Can Workfare Programs Help Mitigate Negative Consequences of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Poor Households? Evidence from Randomized Controlled Trials in the DRC, Egypt, and Tunisia

How to cite

Mvukiyehe, Eric. 2022. "Can Workfare Programs Help Mitigate Negative Consequences of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Poor Households? Evidence from Randomized Controlled Trials in the DRC, Egypt, and Tunisia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009078. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9078-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Eric Mvukiyehe*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009078
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9078-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2015-05-01 – 2021-12-31
Countries
Congo (Democratic Republic of the) (Sub-Saharan Africa), Egypt (Meadle East and North Africa), Tunisia (Meadle East and North Africa)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9078

Abstract

The COVID-19 pandemic has had unimaginably tragic human costs and devastating negative effects on countries’ economies, triggering an unprecedented economic crisis worldwide and sinking the global economy into the deepest recession not seen in eight decades. Systematic studies documenting socioeconomic consequences from the pandemic, let alone effective strategies to mitigate these consequences, remain scarce. This study addresses this question head-on, leveraging two large and coordinated cluster randomized controlled trials (RCTs) carried out as part of the rollout of World Bank-funded public works programs in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), Egypt and Tunisia between 2015 and 2021 and at least one endline survey in each country during the COVID-19 pandemic. It provides systematic quantitative evidence on economic conditions as a result of the pandemic and ascertains the extent to which participation in workfare programs helped mitigate the negative socioeconomic consequences of the pandemic and quarantine measures to contain it. The primary outcomes of interest concern potential socioeconomic consequences of COVID-19 on households. The array of any such consequences is broad, but this study focuses on six broad outcome families: (i) exposure to COVID-19; (ii) consumption and food security; (iii) economic shocks (e.g., job loss or drop in productivity and earnings); (iv) coping mechanisms; (v) children’s health and schooling; and (vi) subjective/psychological well-being.

Intervention

As with PWPs in general, the project activities varied widely in terms of their location, infrastructure, and implementation modalities, but they all shared key common features and experimental design, which makes rigorous analysis possible. Specifically, the PWPs in our study provided temporary employment opportunities to poor and vulnerable individuals, such as the opportunity to work in the creation and maintenance of local infrastructure, in exchange for a wage. The provision of temporary employment opportunities provided recipients with a source of income to help smooth their income and consumption.

Moreover, the local infrastructure projects benefited not just the workers, but also the broader community indirectly from the upgraded infrastructures and presumably better access to services. For example, newly constructed roads in rural areas can help connect farmers to agricultural markets and thus provide them with an opportunity to sell their products. Further, all PWPs in the proposed research use community-based geographic targeting to reach poor regions.

Our studies are specifically designed to capture both the effects of the PWP infrastructure projects and the voluntary participation in such projects in exchange of wage.

Overall, program features presented in Table 1 are representative of the distribution of PWPs from other low- and-middle income countries (Subbarao et al., 2013), except for those that allow for yearly participation in public works activities like India.

Experimental design

We leverage experimental studies and data from three randomized control trials in the DRC, Egypt, and Tunisia. One site follows household/individual-level randomization (DRC rural), whereas the studies in Egypt and Tunisia follow two-stage cluster randomization. In the household level randomized designs, the opportunity to work in a public works program only varies at the household/individual level and hence generates only two groups of households of interest - treatment households and control households– where both belong to the treatment communities. This allows us to estimate only the net effects of the program including both the direct and spillover/general equilibrium effects of the program that would impact beneficiaries and non-beneficiaries alike. In the DRC study, household/individual-level randomization was carried out using a public lottery.

In contrast, in the two-stage cluster randomized design carried out in the Egypt and Tunisia study, the opportunity to work in a public works program is first randomized at the community level and then within treatment communities, at the household level. This generates three groups of households of interest - treatment households in treatment communities, control households in treatment communities, and control households in control communities. A key feature of the two-stage design is that it allows us to separately estimate the direct effect of the public works program from the indirect spillover effects/general equilibrium effects of the intervention.

Specifically, in the DRC, we targeted 121 villages in which randomization was carried out the household/individual-level only.
In Egypt, the main villages sample consists of an initial sample of 196 matched pairs of control and treatment villages constructed from a larger sample of 760 villages in which projects could be implemented, based the census poverty map within Egypt’s most deprived Governorates (Asyut, Sohag, Giza, Minya, Qena, Beni Suef, Fayoum, Aswan, and Luxor). Matched pairs were constructed based on a set of covariates coming from the poverty map, creating observationally similar pairs of villages coming from same district. One village in each pair was randomly assigned to treatment and the other to the control. Of these, projects could be implemented in 78 villages due to operational constraints, with 86 control villages. We ended up with an effective sample was 164 villages. In addition, there are 70 villages in which randomization was carried out at the individual level only, as SFD had already awarded contract to the NGOs before the design of the study, although before selection of beneficiaries.

In Tunisia, the study sample consisted of 80 communities, formally known as imadas—the lowest level administrative unit—in rural Jendouba Governorate (province), one of the poorest and underserved provinces in the country. Of these, 40 communities were randomly selected to receive the treatment condition and the remaining 40 communities to the control condition.

In both studies, while the construction of lists of eligible participants (and management of the projects) was done by an NGO in charge of project implementation in each village/community, randomization of potential participants in the project was carried out remotely by the research team using Stata.

Design details

Randomization method
In the DRC, randomization was carried out using a public lottery in the field whereas, in Egypt and Tunisia, both community/cluster-level and individual/household randomization was carried out remotely by the research team using Stata.
Randomization unit
Village-level and individual-level
Clusters
1--DRC: 121 2--Egypt: 186 clusters in matched pairs 3--Tunisia: 80
Observations
1--DRC: 125-135 clusters, though assignment to treatment was done at the individual level (i.e., randomly selected workers in all of these villages received the reatment.) 2--Egypt: 186 clusters in matched pairs (78 treatment villages and 86 control villages) 3--Tunisia: 40 treatment villages and 40 control villages
Arms
1--DRC: 121: about 2,000 participants 2--Egypt: 186 clusters in matched pairs (78 treatment villages and 86 control villages.): About 2,500 participants 3--Tunisia: 40 treatment villages and 40 control villages: half and half and about 2,500 participants
Primary outcomes
I. Exposure to COVID-19 (direct and/or indirect) II. Economic shocks due to COVID-19 (e.g., loss jobs, decreased hours/productivity or wages/earnings) III. Food security and general consumption IV. Shocks and coping strategies during COVID-19 V. Children’s health and schooling/disruptions during COVID-19 VI. Subjective well-being and cohabitation in COVID-19 VII. Shocks and coping mechanisms VIII. Access to basic services (health and education) IX. Women’s Empowerment (autonomy, agency and intimate partner violence)
Secondary outcomes
Combined both primary and secondary outcomes, as per the above.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords