Paternalism in the Welfare State

How to cite

Freitas-Groff, Zachary; Ambuehl, Sandro; Fan, Tony; Bernheim, B. Douglas. 2022. "Paternalism in the Welfare State." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009144. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9144-5.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Zachary Freitas-Groff* , Sandro Ambuehl , Tony Fan , B. Douglas Bernheim

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009144
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9144-5.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2022-08-02 – 2024-09-30
Countries
United States of America ()
JEL codes
D6, D63, D64, D9, D91, D3, D31, H53, I38
Secondary IDs
Stanford IRB-53441
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9144

Abstract

Assistance towards the poor in Western economies is often delivered in the form of in-kind transfers. This form is puzzling from the vantage point of standard microeconomic theory, according to which cash transfers are the most efficient means of raising recipients' welfare. To understand the motivations for such policies, we conduct a lab-in-the-field experiments in the US. General population respondents have the opportunity to place restrictions on a transfer we deliver to a welfare recipient who participates in the study. We examine the causes underlying the restrictions individuals impose. We quantify the importance of various motives including respect for the recipient's autonomy. We characterize how these motivations differ depending on whether the welfare recipient is black or white, male or female, and whether the recipient has children. In counterfactual simulations, we then examine whether and how approval of paternalistic constraints on welfare payments would change if individuals had accurate beliefs about the recipients' use of the funds as well as about the demographic composition of the recipient pool.

Experimental design

We present respondents with a Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP, food stamps) recipient and one of two different food boxes (a healthy box and a representative box), each worth about $50. One in 20 respondents makes the choice about a real person. Respondents learn that the welfare recipient may or may not be real and do not learn whether they are. Respondents then make a series of choices regarding whether the welfare recipient receives the food box or a set of gift cards of their choice worth a given dollar amount.

In order to run these treatments, we first ran a survey with SNAP recipients where we elicited their preferences for the food box compared to gift cards.

After running the initial survey, we recruit a new pilot panel of 428 respondents. First, we alter the way we elicited respondents’ beliefs (meanBelief, sdBelief) to drag and drop tags into bins rather than using a grid. Second, we randomly provide information about SNAP recipients’ alcohol consumption to some respondents and not to others.

We finally rerun the new design with a panel of 1,997 respondents using the new interface.

Design details

Randomization method
Random number generator on Qualtrics platform
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
Initial survey: 4,000 respondents (including 3,800 respondents who make choices about artificial welfare recipients with pre-specified demographics); 140-160 real welfare recipients for incentives. Second round: 428 respondents; 137 real welfare recipients for incentives. Final round: 1,997 respondents; 133 real welfare recipients for incentives.
Observations
Initial survey: 4,000 respondents (including 3,800 respondents who make choices about artificial welfare recipients with pre-specified demographics); 140-160 real welfare recipients for incentives. Second round: 428 respondents; 137 real welfare recipients for incentives. Final round: 1,997 respondents; 133 real welfare recipients for incentives.
Arms
Initial survey: Approximately 300 respondents in the young white male bin Approximately 300 respondents in the young black male bin Approximately 600 respondents in the young white female (without children) bin Approximately 600 respondents in the young black female (without children) bin Approximately 600 respondents in the young white female (with children) bin Approximately 600 respondents in the young black female (with children) bin Approximately 300 respondents in the old white male bin Approximately 300 respondents in the old black male bin Approximately 300 respondents in the old white female (without children) bin Approximately 300 respondents in the old black female (without children) bin Second and final rounds: the same proportions of the respective samples
Primary outcomes
• meanBelief: The respondent’s incentivized belief about the average total gift card value the welfare recipient would trade for the food box, elicited using a multiple price list with eight dollar amounts ($0, $25, $45, $60, $70, $85, $105, $130) • patFoodSw: The range out of the nine defined by the eight dollar amounts ($0, $25, $45, $60, $70, $85, $105, $130) in which the respondent switches from sending the welfare recipient the food box to letting them choose between the food box and gift cards worth that amount. • surrSw: The range out of the nine defined by the eight dollar amounts ($0, $25, $45, $60, $70, $85, $105, $130) in which the respondent switches from sending the welfare recipient the food box to sending them gift cards worth that amount. • We again elicit the first and the last of the above three outcomes after informing the respondent whether the welfare recipient prefers food or gift cards worth $70. We had originally planned to use the dollar amounts ($0, $20, $35, $45, $55, $65, $80, $100) but edited the questionnaire to reflect the new price grid after piloting. We also originally planned to provide information about the welfare recipient’s preferences above or below $50 but edited the questionnaire to use $70 as the new benchmark after piloting.
Secondary outcomes
• sdBelief: The respondent’s incentivized belief about the standard deviation of the total gift card value the welfare recipient would trade for the food box, elicited using a multiple price list with eight dollar amounts ($0, $25, $45, $60, $70, $85, $105, $130) • sdBelief, elicited after informing the respondent whether the welfare recipient prefers food or gift cards worth $50. • altruism: The dollar amount out of a list of six dollar amounts ($0, $10,…,$50) that the respondent would give to the welfare recipient if the amount remaining out of $50 goes to a random U.S. taxpayer. • recFood: Whether the respondent recommends choosing food if they give the welfare recipient the choice between food and gift cards (rather than the food box). • Miscellaneous questions regarding how respondents use the food and gift cards, how they spend the marginal dollar from each, the price of the food box, welfare recipients’ demographics, the acceptability of different choices, political views, and demographics.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords