Human history is marred by countless instances of systematic oppression (economic and otherwise) even though oppression is objectively detrimental. Despite our extensive knowledge of the moral, social, and monetary costs of oppression, we know much less about its behavioral determinants, how it sustains, or its second-order effects. This is likely due to the inherent ethical and moral considerations imposed by attempting to create oppression in a controlled setting. To this end, we introduce a novel experimental framework that mimics the behavioral underpinnings of oppression in an ethical, replicable way. We use this new framework to study the relationship between social status, monetary incentives, and the willingness to oppress others. Further, we investigate how the experience of an oppressive regime impacts the trust exhibited by both its perpetrators and victims.
Experimental design
The experiment has 6 different treatments based on the levels of 2 factors: Type Assignment [Random/Random_Reinforced/Earned_Reinforced] x Trust type [generalized/group specific] Following some initial piloting, we have decided to focus on just two cells of our full factorial design during our first wave of data collection. We are currently collecting data for the Random and Random_Reinforced conditions with group specific trust. After we finish data collection, we intend to revisit the remainder of our proposed to design to reconsider other factors which may be of interest.
The Experiment takes place over 5 parts: 1-Type Assignment, 2-Trust Game, 3-Lopsided Public Good Game, 4-Oppression Game, 5-Trust Game
Design details
Randomization method
All eligible participants are invited to all sessions. Order of treatments across sessions is randomized conditional on preserving an even number of sessions for each combination of factors. Where applicable, randomization within the experiment is done via the programming interface, zTree.
Randomization unit
Both of our factors: Type assignment & trust type are randomized at the session level. In the Random assignment treatments, participant type is randomized at the individual level.
Clusters
Following some initial piloting, Our current funding covers approximately 90 clusters of 5 participants
Observations
Each cluster contains 5 participants, for a total of 450 observations. Some aspects of the design involve repeated decision-making implying we will have 2250 observations of behaviour in part 3 and 4500 observations of behaviour in part 4. However, we are primarily interested in the punishment behaviour of Type 1/Star participants which is only observed in Part 4 and only amongst a subset of each cluster. Conditioning on this, there are a total of 2 observations of punishment over 10 rounds in each cluster implying a total of 180 observations based on our current funding.
Arms
Following initial piloting, our goals is to get 64 observations in each of the two cells we are currently running (i.e. a total of 64 clusters & 320 participants). Once we complete data collection for the first two cells, we plan to decide which additional treatments of interest to run prior to applying for additional funding.
Primary outcomes
public good contribution, punishment application, change in amount sent/returned in trust game before and after experience of oppression
Secondary outcomes
relationship between behaviour in the experiment and demographic data collected in survey. The impact of experience during the experiment on self-reported self-esteem and strength of group attachment. The relationship between SDO and application of punishment points (oppression) during the experiment
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.