Learning versus Signaling in the Workplace: Evidence from the Adoption of Commitment Savings Accounts
How to cite
Kanz, Martin; Klapper, Leora; Breza, Emily. 2015. "Learning versus Signaling in the Workplace: Evidence from the Adoption of Commitment Savings Accounts." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0000913. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.913-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
While an increasing number of low-income households in developing countries has access to a formal bank account, there are many barriers that prevent households from accessing a wider range of welfare-enhancing financial products and services. Although technically “banked”, these individuals often find the formal financial sector daunting and complicated and fail to actively engage with it. As a result, they are not able to fully utilize the facilities it offers and more importantly, they are unable to use the formal financial sector as a mechanism to meet their financial goals. In this project, we examine how workers learn about a new financial product being offered as an add-on to a basic salary account and examine the mechanisms that drive the adoption decision. We partner with a leading bank in Bangladesh and offer a simple "Deposit Pension Savings" (DPS) product to salaried workers in the garment sector in Bangladesh who already have an electronic payroll account. Workers are given the option to enroll in the DPS plan and commit to having a fixed savings amount debited from their monthly salary. We vary the conditions under which the product is presented to eligible workers and study to what extent the adoption decision is driven by learning about the product versus the desire on the worker's part to convey information to the employer.
Intervention
We work with a leading bank in Bangladesh to offer a DPS commitment savings product to garment workers that already receive their monthly salary into an electronic payroll account. Workers are given detailed information about the product and have the opportunity to sign up for a DPS account. If they do so, they can choose an amount to be debited from their monthly salary and deposited into their savings account.
The intervention varies the conditions under which workers are offered the product. All workers in the treatment groups receive a detailed presentation of the product terms and characteristics and complete a short survey at the end of the information sessions. The main intervention consists of two additional features that are added to the product presentations for randomly chosen subgroups of workers: (1) an endorsement of the product from the employer, delivered by a floor manager (2) an announcement that feedback about the sign-up decision will be provided to the employer.
The intervention is set-up as a simple 2x2 design with the following treatment groups:
1. Control [No offer]
2. T1: No employer endorsement + no feedback to employer [Basic offer]
3. T2: No employer endorsement + feedback to employer
4. T3: Employer endorsement + no feedback to employer
5. T4: Employer endorsement + feedback to employer
We compare take-up rates under these experimental conditions to examine to what extent the take-up decision is driven by (i) information about the product versus (ii) employer endorsement (information from a credible source) versus (iii) feedback to the employer i.e. the ability to signal to the employer. Using data on personal characteristics, we will also examine whether the take-up decision varies systematically by worker characteristics across the treatment groups.
Experimental design
The intervention is set-up as a simple 2x2 design with the following treatment groups:
1. Control [No offer]
2. T1: No employer endorsement + no feedback to employer [Basic offer]
3. T2: No employer endorsement + feedback to employer
4. T3: Employer endorsement + no feedback to employer
5. T4: Employer endorsement + feedback to employer
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.