Adoption and Impacts of Digital Payment Technologies: Evidence from Informal Transit

How to cite

Houeix, Deivy. 2022. "Adoption and Impacts of Digital Payment Technologies: Evidence from Informal Transit." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009155. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9155-1.3

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Deivy Houeix*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009155
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9155-1.3
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2022-03-29 – 2023-05-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9155

Abstract

Digital technologies have spread rapidly in much of the world. Despite their expected impacts on productivity and growth, rates of adoption remain modest among firms in sub-Saharan Africa. This research will evaluate the impact of digital payments on business activity, and investigate the role of information asymmetry within firms in explaining businesses’ resistance to technology adoption. By mitigating moral hazard, digital technologies enable changes in the contracting space between employers and employees, in ways that may constitute a barrier to their adoption. To study these questions, I will conduct a randomized experiment by introducing digital payment technologies into widespread small businesses, taxis. In collaboration with a large mobile money company, I will test options for digitizing payments and evaluate the impact of digital payment technologies in the informal transit sector.

Intervention

Owners and drivers will be invited to use the digital payments technology. QR codes will be installed in taxis to allow passengers to pay securely. We will recruit owners and drivers in two ways: marketing meetings in collaboration with taxi associations and listing of interested drivers and owners throughout the city by hired enumerators. Owners and drivers will be invited to participate in the study to test the product before its official launch. In collaboration with a partner company, I designed a base product with three options for randomly varying the amount of information available to the owners on their drivers. The randomly selected control group will be offered nothing and on a wait list.

Experimental design

Owners and drivers will be invited to use the digital payments technology that aims at reducing transaction costs. In collaboration with the partner company, I designed a base product with three options for randomly varying the amount of information available to the owners on their drivers:
A) No Visibility: The owners can only receive payments from drivers at no fee.
B) Limited Visibility / Limited Liability: The owners get notified each day via text every night of their drivers’ total collection up to the estimated daily usage of digital payments for taxis. If the total balance is above average, the owners do not get notified of the surplus.
C) Full Visibility: The owners get notified and can observe all the drivers’ transactions. They also receive an SMS about the total transactions of the day. This option is currently the only one offered to other types of businesses accepting digital payments.
D) Control group: Waitlisted for the time of the experiment and followed using both survey and administrative data.

The partner company plans to reach further taxi owners/drivers outside of this sample.

We plan to "treat" the control group with either full visibility or no-visibility at endline, with the intent to conduct another round of follow-up in the future. The visibility group will be randomly sub-divided into two groups: whether we nudge the drivers or the owners about the possible contractual changes induced by the visibility to strengthen the treatment effect and measure the trigger of the contractual change if any.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done by computer.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is the taxi business, i.e., the interested taxi owners. The owners and their drivers will be randomized into one of the six groups, i.e., 3 options and a control group, also each assigned to one of the three options to elicit their willingness-to-pay for it (waitlisted) (3 + 3). I stratify the randomization by anticipated dimensions of heterogeneity, i.e., -- Proxy for baseline knowledge/beliefs (business type, number of taxis, and length of the relationship). -- Proxy for baseline risk aversion, i.e., whether the taxi drivers circulate throughout the city or mostly wait for passengers in a fixed place. -- Proxy for baseline taxi-like digital usage The randomization will be done in several batches and listing surveys will continue to happen in addition to the baseline survey.
Clusters
N/A
Observations
The target sample is 1,200 owners along with their drivers.
Arms
240 owners and their drivers in each of the three treatment arms. 480 owners and their drivers in the control group (sub-divided into three options to elicit willingness-to-pay).
Primary outcomes
The analysis will include three main sets of outcomes: (a) Technology adoption: I will measure adoption barriers on two dimensions: take-up and usage across the three options, as key variables of interest, using both survey and administrative data. (b) Impacts on business productivity, profits, growth, and financial inclusion, including leakages, costs, quantities (passengers), prices, and business growth, savings, credit, money transfers to other sources, using both survey and administrative data. (c) Contracts and relationships between owners and drivers, including trust, repayment, beliefs, value of the relationship, contract changes. Owners driving their own taxi alone, with no other drivers will be included and randomly offered one of the 3 options to study hiring of a new driver as an outcome.
Secondary outcomes
The partner plans to offer discounts to passengers to increase take-up. The latter discounts will be randomized and studied as secondary outcomes.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords