Revealed-preference study of the impact of narratives and conceptual frames: evidence from a negative externality laboratory experiment

How to cite

Goff, Sandra; Ifcher, John. 2022. "Revealed-preference study of the impact of narratives and conceptual frames: evidence from a negative externality laboratory experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009063. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9063-2.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Sandra Goff* , John Ifcher

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0009063
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9063-2.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2022-04-09 – 2022-08-31
Countries
United States of America (California), United States of America (National)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/9063

Abstract

Our proposed work builds from Bartling, Weber, and Yao (2015) by using an RCT to examine choices in a laboratory market in which we vary the way a negative externality associated with a transaction is characterized. Like Bartling et al. (2015), we use a fictious product in a laboratory setting with real stakes and real impacts on a bystander. In the experiment by Bartling et al. (2015), consumers can choose between a socially responsible product and a product that produces a negative externality for a bystander. The authors find that people are willing to forgo personal benefit to choose a socially responsible product. Our protocol differs from Bartling et al. (2015) in some important ways. First, instead of choosing which of two products to sell, the seller can choose to sell a product that has an external cost for a bystander, or they can refuse to produce a good for sale. Similarly, buyers can choose to purchase the externality-producing good or refrain from making a purchase. This design simulates a context in which there is no socially responsible substitute on the market. Experimental conditions in the study vary the conceptual frame of the negative externality. We examine whether subjects’ willingness to sell and buy this “unfair” product is impacted by the conceptual frame.

Intervention

Experimental conditions in the study vary the conceptual frame of the negative externality. We examine whether subjects’ willingness to sell and buy this “unfair” product is impacted by the conceptual frame.

Experimental design

STUDY 1
Participants will engage in a laboratory market game with real stakes for themselves and a bystander. Sessions are randomly assigned to one of three experimental conditions - a control and two treatments. In the two treatments, the framing of the negative externality produced by the players is altered.

STUDY 2
Study 2 implements a similar design but using an online asynchronous market on Qualtrics.

Design details

Randomization method
STUDY 1: Assignment of conditions to sessions is done non-randomly to ensure even spread across days/times; participants sign up for days/times according to their schedule preferences; payment round is determined randomly by the computer STUDY 2: Randomization of condition assignment is performed using Qualtrics' built-in functions.
Randomization unit
STUDY 1 experimental sessions STUDY 2 individual
Clusters
STUDY 1 approximately 18 - will depend upon group size and interest at recruitment STUDY 2 Plan to recruit 2,158 participants
Observations
STUDY 1 As many as can be recruited - up to 600 students. STUDY 2 Plan to recruit 2,158 participants - each will make 2 decisions = 4,316 observations
Arms
STUDY 1 Approximately 200 depending upon scheduling. If sessions get out of balance due to cancellations, etc., we will err on the side of oversampling experimental sessions. STUDY 2 T1: 120 Sellers, 96 Buyers, 96 Bystanders T2: 55 Sellers, 44 Buyers, 44 Bystanders T3: 55 Sellers, 44 Buyers, 44 Bystanders T4: 120 Sellers, 96 Buyers, 96 Bystanders T5: 120 Sellers, 96 Buyers, 96 Bystanders T6: 120 Sellers, 96 Buyers, 96 Bystanders T7: 120 Sellers, 96 Buyers, 96 Bystanders T8: 120 Sellers, 96 Buyers, 96 Bystanders
Primary outcomes
STUDY 1: sell: dummy variable = 1 if seller decides to offer a product for sale buy: dummy variable = 1 if buyer decides to purchase a product price: price at which product was purchased STUDY 2: offer: whether the Seller offers a product for sale offer price: the price at which the Seller offers the product for sale buy: whether the Buyer chooses to buy a product wtp: the Buyer's willingness to pay belief_maxwtp: the Seller's beliefs about the Buyer's wtp

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords