Impact of Behavioral Change Sessions on Attitudes Towards Work
How to cite
Kurdi, Sikandra; Yassa, Basma; Gilligan, Daniel; Palloni, Gio; Tabe, Martin. 2022. "Impact of Behavioral Change Sessions on Attitudes Towards Work." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008988. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8988-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Forsa is a new economic inclusion program offered by the government of the Arab Republic of Egypt. Forsa beneficiaries, primarily drawn from the pool of current beneficiaries of the Takaful cash transfer program, will receive training and support to either enter wage employment or to develop income from self-employment. The Forsa program design relies on the premise that for the eligible population of poor households with weak labor force attachment, a key determinant of program success involves changing aspirations and attitudes towards work. Eligible households for the new Forsa program are invited to a behavioral change session designed to inform them about the new program and motivate them to enroll. This study seeks to examine the short-term impacts this behavioral nudge on aspirations and attitudes towards work. The analysis is based on a simple randomization of households to two different groups, one that attends the 2–4-hour behavioral change session before data collection and the other that attends the session after data collection. In addition to simple comparisons of self-reported aspirations and attitudes, we will perform heterogeneity analyses to understand potential mechanisms. The study is embedded within the baseline data collection activities for a larger evaluation of the Forsa intervention "Expanding Opportunity: Testing asset grants and jobs programs for Egypt’s poor." (https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.7944-1.0).
Intervention
Building on the Takaful and Karama cash transfer program (TKP), Forsa is a new pilot economic inclusion program implemented by the Ministry of Social Solidarity of Egypt. Forsa will provide short-term support to unemployed working age members of poor households by linking them to wage employment opportunities or providing training and assets to support self-employment. Before the actual implementation of the various interventions, eligible households are invited to a behavioral change session to motivate them to enroll in the program. Based on uptake data from the earliest governorate for implementation (which not included in the areas used for this analysis), approximately 67% of invited households sent a member to attend the behavioral change session.
Eligible households are either current beneficiaries of the TKP cash transfer program or rejected applicants just above the PMT threshold used for targeting the Forsa program who also fulfill the following eligibility criteria:
• Have at least one member of working age (19 to 55 years).
• Have a household head without formal employment and, if present, a spouse also without formal employment.
• Own less than 0.5 feddan (0.52 acres) of agricultural land.
• Not be a participant in any other transfer or asset program of the Ministry of Social Solidarity or other local or international non-governmental organization (NGO).
• Own no more than four medium-sized livestock or one large animal.
• Own a house with no more than one floor.
• Have no access to remittance income from a household member working outside of Egypt.
The objective of the behavioral change sessions is both to introduce more details about the Forsa program and to emphasize the benefits of financial independence and economic empowerment relative to financial reliance and aid dependency. The messages of the behavioral change sessions fall under four main themes:
Introducing the culture of work -. Participants were refreshed on the importance of work for improving their family’s standard of living and breaking out of the cycle of poverty.
Insisting that the continuity of Takaful transfers is not guaranteed – Participants were reminded that eligibility to receive Takaful transfers will end at some point due to limitations in the state’s budget. This insistence is consistent with the TKP program system of requiring recertification every three years and ending transfers for beneficiaries who are not deemed eligible during the recertification.
Emotional and religious encouragement. The trainers emphasized to the participants that Forsa is an opportunity for them to break intergenerational poverty cycles and prevent the transfer of their current deprivation and misery to their children. The trainers also incorporated a religious, focusing on how all religions praise hard work and the pursuit of general social and economic improvement.
Examples of success. The sessions also highlighted successful examples of people from their local communities who were able to break out of the poverty cycle by directing their efforts into income-generating opportunities.
Additionally, attendees are made aware that their Takaful cash transfers will not be stopped upon registration for Forsa – they will be sustained for at least 6 months to allow for a smooth transition into self-reliance. At the end of the session, households were required to make a decision about joining Forsa.
The behavioral change sessions are separated by gender and age and attended by up to 40 participants. They were supposed to include a standard presentation with video messages lasting four hours, however, it is uncertain how precisely these standards were followed during implementation.
Experimental design
This study is embedded within the baseline data collection of a cluster randomized controlled trial to measure the impact of Forsa.
For this study, we randomized at the household level which households received an invitation to the behavioral change session prior to the baseline survey data collection in January-February 2022. The exact timing of the behavioral change sessions in each area depended on the pace of implementation and varied from June to December 2021. Households randomized into the control group for the behavioral change session will receive an invitation in March 2022.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.