Information provision, police beliefs and public trust: Experimental evidence from Colombia

How to cite

Tobon, Santiago; Perez-Vincent, Santiago; Norza, Ervyn. 2022. "Information provision, police beliefs and public trust: Experimental evidence from Colombia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008947. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8947-1.6

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Santiago Tobon* , Santiago Perez-Vincent , Ervyn Norza

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008947
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8947-1.6
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2022-03-21 – 2022-07-31
Countries
Colombia (Barranquilla, Bucaramanga, Cali, Cartagena, Medellin )
JEL codes
K42, H11, H56, N46, C93
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8947

Abstract

The National Police of Colombia wants to raise their public trust and legitimacy by following procedural justice protocols in citizen-police day-to-day interactions. In our context, procedural justice refers to the idea of fairness in police decisions and interactions with citizens. We partnered with the Police to test an information campaign with police patrols across five Colombian cities: Barranquilla, Bucaramanga, Cali, Cartagena and Medellín---the largest Colombian cities excluding the capital Bogotá. The experimental sample consists of 351 police quadrants---a police patrolling area akin to a police beat. We randomly assigned quadrants to: (i) intensified interactions with citizens plus procedural justice instructions; (ii) intensified interactions with citizens plus procedural justice instructions, with the addition of an information campaign on procedural justice values; or (iii) neither. To randomize quadrants into treatment arms, we stratified by city, poverty level, and baseline public trust. We will measure impacts on police beliefs and public trust. Because patrolling areas are relatively large, we collect data on one street block within the quadrant, and ask police patrols to target it as a "pilot" block. We randomly sampled "pilot" street blocks within quadrants.

Note: We updated the abstract after the intervention finished, but not as an ex-post change. The intervention evolved after we registered the PAP, and this is a more accurate description of what the intervention effectively was.

Intervention

We are testing two interventions: (i) intensified interactions with citizens plus procedural justice instructions; and (ii) intensified interactions with citizens plus procedural justice instructions, with the addition of an information campaign on procedural justice values. In our context, procedural justice refers to the idea of fairness in police decisions and interactions with citizens. Our units of analysis are police quadrants or patrolling areas, akin to police beats.

The first treatment arm consists of increasing police presence and the quality of interactions with citizens within the patrolling area. Police patrols will be instructed to intensify their presence and interactions, with specific instructions on the importance of police contact with citizens. Following the beginning of the intervention, patrols in this treatment arm will receive daily messages on procedural justice protocols, e.g., to be fair and to listen to citizens' complaints and questions.

The second treatment arm consists of exactly the same components as the first with the addition of an information campaign where police officers received daily reminders on the importance of procedural justice principles. These messages highlight, for instance, cordially greeting people before starting any dialogue or being empathetic with whoever they interact with.

Because patrolling areas are relatively large, we collect data on one street block within the quadrant, and ask police patrols to target it as a "pilot" block. We randomly sampled "pilot" street blocks within quadrants.

Note: We updated the intervention description after the intervention finished, but not as an ex-post change. The intervention evolved after we registered the PAP, and this is a more accurate description of what the intervention effectively was.

Experimental design

The study focuses on five Colombian cities: Barranquilla, Bucaramanga, Cali, Cartagena and Medellín---these are the largest Colombian cities excluding the capital Bogotá.

For our experimental sample, we randomly chose 351 quadrants out of the universe of police quadrants across the five cities---we excluded from the sampling frame only exceptional cases such as quadrants in a Caribbean island nearby Cartagena. From the experimental sample, quadrants will be assigned to each treatment arm using stratified randomization. Probability of assignment to each treatment arm is 33%.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was done in an office using a computer. We assigned treatment as follows: First, we stratified by city. Within each city, we stratified by terciles of poverty scores using census data. Within each tercile of poverty score, we ranked quadrants based on the baseline public trust measure. Within each triplet in the ranking, we randomized quadrants. Probability of treatment assignment is 33% for all treatment arms.
Randomization unit
Our units of analysis are police quadrants or patrolling areas, akin to police beats. These are discussed above.
Clusters
351 police quadrants.
Observations
About 2,100 surveys, 6 from each police quadrant. We will cluster observations by quadrant in our analysis.
Arms
~351/3 police quadrants assigned to intensified interactions with citizens ~351/3 police quadrants assigned to intensified interactions with citizens plus procedural justice instructions ~351/3 police quadrants assigned to control
Primary outcomes
We have three main outcomes: 1. Public trust in the police 2. Demand for policing services 3. Police beliefs
Secondary outcomes
Our secondary outcomes are: 1. A first stage measure of police activity 2. Four indices to better understand the mechanisms that change public trust in the police: procedural justice, perceived effectiveness, perceived accountability and transparency, and convergence of values
Sponsors
Name: Interamerican Development Bank Location: Washington, DC Url: https://www.iadb.org
Partners
Name: National Police of Colombia Partner_type: government Url: https://www.policia.gov.co

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords