Under pressure: the impact of women's mental load on labor productivity and occupational choices. Evidence from Kenya.
How to cite
Vitellozzi, Sveva; Cecchi, Francesco; Rapallini, Chiara. 2022. "Under pressure: the impact of women's mental load on labor productivity and occupational choices. Evidence from Kenya.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009021. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9021-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The labor productivity gap between men and women is a widespread phenomenon and seems to persist along the whole wage distribution. In developing countries, this gap is particularly pronounced both in urban and rural settings. Even though the literature has given increasing attention to this issue, it has partly neglected the psychological dimension that could contribute widening this gap. Under this perspective, women risk being more disadvantaged than men because of mental load, the management underlying household activities. This burden is mostly carried by women, and it may have harmful effects on their health, their labor productivity and, more broadly, their empowerment. Following the recent literature on scarcity, according to which poverty negatively impacts cognitive functions and economic outcomes, the aim of this study is to analyze the gender-differentiated impact of mental load on labor productivity controlling for attentional constraints as leading mechanism. To test for this hypothesis, we propose a lab-in-the-field-experiment where participants will be exposed to a scenario inducing thoughts about mental load, and then they will be asked to perform an effort task.
Intervention
We want to examine whether women's mental load, i.e., the management behind household activities, negatively affects cognitive abilities and labor productivity through a lab-in-the-field experiment. The treatment consists of priming in the mind of the participants thoughts related to mental load. They will then be asked to perform an effort task for 30 minutes during which they will have to divide black from red beans, and to complete as many Towers of Hanoi as possible with 4 and 5 disks. In the last slot, they will be asked to choose whether they rather perform the Tower of Hanoi with 5 disks or the beans again. This last information will be used to test whether mental load leads individuals to self-select into less cognitive-demanding tasks (i.e., sorting beans) because their mind is already overloaded by thoughts related to the management of the household activities. We will also test whether mental load leads individuals to make an income-maximizing choice based on information they have from the previous two rounds.
The choice of the two effort tasks is slightly gendered: while dividing black from red beans is a gendered task for women, and requires low cognitive skills, the Tower of Hanoi is slightly gendered towards men.
Experimental design
Participants in the treatment and in the control group will be exposed to the same activities but in different orders. Participants in the treatment group will be first exposed to the treatment before being asked to perform an effort task. After the effort task, they will be exposed to a Digit Span Task to measure their attention level, they will have to self-assess their own stress level, and they will finally answer basic socio-economic questions. Participants in the control group, on the other hand, will be asked to compile the socio-economic questionnaire first, and then to perform the effort task. After the effort task, they will be exposed to the Digit Time Span and they will have to self-assess their own stress level. They will also have to complete a simplified version of the Raven's matrixes. Finally, they will be exposed to part of the treatment.
The treatment consists of three parts: first, participants will have to compile a time use module under the form of time diaries; then they will be asked to recall their most pressing worries and thoughts related to the household; and finally they will have to link these thoughts and worries within the schedule of a typical workday. To do this last exercise, they will have to look first to a short video with role models (i.e., inhabitants of Kibera) talking about their worries and thoughts in relation to a normal weekday. The scope of the video is twofold: first, it should trigger thoughts related to mental load by having participants identify with the subjects in the video; second, it should help participants to better understand the nature of the exercise we are asking them to engage in.
The effort task will last 30 minutes. The 30 minutes will be divided into three-time slots of 10 minutes each. During the first two slots, participants will have to divide black from red beans and to complete as many Towers of Hanoi as possible with four disks. For the last time slot, participants will have to choose whether they would rather complete as many Towers of Hanoi as possible with 5 disks or divide black from red beans again.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.