Got Beef with Beef: Climate Labels for Sustainable Food Consumption

How to cite

Page, Lucy. 2022. "Got Beef with Beef: Climate Labels for Sustainable Food Consumption." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009149. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9149-2.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Lucy Page*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009149
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9149-2.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2022-03-25 – 2023-06-30
Countries
United States of America ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9149

Abstract

Food systems account for approximately 26% of global greenhouse gases, with high variation in carbon footprints across different types of food. Despite the food system's large contribution to climate change, most consumers are unaware of how their food choices impact the climate. We partner with a large meal kit company in the US to test the impacts of menu labels indicating the relative carbon impact of meals in an RCT with over 100,000 customers. We will test the impacts of these labels on key administrative outcomes, like meal choices, customer retention, and customer referrals. We complement this large-scale experiment with a survey experiment in a sample recruited from Facebook, where we will test the impacts of carbon labels on knowledge, beliefs, and other pro-environmental behaviors.

Intervention

Our partner company will estimate the carbon footprints of each meal on their weekly menus and then classify each meal into three tiers based on their carbon footprint. The intervention will then label each meal on the company's weekly menus with a symbol denoting which of the three carbon footprint tiers they fall in. In particular, three treatment variations will be as follows:
1) Meals are labeled as falling in three tiers of carbon impacts with abstract symbols based on color-coded globes, alongside descriptions of what each level of the symbol denotes.
2) Meals are labeled as falling in three tiers of carbon impacts with letter grades from A through C, alongside explanatory descriptions.
3) Only those meals in the lowest-impact tier are labeled as "Climate Superstars" on the menus.

In our survey experiment, there will be one treatment menu including carbon labels:
1) Meals are labeled as falling in three tiers of carbon impacts with abstract symbols based on color-coded globes, alongside descriptions of what each level of the symbol denotes.

Experimental design

We will work with a meal kit company to implement a large-scale online experiment with over 100,000 of their customers in the United States. In this experiment, all meals are classified into three tiers based on the carbon footprints associated with producing the meals. Customers are randomly assigned to one of four groups: (1) a treatment group that sees menus where climate impact is represented by an abstract symbol, (2) a treatment group that sees menus where climate impact is represented by letter grades, (3) a treatment group that sees menus where the most carbon-efficient meals are labelled as "climate superstars", and (4) a control group that will see the regular menus without any climate labels. The experimental menus will be applied to 10 weeks of meals.

In addition to this large-scale field experiment with our partner company, we implement a survey experiment with participants recruited via Facebook ads. In this survey experiment, we randomly assign participants to two groups: a treatment group that sees menus where climate impact is represented by an abstract symbol, and a control group that sees menus without any climate impact labels. The meals are taken from one week of the meal kit company's menu, and participants will have a chance to win a free box with the meals they chose in the survey experiment. Due to spending limits on Facebook recruitment and the timing of our partner company's meal cycles, we will run this off-platform experiment in two waves, each for a separate week of our partner company's meals.

Design details

Randomization method
Survey experiment: Randomization done via Qualtrics
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
N/A
Observations
Mealkit experiment: 133,000 customers Survey experiment via Facebook: 6,000 participants, to be split over an initial wave with N = 2470 and a second wave with approximately N = 3500. We run this survey experiment in two waves due to the combination of spending limits on Facebook recruitment and the timing of our partner company's meal cycles.
Arms
Experiment with partner company: 34,000 control, 33,000 abstract labels, 33,000 letter-grade labels, 33,000 climate-superstar labels Survey experiment: 3,000 control, 3,000 abstract labels
Primary outcomes
Experiment with partner company: - Meal choices (including related to different proteins, climate-friendly levels, and add-ons) - Retention of customers Survey experiment recruited from Facebook: - Meal choices (including different proteins, climate friendly levels) - Knowledge of the carbon footprints of different types of food - Spillovers to other climate-related actions: 1) Donations to climate causes, 2) Willingness to seek out new climate-related information about food
Secondary outcomes
Experiment with partner company: - Cost, revenue, and profit per customer - Customers' referrals of new customers - Donations of meal kits through meal kit website Survey experiment recruited from Facebook: - Beliefs about the efficacy and moral imperative of actors in combating climate change - Perceptions of meals' healthiness, climate-friendliness, and tastiness - Perceptions related to own contributions to combating climate change - Self-perceptions as an environmentalist, altruistic, etc.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords