Inflation Expectations and Investor Behavior

How to cite

Schnorpfeil, Philip; Hackethal, Andreas; Weber, Michael. 2022. "Inflation Expectations and Investor Behavior." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0008940. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8940-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Philip Schnorpfeil* , Andreas Hackethal , Michael Weber

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0008940
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.8940-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2022-02-09 – 2022-05-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D14, D83, D84, E31, E52, G11, G12, G41
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/8940

Abstract

We use a randomized control trial on a sample of German brokerage clients to study the effect of inflation beliefs on investment choices. We first elicit inflation-related beliefs, including estimates of asset returns in past inflationary periods. To shift beliefs about inflation and how to protect against it, three treatment groups then receive two sets of information: a first treatment arm receives information on the recent inflation surge in Germany, a second arm on asset returns during historical periods of high and increasing inflation, and a third one a combination of both. One control group receives no information. Following the information provision, we test for treatment effects on inflation beliefs, asset-return expectations, and hypothetical portfolio choices. Importantly, we also use bank data to test whether the treatments feed into actual portfolio and consumption choices. The latter serves to compare our treatment effects to the existing literature linking inflation beliefs to consumption decisions. Moreover, elicitation of a wide array of additional post-treatment beliefs on the household’s expected financial situation, overall economy, and corporate outcomes allows us to pinpoint underlying mechanisms.

We also plan to investigate the role of (prior) investor beliefs about how to protect against a surge in inflation, as elicited in the survey, using observational data. We test whether we find trading consistent with these inflation-hedging beliefs shortly after announcements of inflation increases in Germany in 2021. We use portfolio-transaction data on the brokerage clients that participate in the survey as well as on a broader set of brokerage clients. For survey participants, we can use their respective inflation-hedging beliefs; for the broader set of brokerage clients, we test for portfolio choices consistent with average inflation-hedging beliefs.

Experimental design

The survey begins by eliciting respondents’ recent motivations for portfolio trades (which can include changes in inflation). We then ask about perceptions of current inflation and expectations about future inflation. The pre-treatment section ends with estimations of unconditional historical asset returns, followed by historical asset returns in periods of increasing and high inflation. We interpret differences in the two return estimations as respondents’ beliefs about assets’ inflation-hedging properties. We elicit return estimates for the German stock market, German energy stocks, the US and Japanese stock markets, two- and ten-year German government bonds, a commodity index, gold, and private real estate.

Following the prior-beliefs section, we randomly allocate each respondent to one of four groups (with equal probability). The first group is a control group that is not shown any information. Group 2 receives information on the time series of inflation, on the possibility of a further increase in inflation, and on drivers of the recent increase in inflation. Group 3 receives actual returns of the German stock market, German energy stocks, the US and Japanese stock market, ten-year German government bonds, and gold in historical periods of increasing and high inflation. This treatment also includes a short summary statement on the past asset returns. Group 4 receives the information provided to group 2 and group 3.

All respondents then answer questions on their one-year- and five-year-ahead expectations about inflation, on hypothetical portfolio choices, on asset-return expectations, as well as on their expectations about risks to the German financial market, their financial situation, and economic development. We also elicit beliefs about consequences of inflation for corporate outcomes and various demographic characteristics. In the months following respondents’ survey completion, we use bank data to test for treatment effects on actual portfolio choices and savings and consumption decisions.

We hypothesize that (i) the inflation treatment increases concerns about inflation, leading respondents to adjust their asset-return expectations and portfolio choices so as to incorporate (prior) beliefs about assets’ inflation-hedging properties; (ii) the asset-return treatment induces expectations and portfolio choices that reflect the newly acquired information on the assets’ past performance during inflationary periods, at least for those concerned about inflation going forward; and (iii) the provision of information about inflation and past returns fosters effects similar to (ii), but more strongly so given increased worries about inflation.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is performed by a computer that assigns incoming subjects to different experimental arms
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
N/A
Observations
Around 4,000
Arms
Around 1,000
Primary outcomes
Survey: expectations of future inflation and future asset returns; hypothetical portfolio choices; beliefs about inflation being risk to financial markets over next 12 months Bank data: portfolio choices, savings rate
Secondary outcomes
Survey: belief about now being a good time to purchase durable goods Bank data: consumption decisions

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords