Gender gaps in exam performance at the top
How to cite
Skarpeid, Ingvild Lindgren; Franco, Catalina. 2023. "Gender gaps in exam performance at the top." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0009016. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.9016-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The starting point for the current research project is to understand the why there is a gender gap at the top of the performance distribution for a high-stakes college entrance exam in Colombia. It has been previously documented that women’s academic performance declines when stakes are high (Cai et al., 2019) and that this has consequences for their admission to their preferred academic program (Jurajda & Münich, 2011). Some research has looked at gender differences in willingness to take risk and self-confidence to explain the gender gap (Riener & Wagner, 2018), and it has been documented in a number of studies that women are less willing to guess in exams and therefore leave more questions unanswered, resulting in lower test scores (Baldiga, 2014; Coffman & Klinowski, 2020). In this paper, we investigate whether differences in performance among these top performing females and men result from gender differences in their test-taking strategies. The current pre-analysis plan details the treatments proposed for a pilot which will be run before scaling up the intervention in spring 2022.
Intervention
In this pilot we study gender differences in test-taking strategies under pressure. We simulate a real-life situation of an important university entrance exam where the participant is either close to, or far away from a cutoff that can give her access to the institution academic program of her preference. The number of allowed mistakes resembles how far students are from a cutoff in a test. Being close to a cutoff means that any mistake is costly because students may just miss the cutoff to get access to their preferred academic option. Being far from a cutoff means that mistakes are less costly because it is unlikely that the outcome of the test changes whether they get access to their preferred academic option.
We will test the effect of this manipulation as well as testing for possible incentive concerns that must be considered before scaling up the experiment on a larger sample.
Experimental design
The main purpose of the pilot is to test an experimental simulation of being near or far from the cutoff. We create a setting where the student is close to a cutoff by manipulating the number of mistakes she can make before losing her experimental earnings. In the treatment where few mistakes are allowed or "close to the cutoff", every mistake is costly: one mistake might send the student from being just above to just below the cutoff and lose her experimental earnings. In the "far from the cutoff" treatment, many more mistakes are allowed. We also manipulate when in the test the students face a very hard question that they are likely to get wrong, to see whether test strategies are affected by when the student randomly faces a hard question in the examination, early or late in the test.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.