Socially-Expected Leadership
How to cite
Duque, Mauricio Fernandez; Hiscox, Michael. 2022. "Socially-Expected Leadership." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009191. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9191-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We provide experimental evidence to assess whether pro-social leading is motivated by altruism or by a less lofty desire to conform with expectations. The evidence from our initial experiment indicates that many individuals' pro-social leading may be driven by conformity to what they imagine is expected of them by others. This is somewhat counterintuitive as the notion of leadership seems to imply influencing others by surpassing expectations, not simply conforming with them. But what we observe looks less like inspired boldness and more like stock role-playing.
Intervention
Subjects face sequential choices about how of their 100 peso endowment to divide between themselves and a charity. We assign subjects to be either a first-mover who makes a choice that is potentially observable by a second-mover. For clarity of exposition, we will refer to the first-movers in the female gender, and to the second-movers in the male gender.
The basic design is the following. First-movers make a contribution decision which will be seen by a second-mover before he makes his own contribution decision (we will call this the "influence scenario"). First-movers also make a contribution decision which will be seen by a second-mover after he makes his own contribution decision (we will call this the "no influence scenario"). Only one of the first-mover's decisions, along with the timing of what the second-mover sees, will be implemented. The first-mover's third decision affects the probability of implementation (we call this the "replication decision"). We also elicit the first-mover's beliefs over what second-movers and first-movers do, and over what others believe second-movers and first-movers do. Finally, we ask first-movers sociodemographic questions, questions about attitudes regarding leadership, and debriefing questions.
The intervention with second-movers is much more straightforward. Second-movers decide how to divide their endowment with the charity, either before or after seeing what the first-mover contributed. Which first-mover the second-mover is matched with, and whether second-movers see their first-mover's contribution before or after their own contribution, are determined randomly.
Experimental design
Contribution decisions.
Each first-mover makes two decisions about how to divide an endowment of 100 pesos between herself and a charity. Subjects learn about the two decisions simultaneously. To eliminate the potential for differences at margins, only one of these decisions (chosen at random) will be implemented for each subject. The first two decisions are made in different scenarios. The two scenarios are identical except in one key aspect. In both scenarios, the first-mover must choose how to split the money between herself and the charity. A second-mover will be told of one of the first-mover's decisions, and will make his own decision about how to divide his endowment. The only difference between the first-mover's first and second scenario is the timing of when the second-mover learns about what the first-mover chose to do. In one scenario, the second-mover will be informed about what the first-mover has contributed before he makes his own decision (we will call this the influence scenario). In the alternative scenario, the second-mover will only get the information after he has made his own decision (this we will call the no influence scenario). In both cases, the second-mover is able to pass judgment on the choice made by the first-mover. However, only in the influence scenario can the first-mover influence what the second-mover chooses to contribute.
The difference between what the first-mover contributes in the influence versus the no influence scenarios is our basic measure of whether there is leadership in the sense of giving extra when in a position of influence.
The design took several considerations into account to isolate the motivation for leading. To minimize social image concerns and demand effects, the first-mover's identity is not revealed to the second-mover, the experimenter or the charity. To further avoid demand effects, we tried to use value-neutral words in the instructions. For example, instead of `influence' and `no influence' scenarios, we referred to scenarios where person 2 contributes before or after seeing what person 1 contributes. We presented both scenarios simultaneously. Pilot sessions indicated that a simultaneous display of the scenarios was important for comprehension. By presenting both scenarios simultaneously, we addressed the further concern that if they made one decision before observing the second scenario, the first decision would anchor the second one.
In a third decision made by the first-mover, she must choose which of the first two decisions she would like to make more likely to be implemented. That is, suppose she had originally decided to contribute X in the influence scenario, and Y in the no influence scenario. Either the influence scenario with a contribution of X by the first-mover is implemented, or the no influence scenario with a contribution of Y by the first-mover is implemented. In her third decision she decides the probability with which the first option is implemented: either 1/3 or 2/3. We will refer to this third decision as the replication decision.
The replication decision she makes reveals which contribution-contingency pair she prefers. It allows us to measure whether subjects "take back leading" in the sense of contributing more in the influence contingency and then makes the no influence contingency more likely to be implemented. It also allows us to measure whether subjects who contribute the same in both scenarios try to put themselves in a position where they can influence others, a second sense of the term leadership in which subjects seek primacy.
Elicitation of beliefs.
After these choices have been made, we ask the first-movers a series of questions to elicit beliefs about others and measure social expectations, presented as `guessing games' (with 50 peso prizes for those who came closest to the correct answers). We asked each first-mover to guess how much the average second-mover contributed to the charity in the influence scenario (a guess for each whole dollar amount between 0 and 10 dollars that the first-mover would have contributed first) and in the no leadership scenario (one amount to guess). After this they were asked to guess how much the average first-mover contributed in the influence and no influence scenario. To generate measures of social expectations, we asked each first-mover to guess the average of what others had guessed that first-movers do. This is our measure of social expectations.
Socio-demographics, personality, exit survey.
After the guessing games, first-movers are asked to answer socio-demographic questions, personality questions and an exit survey.
First-movers are not informed about any details about second-movers other than what we have explained so far.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.