First-hand experience of short-term incarceration
How to cite
Marechal, Michel; Beerli, Andreas; Henkel, Aljosha; Arman, Arto. 2022. "First-hand experience of short-term incarceration." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009150. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9150-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We conduct a randomized controlled trial with the general population and public sector employees to study the effect of first-hand experience of short-term incarceration on perceptions of pains of imprisonment and attitudes towards law and order. In collaboration with the Department of Justice and Home Affairs Zurich, we randomly invite interested citizens to take part in a test run of a newly built prison in Switzerland and measure their attitudes towards punishment.
Experimental design
To participate in a test run conducted in the jail cells of the prison “Gefängnis Zürich West” (GZW), adult individuals with a clean criminal record living in the canton Zurich could applied and indicated their preferred dates to participate in the test run and if they would like to stay overnight. Those applicants were screened regarding the conditions of admission by the members of GZW and then an anonymized list of the eligible participants was handed to the research team.
We invited all participants in that list to an online baseline survey, where we measured participants’ beliefs about – and preferences regarding – the justice system and correctional institutions. We will use these pre-treatment outcomes as control variables in our analysis to increase the precision of our estimated treatment effects. We also collected a variety of other questionnaire measures such as their risk attitudes, criminal attitudes, educational level, and previous jail experience.
After the invitation to the baseline survey, we randomized a share of the applicants to be eligible to participate in the test run (treatment group), while the other participants were not (control group). The head of the GZW then filled the cells for their test run based on the list of participants that were randomly assigned into the treatment group, not exhausting the pool of individuals in the treatment group (for more details, see experimental design details).
Subsequently, the test run will be conducted by the Department of Justice and Home Affairs, starting at noon on the 24th of March and ending at noon on the 27th of March. Participants in the treatment group, that were assigned to participate by GZW and show up for their appointment, will spend a pre-defined amount of time in their assigned cell.
In the second survey (main survey), for which we will invite participants in the afternoon of the 27th of March, we will measure the participants’ perceptions of pain of imprisonment and attitudes towards the justice system. Furthermore, we will elicit their beliefs about the well-being of inmates in a prison in Zurich through an incentivized guessing task and measure their attitude towards law and order through a donation task.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.