Technology and corruption: experimental evidence from the introduction of tax e-filing in Tajikistan
How to cite
Pouliquen, Victor; Okunogbe, Oyebola. 2016. "Technology and corruption: experimental evidence from the introduction of tax e-filing in Tajikistan." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000914. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.914-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Corruption, tax evasion and ineffective revenue collection mechanisms can hinder a country’s economic growth. Designing more efficient and transparent tax administration systems is thus an important policy challenge, particularly for low income countries. Tajikistan, one of the lowest ranking countries on Ease of Paying Taxes (178/189) and Ease of Doing Business (143/189), implemented a reform of its tax system in 2012 to allow tax payers file tax returns electronically (e-filing). E-filing can streamline tax payments by eliminating long submission waiting queues and by reducing corruption, with fewer direct interactions between taxpayers and tax officials. However, few years after this reform, e-filing take-up rate remained low. This study aims to provide empirical evidence on the factors affecting the adoption of a new technology like tax e-filing in a developing country, and the impact of this technology on tax compliance costs, tax behavior, and perceived corruption. Our sample includes 1,500 firms representative of all legal SMEs operating in the capital Dushanbe. These firms were randomly assigned to one of three groups that received different e-filing incentive packages: firms in group1 received information and training on how to register and use e-filing, firms in group 2 received these same services, plus personalized assistance with registration, and firms in group 3 received only a generalized tax training that was not specific to e-filing.
Intervention
Tajikistan adopted a new tax code that went into effect on January 1, 2013. The new code contains a number of reforms aimed at reducing compliance costs for businesses and stimulating business formalization and growth. This study focuses on evaluating one aspect of this reform package: the electronic filing of taxes.
Tajikistan is a fitting context to study the impact of electronic tax filing on compliance costs and (perceptions of) corruption in tax administration. In the absence of e-filing, businesses submit their monthly tax declarations in person at local tax offices with otherwise productive time spent waiting in line for multiple checks and signatures. As such, it has one of the lowest rankings on the Ease of Paying Taxes (178/189) and ranks 143/189 on the overall Ease of Doing Business in 2014. The introduction of e-filing in this context has the potential to transform the tax administration process and thus reduce the tax compliance burden which constitutes a critical component of the business environment.
Corruption is also a major concern in Tajikistan. Enterprise Survey 2013 reports that 41 percent of firms expect to give gifts in meetings with tax officials and CPIA rates Tajikistan as 2.5/6 in its transparency, accountability and corruption in the public sector. E-filing is very relevant in this context because it presents an opportunity to reduce the frequency of interactions between taxpayers and tax officials and thus minimize opportunities for rent-seeking behavior.
The Tax Committee has several motivations for introducing e-filing:
- To improve service delivery and eliminate long wait times for submission of declarations, and resultantly promote voluntary compliance and increase tax revenues
- To reduce corruption by limiting the amount of interactions between taxpayers and the Tax Committee
- To improve the quality of tax records by reducing the mistakes made by clerks with large data entry burdens
- To improve the efficiency of tax administration by releasing officials from routine work to focus on higher value activities.
To encourage e-filing take-up, the tax authority has conducted public information campaigns and trainings for business associations and removed all registration fees. However, take-up remains lower than expected and this study seeks to increase understanding about which measures would increase utilization. In addition, the evaluation will shed light on the extent to which the anticipated benefits of e-filing adoption are being realized.
Interviews with business owners as well as Tax Committee officials indicate that firms are not using e-filing for a variety of reasons, including:
i) Lack of Awareness: Some firms are unaware of the option to file electronically
ii) Lack of Trust: Some firms are aware of the system but are concerned about the security of information submitted online, or worry that e-filing will increase their likelihood of being audited
iii) Procrastination: some firms are willing to e-file but they do not due to procrastination
iv) Supply Side Problems: some firms are willing to e-file but the registration process is too complicated or time consuming
v) Lack of Infrastructure: Some firms would like to e-file but are not able to due to a lack of access to needed infrastructure and skills (such as computers and internet connection)
vi) Preference for Direct Interaction with Inspectors: Some other firms do not wish to file online because they prefer to deal directly with the same tax inspector on a regular basis for the submission of their tax declarations. This could be for benign reasons such as having someone crosscheck their submissions, or for purposes of attempting to evade tax obligations
This evaluation tests two different types of incentives that aim to address the first four barriers:
- Providing information on e-filing and training on how to use it, to increase awareness and trust in the system;
- Providing logistical support for registration to solve some of the supply side problem. It may also solve the procrastination issue.
Experimental design
The study evaluates two different packages of incentives by randomly allocating firms into three groups as follows:
• Group A: Training and Logistical Support: Taxpayers assigned to this group received information about the availability of e-filing, registration procedures and instructions on how to use the system. This training, delivered in group sessions, addresses the non-material factors that constrain the willingness and ability of firms to e-file (such as lack of awareness, lack of training and lack of trust in the system). Following the training session, trained specialists followed up with the firm to gather required documents for submission to the Tax Committee to complete the e-filing registration. This incentive tackles the non-material constraints to e-filing including the hassle factor of having to register and procrastination issues. Taxpayers in this group also received a general training on taxation (not directly connected to e-filling).
• Group B: Training Only: Taxpayers assigned to this group only received the information and training on how to e-file. Unlike group A, they did not receive logistical help with registering. Taxpayers in this group also received a general training on taxation.
• Group C: Control Group: This group of firms serves as a comparison group and did not receive any incentive to e-file. However, following the exact same protocol as for firms in group A and B, firms in this group received a general training on taxation.
Only firms that attended the training were included in the study population. In order to avoid firms choosing to participate in a training based on their treatment allocation, the exact same protocol was used to invite firms to the trainings.
The 2004 firms were randomly allocated into two treatment groups and one control group:
- In group A, 800 firms were sampled and 594 attended to the training.
- In group B, 400 firms were sampled and 296 attended to the training.
- In group C, 800 firms were sampled and 608 attended to the training.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.