Mental Health, Teacher Stress and Student Achievement: Experimental Evidence from Pakistan

How to cite

Mehmood, Sultan; Naseer, Shaheen; Chen, Daniel. 2022. "Mental Health, Teacher Stress and Student Achievement: Experimental Evidence from Pakistan." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009121. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9121-1.4

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Sultan Mehmood* , Shaheen Naseer , Daniel Chen

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009121
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9121-1.4
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2022-02-15 – 2022-03-22
Countries
Pakistan (South Asia)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9121

Abstract

Is teacher stress holding back student achievement? Does stress transmit from teacher to students? How does psychological and pharmacological aid to teachers influence their mental health and students? We hope to answer these questions, by conducting a field experiment with one of the largest charter school networks in the world, the PEN Education Network of Pakistan. Using detailed data on teachers’ self-reported stress, life satisfaction, teachers stress hormonal concentrations in blood plasma, we explore whether and under which conditions do teacher stress is alleviated and whether this impacts student achievement. We randomize teachers into 6 treatment arms. The teachers are further cross-randomized into social signaling treatment using color-coded bracelets that aims to reduce stigma associated with mental health. In the first treatment group, we assign teachers in 4 weekly sessions with a psychologist practicing cognitive behavioral therapy. The second, third and fourth group is assigned a session with the psychiatrist with possibility to prescribe medicines where we subsidize the prescription medicines to varying degrees (0% vs 50% vs 100% subsidies of prescriptions). Finally, we randomly assign the teachers into 4 weekly sessions of mindfulness meditation of same length of time as the psychologist treatment.

Intervention

T1) Psychology Treatment: 4-week of weekly sessions with a psychologist administrating cognitive behavioral therapy (4 individual sessions).
T2) Psychiatrist with no subsidy of prescription medicines: 1 session with a psychiatrist who has an option to prescribe medicines (zero subsidy of medicine: 100% payment from teachers own pocket) - 1 individual session
T3) Psychiatrist with full subsidization of prescription medicines- 1 session with a psychiatrist prescribing medicines, with the prescribed medications provided for free (100% subsidization) - 1 individual session
T4) Psychiatrist with co-paying - 1 session with a psychiatrist prescribing medicines and providing those medications for 50% of total costs (co-paying) - 1 individual session
T5) 4 sessions each week mindfulness meditation for one month (equal to time spent for psychologist treatment). - 4 sessions.

T6) Placebo lectures (4 lectures) on macroeconomic facts, concepts and trends of equal length and frequency of meetings with psychologist and mindfulness meditation (4 sessions).

Each treatment arm, including the placebo, are further cross-randomized into social signaling treatment using color-coded bracelets that aimed to reduce stigma associated with mental health.

Experimental design

Our sample consists of 850 teachers with about 140 teachers per treatment arm and 25000 students across Punjab and Sindh provinces of Pakistan. We randomly assign teachers into the following 6 groups:

T1) Psychology Treatment: 4-week of weekly sessions with a psychologist administrating cognitive behavioral therapy.
T2) Psychiatrist with no subsidy of prescription medicines: 1 session with a psychiatrist who has an option to prescribe medicines (zero subsidy of medicine: 100% payment from teachers own pocket)
T3) Psychiatrist with full subsidization of prescription medicines- 1 session with a psychiatrist prescribing medicines, with the prescribed medications provided for free (100% subsidization).
T4) Psychiatrist with co-paying - 1 session with a psychiatrist prescribing medicines and providing those medications for 50% of total costs (co-paying)
T5) 4 sessions each week mindfulness meditation for one month (equal to time spent for psychologist treatment).
T6) Placebo lectures (4 lectures) on macroeconomic facts, concepts and trends of equal length and frequency of meetings with psychologist and mindfulness meditation.
The teachers are further cross-randomized into social signaling treatment using bracelets with message that aims to reduce stigma associated with mental health.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization by computer
Randomization unit
Individual teacher
Clusters
850 teachers
Observations
25000 students and 850 teachers.
Arms
About 4000 students and 150 teachers per treatment arm
Primary outcomes
Exact pre-registered primary outcome variables: 1) cortisol concentration in plasma, measured in micrograms per deciliter, using the Chemiluminescence Immunoassay (CLIA) technique 2) Teacher self-reported stress 3) Mathematics, Urdu, English test scores of students
Secondary outcomes
Exact pre-registered for heterogeniety anlaysis: (1) wrist bands public signaling the teacher goes to see a psychiatrist and (2) treatment impact on those that have higher pre-treatment self-reported stigma see a psychiatrist. Other outcomes that may be used for exploratory analysis but analyzed only if the data becomes available: 1) Teacher score on analytical creativity task 2) Student creative writing test scores 3) A measure of extent of mental health stigma perceived by the teacher, pre and post-treatment.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords