing women.
Intervention
6-month wage subsidy targeted to firms that hire women for technical/professional roles.
Experimental design
There will be a single treatment arm consisting of a 6-month wage subsidy targeted to firms that hire women for technical/professional roles. The average wage subsidy would amount to approximately 25% of the salary offered. We are planning to use the Becker-DeGroot-Marschak (BDM) mechanism to elicit truthful reporting of the level of subsidy that would be needed and to select the firms that actually win the subsidy. The BDM is a way of asking questions such that the respondent truthfully reveals the price at which they value something. In our study, this refers to their willingness to pay for a female employee. We will ask how much of the employee’s salary needs to be subsidized (i.e. paid by us) for the firm to hire a female employee for the posted vacancy. If the share they require is lower than the number drawn randomly by a computer, we will subsidize the amount equal to the randomly drawn number. However, we will share their salary costs only if the firm actually hires a female candidate (based on their own selection process) for this job. On the other hand, if the share of the salary that they report wanting to be subsidized is more than the number drawn randomly by a computer, they do not have to pay anything, and we do not share employee costs. In this case, they would be free to hire whoever they want.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.